• Support PF! Buy your school textbooks, materials and every day products Here!

Vector spaces: norm and basis

  • Thread starter union68
  • Start date
  • #1
140
0
Hello. My question is: does the norm on a space depend on the choice of basis for that space?

Here's my line of reasoning:

If the set of vectors [tex]V = \left\{ v_1,v_2\right\}[/tex] is a basis for the 2-dimensional vector space [tex]X[/tex] and [tex]x \in X[/tex], then let

[tex] \left(x\right)_V = \left( c_1,c_2\right)[/tex]

denote the component vector of [tex]x[/tex] with respect to the basis [tex]V[/tex]. Now, let [tex]E[/tex] be the standard basis for [tex]X[/tex]; i.e.,

[tex]E = \left\{ \left(1,0\right),\left(0,1\right)\right\}[/tex]. Suppose

[tex]\left(v_1\right)_E = \left(2,1\right),[/tex]

and

[tex] \left(v_2\right)_E = \left(0,1\right)[/tex].

If [tex]\left(x\right)_E = \left(2,3\right)[/tex], then

[tex] \left(x\right)_V = \left(1,2\right)[/tex].

However, if we use the standard euclidean norm, the norm of vector [tex]\left(x\right)_V[/tex] is [tex]\sqrt{5}[/tex], whereas the norm of [tex]\left(x\right)_E[/tex] is [tex]\sqrt{13}[/tex].

Is this a correct analysis? It seems correct, since the euclidean norm depends on the components of the vector, and the components depend on the choice of basis...but something seems fishy.

Thanks!
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
236
0
You are correct--the value of the norm of a vector is basis-dependent. You can see it easily by noticing that [tex]\{(2,0),(0,2)\}[/tex] is also a basis for [tex]\mathbb{R}^2[/tex]. But no matter which basis you choose, the norm will still be a norm (satisfy all the conditions), so it doesn't matter.
 
  • #3
140
0
Fantastic. Thanks for the quick response. However, this leads me to more questions and some trouble:

With the above set [tex]V[/tex], we would have

[tex]\left(v_1\right)_V = \left(1,0\right)[/tex]

and

[tex]\left(v_2\right)_V = \left(0,1\right)[/tex],

correct? But, [tex]\left|\left(v_1\right)_V\right| = \left|\left(v_2\right)_V\right| = 1[/tex]. Furthermore, if we were to take the dot product as our inner product, and if it were dependent on the choice of basis also, then

[tex] \left< \left(v_1\right)_V,\left(v_2\right)_V\right> = 0[/tex].

This would mean that [tex]V[/tex] were an orthonormal basis with respect to (no suprise) itself. Ha. But, clearly, with reference to the standard basis, it isn't.

This makes me wonder, there has to be a common standard by which we judge all basis sets, otherwise we run into the problem above: that every basis can be turned into an orthonormal basis by considering the basis vectors as coordinate vectors with respect to themselves.

I have never seen this addressed before in any text, which is why I think I'm making a terrible mistake.
 
  • #4
236
0
every basis can be turned into an orthonormal basis by considering the basis vectors as coordinate vectors with respect to themselves.
If you do this, you'll just recover the standard basis every time, so it shouldn't be surprising. If I understand you correctly.
 
  • #5
140
0
If you do this, you'll just recover the standard basis every time, so it shouldn't be surprising. If I understand you correctly.
Yup, you understand me. This isn't a problem, though?

When we say that this or that that is/isn't an orthonormal basis, did we make that determination with respect to another basis? Because, as in my second post, every basis is an orthonormal basis with respect to itself.

For instance, it doesn't make any sense to me to say that

[tex]\left(x\right)_V = \left(1,2\right)[/tex],

but then to express the basis vectors as [tex]v_1 = \left(2,1\right)[/tex] and [tex]v_2 = \left(0,1\right)[/tex], where clearly those are component vectors with respect to the standard basis. Why would we not express [tex]v_1[/tex] and [tex]v_2[/tex] as component vectors with respect to themsevles, since that's the basis we're working in?
 

Related Threads for: Vector spaces: norm and basis

  • Last Post
Replies
16
Views
4K
Replies
0
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
728
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
303
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
980
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
673
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
4K
Top