- #1

- 27

- 0

My friend asked me a question that totally shocked me for a second.. here was the question...

"Is a voltage source turned off the same as a voltage source outputting 0V or near 0V?"

Then he asked me if we connected the two terminals of a voltage source to two points on an already ENERGIZED dc network... and the voltage output of the voltage source matches the exact same voltage that was in the network between the two points.. what is the effect? What is the effect when we change the voltage source (variable) to an output of 0.000001V and plug it between those two points? WHat is the effect of turning off the voltage source and plugging it between those two points?

My take on it is.... a voltage source turned on but outputting 0V should be considered a short, but turned off should be considered an open (I'm thinking back to a simple power supply with a bridge rectifier a cap and a zener.... u have the bridge to provide the open - yet in one direction current can go in one terminal of the power supply... through a set of diodes and come out the other end of the supply).

Also, when using the superposition theorem.. we TURN OFF the sources... and we replace an ideal voltage source with a short.........

Any thoughts on what my inquisitive friend was blabbering about?

"Is a voltage source turned off the same as a voltage source outputting 0V or near 0V?"

Then he asked me if we connected the two terminals of a voltage source to two points on an already ENERGIZED dc network... and the voltage output of the voltage source matches the exact same voltage that was in the network between the two points.. what is the effect? What is the effect when we change the voltage source (variable) to an output of 0.000001V and plug it between those two points? WHat is the effect of turning off the voltage source and plugging it between those two points?

My take on it is.... a voltage source turned on but outputting 0V should be considered a short, but turned off should be considered an open (I'm thinking back to a simple power supply with a bridge rectifier a cap and a zener.... u have the bridge to provide the open - yet in one direction current can go in one terminal of the power supply... through a set of diodes and come out the other end of the supply).

Also, when using the superposition theorem.. we TURN OFF the sources... and we replace an ideal voltage source with a short.........

Any thoughts on what my inquisitive friend was blabbering about?

Last edited: