The second law of thermodynamics -- What does "from cold to hot" mean?

In summary: Above a certain temperature, a substance can no longer move. However, up until that point, it still has kinetic energy.
  • #1
QuasarBoy543298
32
2
in Clausius formulation, what does the phrase "from cold to hot" means?
I can understand it intuitively but in the language of the zero and first laws, we have not defined a temperature scale, only equivalence classes of systems that will be in equilibrium with each other (systems with the same value of the empirical we defined by a reference system).
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
It's clear enough, without going through the specifics, that 'from cold to hot' ordinarily means from a reservoir of lesser molecular motion to a reservoir of greater molecular motion. The Wikipedia Clausius Theorem article satisfactorily explains the specifics and the mathematics. The theorem is valid for the special case class of reversible processes.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
saar321412 said:
in Clausius formulation, what does the phrase "from cold to hot" means?
I can understand it intuitively but in the language of the zero and first laws, we have not defined a temperature scale, only equivalence classes of systems that will be in equilibrium with each other (systems with the same value of the empirical we defined by a reference system).
Relative temperature is essentially a measure of the direction that heat flows between two bodies in thermal contact i.e. heat flow always occurs from higher to lower temperature. So unless temperature has some other definition, a law that says that heat cannot flow from cold to hot is merely a tautology.

You need kinetic theory to explain what temperature is. Clausius made very important contributions to the development the kinetic theory of gases. By analysing the physics of motion of the molecules of gases, if one gas (A) is put into physical contact with another gas (B) and the average translational kinetic energy of A's molecules is greater that of the molecules of B, the average translational kinetic energy of B's molecules will increase and that of A will decrease. Clausius showed that no matter how a system is configured, one cannot have a result in which the only change to the system and surroundings is an increase of the translational kinetic energy of the molecules of A and a decrease in that of B.

So, if temperature is defined as the average translational kinetic energy of the molecules of a body that is in thermodynamic equilibrium, it fits with the original concept of temperature. And that is essentially how termpature is defined (although for reasons having to do with quantum mechanics, that definition requires refinement at temperatures close to absolute zero).

AM
 
  • #4
Andrew Mason said:
So unless temperature has some other definition, a law that says that heat cannot flow from cold to hot is merely a tautology.
Yes. "From Hot to Cold" means the direction that the Energy flows. The relationship is monotonic so it always flows the same way, whatever the temperatures or the numbers you have marked on the 'thermometer'.
I never wondered before why all the scales seem to have hot as a more positive number than cold. Is it really just arbitrary or is there something intuitive?
 
  • #5
sophiecentaur said:
I never wondered before why all the scales seem to have hot as a more positive number than cold. Is it really just arbitrary or is there something intuitive?
All non-zero absolute values are positive, and similarly, all motion, in any direction, can be regarded as positive compared to stillness. Although deceleration is negative compared to acceleration, and you could switch the signs, warmer than absolute zero would still mean more than zero molecular motion, so I think the positivity of temperatures, on an absolute scale, is neither just arbitrary nor merely intuitive, but based on empirically observable physical fact.
 
  • #6
wiki said:
From 1743, the Celsius scale is based on 0 °C for the freezing point of water and 100 °C for the boiling point of water at 1 atm pressure. Prior to 1743, the scale was also based on the boiling and melting points of water, but the values were reversed (i.e. the boiling point was at 0 degrees and the melting point was at 100 degrees). The 1743 scale reversal was proposed by Jean-Pierre Christin.
From:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celsius
 
  • Informative
Likes sophiecentaur
  • #7
sysprog said:
but based on empirically observable physical fact.
I think that is not an argument. You are justifying it post hoc, based on what we 'know' about the energy etc etc but thermometers were used before thermodynamics was understood.
However, @gmax137 (thank you) has quoted an example of a scale that's the other way round. :smile: This would particularly make sense for someone who was trying to refrigerate things because the colder the more difficult it becomes. Down in the 0K regions, it's particularly reasonable - like speeds just below c.
 
  • #8
sophicentaur said:
I think that is not an argument. You are justifying it post hoc, based on what we 'know' about the energy etc etc but thermometers were used before thermodynamics was understood.
The phrase 'slow as molasses in January' comes to mind. Speed has always been regarded as positive. That's true in any direction; for example, even when oarsmen row the boat in the direction opposite to that toward which they are facing, they still understand that the coxswain's more frequent stroke calls urge them to a positively greater speed. I think the recognition of the correlation of hotter to faster is ad hoc, not post hoc, and was commonly recognized long before any formalization of thermodynamics. Rubbing your hands together faster makes them hotter, running positively faster makes you positively warmer, and freezing something decreases its speed all the way to a stop.
 
Last edited:
  • #9
saar321412 said:
I can understand it intuitively but in the language of the zero and first laws, we have not defined a temperature scale

We have the Kelvin scale as an absolute scale only. It depends upon 2 temperatures - Absolute Zero at 0K and Triple Point of Water at 273.16K. These temperatures are absolute means, they happen at a particular temperature and pressure and they could not vary. Where as both melting and boiling point of water could vary with pressure.
For convenience sake, 1K difference is kept as 1C difference.
 

1. What is the second law of thermodynamics?

The second law of thermodynamics is a fundamental law in physics that states that in any spontaneous process, the total entropy (disorder) of a closed system will always increase or remain the same. This means that energy will always flow from hot to cold, and not the other way around.

2. What does "from cold to hot" mean in the second law of thermodynamics?

In the context of the second law of thermodynamics, "from cold to hot" means that heat will naturally flow from a colder object to a hotter object. This is because heat energy tends to spread out and equalize, resulting in a decrease in entropy. This principle is also known as the law of heat flow.

3. Why does heat always flow from hot to cold?

This is due to the fact that heat is a form of energy that naturally flows from a higher temperature to a lower temperature. This is because hot objects have more thermal energy, which causes their molecules to vibrate faster and collide with neighboring molecules, transferring heat energy to them. As a result, the overall temperature of the system will eventually equalize.

4. How does the second law of thermodynamics relate to everyday life?

The second law of thermodynamics has many practical applications in our daily lives. For example, it explains why ice cubes melt in a glass of water, why a cup of coffee left on a table will eventually cool down, and why it is more difficult to maintain a tidy room than to make a mess. It also has implications in fields such as engineering, biology, and environmental science.

5. Is it possible for heat to flow from cold to hot?

No, it is not possible for heat to flow from cold to hot in a closed system. This would violate the second law of thermodynamics, which states that the total entropy of a closed system can never decrease. However, it is possible for heat to be transferred from a colder object to a hotter object through external work, such as using a refrigerator or air conditioner. In these cases, the overall entropy of the system still increases.

Similar threads

Replies
20
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
15K
Replies
12
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
954
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
33
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
698
Replies
19
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
721
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
2
Views
721
Back
Top