Theory Question (1 Viewer)

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

I have a question dealing with acceleration. A car is on a frictionless ramp. The car is tied to a string that goes over a pulley and over the pulley there is a hanger. As the mass of the hanger increases should the acceleration of the car increase, decrease or stay the same. I thought it would remain the same since the hangar will accelerate at the same rate regardless of mass but results show otherwise. Thanks
 
Jacob87411 said:
I have a question dealing with acceleration. A car is on a frictionless ramp. The car is tied to a string that goes over a pulley and over the pulley there is a hanger. As the mass of the hanger increases should the acceleration of the car increase, decrease or stay the same. I thought it would remain the same since the hangar will accelerate at the same rate regardless of mass but results show otherwise. Thanks
Think about Newton's 2nd. The greater the mass on the hanger, the greater the force the Earth exerts on it. So a greater mass on the hanger should produce a greater force on the car (via the tension force). Thus the car accelerates faster.

-Dan
 

Doc Al

Mentor
44,642
966
Just to add to Dan's comments...

Jacob87411 said:
I thought it would remain the same since the hangar will accelerate at the same rate regardless of mass but results show otherwise.
I presume you are thinking that all objects have the same acceleration due to gravity regardless of mass. That's only true for objects in free fall, where the only force acting on them is gravity. But the hanger is not in free fall; gravity is not the only force acting on it--the string is also pulling it upwards.
 
Ok I have a question then when solving for the forces. First the forces of the hanger thats falling

The sum of the forces = T-mg=ma assuming down is negative, up is positive.

Sum of forces on the car being dragged in the Y direction is 0. Assuming this is frictionless is the sum of the forces just the force of tension pulling the car? Thanks
 

lightgrav

Homework Helper
1,248
30
yes.
If friction is zero, the only (horizontal) Force applied to the car is Tension.

Be sure to use the correct prepositions :
We add the Forces APPLIED TO the hanger by other things ... these
are called Forces ON the hanger BY the other things (not "of" the hanger).

The sum of the Force y-components on the car is zero ...
this is not quite the same as "sum of forces on the car ... is 0" .

By the way, why don't you call the coordinate along the string as "x"?
 
Well Im trying to derive the equation for acceleration to help explain why it increases and I am having problems doing that.

For the hanger:
Sum of Forces X = 0
Sum of Forces Y = T-mg=ma

Car:
Sum of forces X= T=ma
Sum of forces Y= 0

I know that much but im having issues deriving for the acceleration of the system to explain why mass increase results in acceleration increase
 

Doc Al

Mentor
44,642
966
Careful with those equations. I see several problems:
(1) You failed to distinguish between the two masses. Call them by different symbols: [itex]m_h[/itex] versus [itex]m_c[/itex].

(2) You failed to use a consistent sign convention and properly reflect the acceleration constraint. The constraint is that if the car has acceleration +a (up the ramp) then the hangar will have acceleration -a (down).

(3) You neglected the weight of the car.​

Try rewriting those equations with that in mind.
 

The Physics Forums Way

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top