Ultimate Question

  • Thread starter jimmy p
  • Start date

jimmy p

Gold Member
347
30
Ok for all ya Dilbert fans out there...and i suppose anyone else who is interested, what are your personal answers to this ultimate question...here goes

If a moth fought a bee in a woollen jumpsuit who would win?

ps. the bee is wearing the jumpsuit

thanx
 

megashawn

Science Advisor
435
0
Well, my question is what exactly can a moth do? Nothing that I can think of. Go ahead and tie a gravel to the bee, and I'll still put odds in his favor.


Of course, I know nothing about Dilbert.
 

jimmy p

Gold Member
347
30
Well because the moth is bee is wearing the jumpsuit, the moth could attack it and chew the jumpsuit off (how i see it) but the if the bee stings, then both will die. its hard one and a pity that no1 wants to give input!
 
1,488
20
Ah, this question poses many problems. Such as how consticting is the woolen jumpsuit on the bee? How heavy is the jumpsuit? Because we know so little of the physics of bee flight it is hard to say how this addition may effect it's ability to fly.

Perhaps the weight may slow the bee to the same speed as a moth (I believe that bees normally fly faster than moths as the moths seem to have much higher wind resistance). However it may be so much additional weight that the bee can't fly at all, leaving it totally at the mercy of the ravenous wool-eating moth.

Now, a wise moth would just eat some of the jumpsuit, enough to get a good bite on the bee. However, moths do stupid things like fly into open flames, so I think we can safely rule out the possiblity of the moth doing anything wise.

Then we have the possiblity that the bee can sting through the woolen jumpsuit. If this is the case, the moth would have to rely on how constricted the movements are of the bee in the jumpsuit and its own ability to stay in front of the bee and away from it's stinger.

Perhaps the bee could coat the moth with honey and just stay clear of it long enough for a hungry bear to come and eat it.
 

dduardo

Staff Emeritus
1,894
3
The bee would win because he could call other bees to attack.

Bees swarm, moths don't.
 
1,488
20
Good thought, dduardo, however, much of bee communication is through posturing.

Perhaps the woolen jumpsuit would inhibit its motion to the point that a conversation between other bees may be like:

Bee Number 1 - "What's wrong with Buzz?"

Bee Number 2 - "I don't know. I think he wants us to steal second"
 

dduardo

Staff Emeritus
1,894
3
Originally posted by Artman
however, much of bee communication is through posturing.
I thought if a bee was in danger, it secreted something to call the attention of the other bees.
 
1,488
20
Originally posted by dduardo
I thought if a bee was in danger, it secreted something to call the attention of the other bees.
The secretion may get trapped in the wool of the jumpsuit, causing all the attacking bees to go after him. Unable to outrun the rest of the swarm he may get overrun and find himself getting stung repeatedly while trying desperately to convey the message "My God you idiots, Can't you see I'm a bee in a jumpsuit!"

Then again they may just go after the moth.
 

FZ+

1,550
2
It all depends on who has the thickest layer of blame-deflecting bureaucracy, and who paid Catbert the most to rig the match.

duh!
 
1,488
20
Originally posted by FZ+
It all depends on who has the thickest layer of blame-deflecting bureaucracy, and who paid Catbert the most to rig the match.

duh!
Catbert would probably favor the bee so he could sell the franchise rights for the company that makes the wool jumpsuits.
 

jimmy p

Gold Member
347
30
Well it is a conundrum indeed. Dont u think it is unfair for the bee to communicate with the colony, shouldnt it just be a 1 on 1match? The bee would probably have a more hefty wallop than the moth would anyway. Your suggestion may be good but dont forget catbert is an evil HR director so he would probably see who is winning (eg, the bee) and attach weights to slow him down or something. Dogbert would probably run a book on it to make money!
 

Related Threads for: Ultimate Question

Replies
416
Views
75K
  • Posted
Replies
23
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • Posted
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Posted
2
Replies
26
Views
7K
  • Posted
Replies
20
Views
3K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Hot Threads

Top