Is America's Obsession with Feeling Good Undermining the Value of Truth?

  • Thread starter coberst
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of a feel-good society guided by the pleasure principle instead of the reality principle, and how America has become an "adolescent society" focused on self-absorption and feeling good rather than truth. It also touches on the influence of mass marketing and consumerism on politics and society, and the idea that success is the metric of truth. The conversation ends with a mention of the rise of fundamentalist evangelical churches and the idea that greed is a destructive force.
  • #1
coberst
306
0
Truth in a Feel-Good Society

A feel-good society is one guided more by the pleasure-principle than the reality-principle.

The pleasure principle is a concept originated by Sigmund Freud; it is a principle that continuously drives one to seek pleasure and to avoid pain. The reality-principle, in contrast, is one that defers pleasure when necessity demands it.

As one matures one becomes ruled more by the nature of reality, i.e. truth, than by the desire for pleasure. Freud informs us that the mature individual "no longer let's itself be governed by the pleasure principle, but obeys the reality principle, which also at bottom seeks to obtain pleasure, but pleasure which is assured through taking account of reality, even though it is pleasure postponed and diminished".

I claim that America is now functioning as an ‘adolescent society’; America has in the last several decades come to be guided more by self-absorption in feeling-good than by truth. I do not think that such was the case following WWII when Harry Truman faced reality eye-to-eye and America acted very much as a mature society accepting its responsibility to act as a leader seeking to help guide the world beyond the dangers that had grown up primarily because of the technologies developed to fight WWII.

America has learned the power of mass marketing and has used that power to revolutionize its politics. “Madison Avenue” has become the symbol of mass marketing expertise in America. Madison Avenue has developed an understanding of human behavior that has allowed it to successfully and consistently manipulate human desires in America.

Americans have grown to accept the identifying appellation of ‘consumer’ with apparently a large degree of eagerness. We have become happy consumers reacting to the manipulations by Madison Avenue; we think of consumerism as synonymous with being a good American. When asked what Americans could do to help in the war effort against terrorism Bush told us to go shopping and we accepted that as the patriotic thing to do.

Political operatives, having recognized the power of the Madison Avenue techniques, have successfully directed those techniques into the world of politics. And those political manipulations have turned America into a Feel-Good Society, which has little regard for the value of truth.

Focus Groups and framing issues have become the bread and butter of political campaigning. Politicians pander because that is the road to election. American citizens can’t handle the truth; therefore politicians do not tell them the truth.

Success is the metric of truth.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
coberst said:
Truth in a Feel-Good Society

A feel-good society is one guided more by the pleasure-principle than the reality-principle.

The pleasure principle is a concept originated by Sigmund Freud; it is a principle that continuously drives one to seek pleasure and to avoid pain. The reality-principle, in contrast, is one that defers pleasure when necessity demands it.

As one matures one becomes ruled more by the nature of reality, i.e. truth, than by the desire for pleasure. Freud informs us that the mature individual "no longer let's itself be governed by the pleasure principle, but obeys the reality principle, which also at bottom seeks to obtain pleasure, but pleasure which is assured through taking account of reality, even though it is pleasure postponed and diminished".

I claim that America is now functioning as an ‘adolescent society’; America has in the last several decades come to be guided more by self-absorption in feeling-good than by truth. I do not think that such was the case following WWII when Harry Truman faced reality eye-to-eye and America acted very much as a mature society accepting its responsibility to act as a leader seeking to help guide the world beyond the dangers that had grown up primarily because of the technologies developed to fight WWII.

America has learned the power of mass marketing and has used that power to revolutionize its politics. “Madison Avenue” has become the symbol of mass marketing expertise in America. Madison Avenue has developed an understanding of human behavior that has allowed it to successfully and consistently manipulate human desires in America.

Americans have grown to accept the identifying appellation of ‘consumer’ with apparently a large degree of eagerness. We have become happy consumers reacting to the manipulations by Madison Avenue; we think of consumerism as synonymous with being a good American. When asked what Americans could do to help in the war effort against terrorism Bush told us to go shopping and we accepted that as the patriotic thing to do.

Political operatives, having recognized the power of the Madison Avenue techniques, have successfully directed those techniques into the world of politics. And those political manipulations have turned America into a Feel-Good Society, which has little regard for the value of truth.

Focus Groups and framing issues have become the bread and butter of political campaigning. Politicians pander because that is the road to election. American citizens can’t handle the truth; therefore politicians do not tell them the truth.

Success is the metric of truth.

Correlates quite interestingly with the recent swelling of the ranks in evangelist fundamental christian churches. Though we are seeing quite the stir from many secular intellectual writers in return to the growing appreciation of comforting delusions.
 
  • #3
Look further than the internet, media and entertainment to blame. They are held by corporate giants and only want your money out of your pocket.

What really governs pleasure principle nowadays, involves spending a lot of money. Greed will destroy us all.
 
  • #4
I've always thought this was true, because people have always attacked me if I suggested that people might consider refraining from having children because the world is becoming overpopulated. It's like, they bury their heads in the sand, about everything from the environment to the national debt.
 

1. What is the concept of "Truth in a Feel-Good Society"?

The concept of "Truth in a Feel-Good Society" refers to the idea that in modern society, there is a tendency to prioritize feelings and emotions over facts and objective truths. This can lead to a distorted view of reality and a reluctance to accept uncomfortable truths.

2. How does this concept affect scientific research and findings?

This concept can have a significant impact on scientific research and findings as it can lead to a bias towards research that supports a certain narrative or makes people feel good, rather than focusing on objective evidence and data. It can also make it difficult for scientists to present and communicate their findings if they go against popular beliefs or emotions.

3. What are the potential consequences of a society that prioritizes feelings over truth?

The consequences of a society that prioritizes feelings over truth can include a lack of critical thinking skills, a decline in scientific progress, and an increase in misinformation and fake news. It can also lead to a divided society where individuals only seek information that confirms their own beliefs and opinions.

4. How can scientists navigate this societal trend and uphold the pursuit of truth?

Scientists can navigate this societal trend by remaining objective and following the scientific method in their research. It is essential for scientists to communicate their findings clearly and transparently, even if it may go against popular beliefs or emotions. Additionally, scientists can play a role in educating the public about the importance of critical thinking and seeking evidence-based information.

5. Is there a way to balance emotions and feelings with the pursuit of truth?

Yes, it is possible to balance emotions and feelings with the pursuit of truth. Emotions can play a powerful role in motivating people to seek the truth and can also help individuals connect with the information on a personal level. However, it is important to recognize when emotions may be clouding judgment and to always prioritize evidence and facts in the pursuit of truth.

Similar threads

Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
716
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • General Discussion
Replies
19
Views
5K
  • General Discussion
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • General Discussion
3
Replies
74
Views
9K
  • General Discussion
Replies
28
Views
10K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Back
Top