What's the reason?

  • Thread starter Rainbow
  • Start date
  • #1
62
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

THE THEORY OF GENERAL RELATIVITY states that the gravitation is due to the fact that the heavenly bodies create a sort of dent in the spacetime fabric.

Now,
WHAT IS THE REASON THAT THE HEAVENLY BODIES CREATE SUCH KIND OF A DENT?

Let us for example take an elastic sheet and place metal ball on it. The ball will make a depression in the elastic sheet.

But, the ball creates that dent because something (i.e. the gravity of the earth) is pulling it and forcing it to create such kind of dent.

So, I repeat my question-
What is the reason that the heavenly bodies (like stars, planets, etc) create such kind of a dent in the spacetime fabric?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
1,525
10
The ball will also create a dent if the fabric is accelerated - for example, consider a 1 meter square sheet of spacetime fabric in free space and a queball located at the center - now grab the four corners and accelerate the fabric - the inertia of the queball will deform the fabric. You don't need gravity to explain gravity. If you consider the Hubble sphere as having a radial expansion c, then the Hubble volume is accelerating - and the amount of acceleration is consistent with the gravitational constant - which incidentally has units of volumetric acceleration per unit mass.

But one shouldn't take the analogy too far - the idea of a stretching spacetime fabric is metaphorical
 
Last edited:
  • #3
DrChinese
Science Advisor
Gold Member
7,273
1,085
Rainbow said:
WHAT IS THE REASON THAT THE HEAVENLY BODIES CREATE SUCH KIND OF A DENT?

...

But, the ball creates that dent because something (i.e. the gravity of the earth) is pulling it and forcing it to create such kind of dent.

So, I repeat my question-
What is the reason that the heavenly bodies (like stars, planets, etc) create such kind of a dent in the spacetime fabric?
Good question, I think we'd all like to know the answer to that. I doubt we ever will though. By definition: if a theory is fundamental, there is no further explanation possible. Only if relativity is ultimately shown to be part of an even more fundamental theory will it be superceded.

Even with your description of the ball and the dent caused by gravity, nothing is answered - because you think it is a "reasonable" explanation not requiring further elucidation. But any theory of gravity comes back to exactly the same question: Why?
 
  • #4
mathman
Science Advisor
7,798
430
It is questions like this that lead to people advocating "intelligent design". That is the catchall answer to any question which science is unable to answer (at this moment).
 
  • #5
EnumaElish
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2,304
124
See this thread generally, and posts #4 ff specifically.
 

Related Threads on What's the reason?

Replies
1
Views
999
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
41
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
1K
Top