- #1

- 1

- 0

So my question is: Do we know what gravity is? If so, what is it? If not, why don't we know, and what do we need to find out?

thank you in advance.

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

- Thread starter Backus
- Start date

- #1

- 1

- 0

So my question is: Do we know what gravity is? If so, what is it? If not, why don't we know, and what do we need to find out?

thank you in advance.

- #2

jtbell

Mentor

- 15,755

- 3,969

How would we know whether it's the "actual thing"?

- #3

Chronos

Science Advisor

Gold Member

- 11,408

- 742

Gravity is the negative reaction of space to the positive energy of matter.

- #4

- 1

- 0

The truth is that gravity is just a math model that that helps us predict stuff pretty well. Keep a close eye on cern...maybe we'll see some gravitons in our lifetime!

- #5

Chronos

Science Advisor

Gold Member

- 11,408

- 742

- #6

- 23

- 0

Gravity is the negative reaction of space to the positive energy of matter.

- #7

- 20

- 0

Unfortunately, we don't actually know for sure what causes gravity....

This is the real issue. We can describe what gravity is and what it does.

The reason it is there is the real mind blower.

- #8

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus

Science Advisor

- 21,156

- 4,996

This is the real issue. We can describe what gravity is and what it does.

The reason it is there is the real mind blower.

I don't see this as an issue at all. I don't even think it's possible to know whether or not we know what something "really is". If we can accurately predict what will happen using a model, does it matter if the model and underlying theory is "really true" or not? Even if we were able to predict things with perfect precision and accuracy, how could anyone know if we "really" knew what something is?

- #9

- 537

- 1

I don't see this as an issue at all. I don't even think it's possible to know whether or not we know what something "really is". If we can accurately predict what will happen using a model, does it matter if the model and underlying theory is "really true" or not? Even if we were able to predict things with perfect precision and accuracy, how could anyone know if we "really" knew what something is?

I think perhaps the problem is that we don't fully understand how a force can act at a distance. I think that understanding how gravity acts at a distance is something that will help further our understanding and help build better models.

- #10

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus

Science Advisor

- 21,156

- 4,996

I think perhaps the problem is that we don't fully understand how a force can act at a distance. I think that understanding how gravity acts at a distance is something that will help further our understanding and help build better models.

Care to elaborate on how we don't fully understand how a force acts at a distance?

- #11

- 537

- 1

Care to elaborate on how we don't fully understand how a force acts at a distance?

It was my understanding that the graviton is a theoretical particle?

- #12

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus

Science Advisor

- 21,156

- 4,996

It was my understanding that the graviton is a theoretical particle?

Yes, it has not been observed. I'm not sure if the standard model of particle physics even predicts its existence or not.

- #13

- 537

- 1

Yes, it has not been observed. I'm not sure if the standard model of particle physics even predicts its existence or not.

And so virtual particles are what mediate the fundamental forces, yes?

So it's my understanding that a lack of understanding and a lack of knowledge of the existence of the graviton means that the understanding of how the fundamental force of gravity acts at a distance is not complete.

We have models like Newtonian gravity and General Relativity which describe how it works on macroscopic things, but on a quantum level, we don't have a complete understanding. Or at least, that is *my* understanding. I've only got a rudimentary education of basic quantum mechanics principles.

- #14

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus

Science Advisor

- 21,156

- 4,996

And so virtual particles are what mediate the fundamental forces, yes?

Only in Quantum theories, not in GR.

So it's my understanding that a lack of understanding and a lack of knowledge of the existence of the graviton means that the understanding of how the fundamental force of gravity acts at a distance is not complete.

I think GR explains it pretty well.

We have models like Newtonian gravity and General Relativity which describe how it works on macroscopic things, but on a quantum level, we don't have a complete understanding. Or at least, that is *my* understanding. I've only got a rudimentary education of basic quantum mechanics principles.

Sure. But we don't know which one is correct for gravity, or rather which one is more correct and which way we should go to develop the next theory or resolve the discrepancies. Keep in mind that GR is the most accurate theory of gravity we have currently.

- #15

Chronos

Science Advisor

Gold Member

- 11,408

- 742

- #16

- 203

- 11

Drakkith said:I don't see this as an issue at all. I don't even think it's possible to know whether or not we know what something "really is". If we can accurately predict what will happen using a model, does it matter if the model and underlying theory is "really true" or not? Even if we were able to predict things with perfect precision and accuracy, how could anyone know if we "really" knew what something is?

I agree strongly. Physicists, when asked to explain what something

For gravity, physicists have available for description the language of mathematics, including an esoteric kind of geometry-cum-tensor yak which so far provides the best predictive and quantitative description of this particular mystery. Backus should realise what she/he IS: an evolution-conditioned, hard-wired, all -talking, -writing and -describing species of African ape (great to

- #17

- 483

- 3

So my question is: Do we know what gravity is? If so, what is it? If not, why don't we know, and what do we need to find out?

thank you in advance.

The "why" game, known to every four year old.

As a question. Whatever the answer, ask "why?" Repeat until the adult says "Because I said so."

The why game seldom gets beyond five answers. Two is fairly typical.

- #18

- 1

- 0

- #19

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus

Science Advisor

- 21,156

- 4,996

Absolutely not. Please refer to the rules about personal theories and speculation.

- #20

- 1

- 0

To me, general relativity implies that gravity is the fictitious force caused by the fact that we live in universe which is curved by the presence of energy.

As an example of this understanding, one should not say that light is bent by the sun, but rather light travels on a straight line (geodesic) which appears curved in the coordinate system we use to talk about events in the universe. Analogously, flights generally travel along mostly straight lines between cities but these appear curved on the maps we use.

The Earth is not pulling you towards it. As you hurdle forward in time along your timelike geodesic, the distance between your geodesic and the Earth's geodesic is shrinking because of the spacetime curvature. You feel a force because you push against the Earth so that you maintain a constant distance from its center.

- #21

- 3

- 0

When this extra dimension shrinks, you get the gravity effect on the space time (i.e. space time is pulled together). When the extra dimension expands then space/time stretches. The effect on space and time by gravity and anti-gravity (dark matter) is indirect. In the example of a bolloon (the surface is space / time, the inside is gravity's dimension) if the air is added inside the balloon, the volume (gravity dimension) expands and space time stretches (dark energy), when air is removed the gravity dimension contracts and the surface of the bolloon tightens (gravity).

Just my thought is that gravity is the dimension that comes after the 3rd and that time lives in either the 1st dimension or a dimension that comes before the 1st dimension.

This is the real issue. We can describe what gravity is and what it does.

The reason it is there is the real mind blower.

- #22

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus

Science Advisor

- 21,156

- 4,996

Share: