# This strange triple integral

## Homework Statement

$${\int}{\int}{\int}ydV$$ over the region E, where E is bounded by x=0, y=0, z=0, and 2x+2y+z=4

n/a

## The Attempt at a Solution

Assuming that x and y must both be positive, which the boundary conditions seem to require, then the most either one can be is 2, so I have the bounds for x and y being from 0 to 2. Then for z, I guessed that 4-2x-2y is above the xy-plane(webMathematica's Three-Dimensional Visualizer doesn't make the picture any clearer), so the integration looks like so

$${\int_0^2}{\int_0^2}{\int_0^{4-2x-2y}}ydzdxdy$$, which becomes
$${\int_0^2}{\int_0^2}4y-2xy-2y^{2}dxdy$$ and then
$${\int_0^2}4y-4y^{2}dy$$ and finally integrating to
$$(2y^{2}-\frac{4}{3}y^{3})_{0}^{2}=-\frac{8}{3}$$, which puzzles me to no end. If I integrate above the xy-plane, I get a negative answer, and if I integrate below the xy-plane, I get a positive answer. Can somebody illuminate me on this nonsense?(I struggled to identify properly the bounds as may be clear to you)

Related Calculus and Beyond Homework Help News on Phys.org
tiny-tim
Homework Helper
hi planck42! Assuming that x and y must both be positive, which the boundary conditions seem to require, then the most either one can be is 2, so I have the bounds for x and y being from 0 to 2.
nooo you can't integrate both x and y from 0 to 2 …

that would include x = y = 2, and then your z integral would be from 0 to -4, giving you a negative contribution! hi planck42! nooo you can't integrate both x and y from 0 to 2 …

that would include x = y = 2, and then your z integral would be from 0 to -4, giving you a negative contribution! That makes sense; but now I feel even more lost.

tiny-tim
Homework Helper

for each fixed value of z, what does y go between? …

then for each fixed values of z and y, what does x go between? for each fixed value of z, what does y go between? …

then for each fixed values of z and y, what does x go between? I don't find it possible to answer both questions as there is only one boundary function.

Let's just suppose that x is going from 0 to 2(it should be equivalent to taking z from 0 to 4 if I do this right). Then for a fixed value of x, y should be $$\frac{4-z-2x}{2}$$. For a fixed x and y, z should be 4-2x-2y. The problem I have with this is that if I find z for fixed x, I get a z that depends on y, and if I find y for fixed x, then that y is still dependent on z, so there's no acceptable way to arrange the integrals. There must be something that I am missing.

tiny-tim
Homework Helper
hi planck42! just pick 'em off one at a time …

x from 0 to 2;

for fixed x, y from 0 to 2 - x;

for fixed x and y, z from … ? 0 to 4-2x-2y. But how did you get y being from 0 to 2-x for fixed x only?

tiny-tim
if you haven't fixed z, then it's for any value of z (and that includes z = 0, so the maximum for y is 2 - x) 