Triple integral with a curl

  • #1
367
13
In the image attached to this post, there is an equation on the top line and one on the bottom line. In the proof this image was taken from, they say this is a consequence of divergence theorem but I'm not quite understanding how it is. If anyone could explicitly explain the process to go from the top equation to the bottom, that would be greatly appreciated!
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2016-04-17 at 8.58.03 PM.png
    Screen Shot 2016-04-17 at 8.58.03 PM.png
    1.8 KB · Views: 456

Answers and Replies

  • #2
jasonRF
Science Advisor
Gold Member
1,489
551
Consider a vector field
[tex]
\mathbf{G} = \mathbf{c \times F}
[/tex]
where $$ \mathbf{c} $$ is an arbitrary constant vector. Apply the divergence theorem to $$\mathbf{G}$$ and I think you can reconstruct the result.

jason
 
  • #3
367
13
Consider a vector field
[tex]
\mathbf{G} = \mathbf{c \times F}
[/tex]
where $$ \mathbf{c} $$ is an arbitrary constant vector. Apply the divergence theorem to $$\mathbf{G}$$ and I think you can reconstruct the result.

jason

To clarify, would ##\mathbf{G}## replace the entire integrand in the top line of my image (including the curl) since that itself is a vector? I can see the general line of reasoning now, but how is it deduced that ##\nabla ' \times \mathbf {\frac{F(r')}{\big|{r-r'}\big|} } = \mathbf{G} = \mathbf{\hat{n}}' \times \mathbf {\frac{F(r')}{\big|{r-r'}\big|} }##? The curl of this vector should definitely be normal, to itself and I think I'm missing something fundamental here, but why is it necessarily normal to the surface, too?
 
Last edited:
  • #4
jasonRF
Science Advisor
Gold Member
1,489
551
I don't think my post was clear enough, so let me start over. Please ignore my previous post.

I am attempting to show you how to derive the general expression, for which you can insert you special case. Define a vector field [itex] \mathbf{P(r) = c \times Q(r) }[/itex]. Now write down the Divergence theorem
$$ \int \int \mathbf{P(r^\prime) \cdot \hat{n}^\prime} dS^\prime = \int \int \int \mathbf{\nabla^\prime \cdot P(r^\prime) dV^\prime } $$
You now need to simplify this. You should use the fact that [itex]\mathbf{c}[/itex] is a constant so that [itex]\mathbf{\nabla \times c=0}[/itex]
in order to simplify the expression. Then use standard vector algebra to arrange to get the [itex]\mathbf{c}[/itex] outside of both integrals. In the end you should find,
[tex]
\mathbf{c \cdot} \left[ \int \int \mathbf{Q(r^\prime) \times \hat{n}^\prime} dS^\prime + \int \int \int \mathbf{\nabla^\prime \times Q(r^\prime) }dV^\prime \right] = 0.
[/tex]
Since [itex]\mathbf{c}[/itex] is arbitrary we must have,
[tex]
\int \int \mathbf{\hat{n}^\prime \times Q(r^\prime)} dS^\prime = \int \int \int \mathbf{\nabla^\prime \times Q(r^\prime) }dV^\prime.
[/tex]
Does that make sense?

Jason
 
  • #5
367
13
I don't think my post was clear enough, so let me start over. Please ignore my previous post.

I am attempting to show you how to derive the general expression, for which you can insert you special case. Define a vector field [itex] \mathbf{P(r) = c \times Q(r) }[/itex]. Now write down the Divergence theorem
$$ \int \int \mathbf{P(r^\prime) \cdot \hat{n}^\prime} dS^\prime = \int \int \int \mathbf{\nabla^\prime \cdot P(r^\prime) dV^\prime } $$
You now need to simplify this. You should use the fact that [itex]\mathbf{c}[/itex] is a constant so that [itex]\mathbf{\nabla \times c=0}[/itex]
in order to simplify the expression. Then use standard vector algebra to arrange to get the [itex]\mathbf{c}[/itex] outside of both integrals. In the end you should find,
[tex]
\mathbf{c \cdot} \left[ \int \int \mathbf{Q(r^\prime) \times \hat{n}^\prime} dS^\prime + \int \int \int \mathbf{\nabla^\prime \times Q(r^\prime) }dV^\prime \right] = 0.
[/tex]
Since [itex]\mathbf{c}[/itex] is arbitrary we must have,
[tex]
\int \int \mathbf{\hat{n}^\prime \times Q(r^\prime)} dS^\prime = \int \int \int \mathbf{\nabla^\prime \times Q(r^\prime) }dV^\prime.
[/tex]
Does that make sense?

Jason

Thank you! That makes sense. :)
 

Related Threads on Triple integral with a curl

  • Last Post
Replies
0
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
1K
Top