True or false questions, Help!

  • Thread starter vroman
  • Start date
  • #1
vroman
9
0
For some reason, my answers to these questions are wrong, but I don't understand which ones and why, please help:

A)The speed of an accelerated body changes with time...False
B)THe velocity of an accelerated body changes with time...True
C)The words motion and acceleration can be used interchangeably...False
D)The position of a body in motion changes with time...False
E)The acceleration of a body with zero speed is zero...False
F)Motion and acceleration are not the same quantity...True
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
jdavel
617
1
vroman,

They're all right except one. That should help! :wink:
 
  • #3
vroman
9
0
Thanks, I figured it out!
 
  • #4
Curious3141
Homework Helper
2,858
88
vroman said:
For some reason, my answers to these questions are wrong, but I don't understand which ones and why, please help:

A)The speed of an accelerated body changes with time...False
B)THe velocity of an accelerated body changes with time...True
C)The words motion and acceleration can be used interchangeably...False
D)The position of a body in motion changes with time...False
E)The acceleration of a body with zero speed is zero...False
F)Motion and acceleration are not the same quantity...True

I'm sorry to be a stickler here, but which teacher would set such dumb, ambiguous questions for students ?
:grumpy:

My answers would be different for A and E :

A)The speed of an accelerated body changes with time... Not necessarily, but unable to determine if true or false from just this.

E)The acceleration of a body with zero speed is zero...Again, not necessarily, but unable to determine if true or false from just this

If the questions had included the critical word necessarily then they would be OK, but as they stand, I consider them inadequate and misleading.
 
  • #5
jdavel
617
1
Curious3141 said:
If the questions had included the critical word necessarily then they would be OK, but as they stand, I consider them inadequate and misleading.

When an answer of "true" or "false" is asked for, true means "always true" and "false" means "not always true".
 
  • #6
Pengwuino
Gold Member
5,124
17
jdavel said:
When an answer of "true" or "false" is asked for, true means "always true" and "false" means "not always true".

yah, "is" always denotes "true = always true"
 
  • #7
Curious3141
Homework Helper
2,858
88
jdavel said:
When an answer of "true" or "false" is asked for, true means "always true" and "false" means "not always true".

Hmmph, where did such an idiotic convention come from, and are the students taught to assume this by default ? No wonder most of them do so poorly at formal logic, they're not even taught the correct meanings of false and true ! :rofl:

It's all well and good to have this sort of convention for binary dichotomous choices. But I've seen more "complex" truth type questions, where there are choices for T, F, Insufficient info. If faced with a three pronged choice like that, I'd go for the third one, but it can be confusing if students have been taught all along that T = always, necessarily true and F = not always true, but not necessarily false either.
 
  • #8
jdavel
617
1
Curious,

Is the statement "Odd numbers are prime numbers" true, false, or is there "insufficient info" to say one way or the other?

I see no difference (logically) between that statment and the statement "The acceleration of a body with zero speed is zero."
 
  • #9
Curious3141
Homework Helper
2,858
88
jdavel said:
Curious,

Is the statement "Odd numbers are prime numbers" true, false, or is there "insufficient info" to say one way or the other?

I would consider the above statement to be ambiguous. I understand that the intended implication is that a general odd number is necessarily a prime (which of course is FALSE), but it is still possible for confusion with the alternative implication that certain specific odds can be prime (which is TRUE). I would be comfortable with this sort of statement in a conversation, where clarification can always be sought, but not in a textbook, and certainly not in a graded test.

Maybe it's just me, but I expect strict logical clarity in my test questions.
 

Suggested for: True or false questions, Help!

Replies
12
Views
598
Replies
6
Views
995
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
214
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
672
Replies
1
Views
260
Replies
12
Views
512
Replies
11
Views
546
Replies
25
Views
836
Replies
18
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
264
Top