Why cant we choose?

  • B
  • Thread starter BenAS
  • Start date
  • #1
40
9
This I'd guess is a simple question for this forum. I'm just a middle age dude who never went to school and have taken an interest in physics, just trying learn how it works.

The question is, suppose you have an electron with a spin in a superposition of both up spin and down spin. It is my understanding that you are 'not allowed' to choose which spin the electron ends up with. You can only have the electron interact with something at which time 'it' chooses which spin it gets somehow. Why can't we choose?

Maybe just direct me to some material on the subject.

Thanks
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
631
132
This I'd guess is a simple question for this forum. I'm just a middle age dude who never went to school and have taken an interest in physics, just trying learn how it works.

The question is, suppose you have an electron with a spin in a superposition of both up spin and down spin. It is my understanding that you are 'not allowed' to choose which spin the electron ends up with. You can only have the electron interact with something at which time 'it' chooses which spin it gets somehow. Why can't we choose?

Maybe just direct me to some material on the subject.

Thanks
You can choose to find the spin in the horizontal direction with the Stern/Gerlach apparatus arranged properly. But you are correct that you can't choose to make it up or down with a measurement.
Fish around on line about quantum measurement.
 
  • #3
3,379
944
Why can't we choose?
Is there any reason why we should expect to have a choice?
 
  • #4
631
132
Is there any reason why we should expect to have a choice?
There is if one selects a measurement operator with an eigenstate which equals the state to be measured.
 
  • #5
3,379
944
Behaviour of quantum objects is essentially statistical though.
If the observer could choose the desired observation then the whole of QM theory crashes and burns.
We would need to replace it with a theory of how minds affect matter.
That would be very unpopular with a lot of people.
 
  • #6
Vanadium 50
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
2019 Award
25,401
8,589
It's going to be 90 degrees out today. Why can't I choose to make it 70 instead?
 
  • Like
Likes DrewD and bhobba
  • #7
DrChinese
Science Advisor
Gold Member
7,361
1,151
It's going to be 90 degrees out today. Why can't I choose to make it 70 instead?
Actually, I did. A short trip to San Diego did the trick. Although it is a bit overcast.

:smile:
 
  • Like
Likes Demystifier and DrewD
  • #8
297
522
To be quite honest, this answer is also possible: we can't choose because we are not the main players of the quantum game. Some Main Players might well be choosing the outcome, somehow maintaining the Born rule as a rule of the Game, in order to hide themselves.
 
  • #9
DrChinese
Science Advisor
Gold Member
7,361
1,151
To be quite honest, this answer is also possible: we can't choose because we are not the main players of the quantum game. Some Main Players might well be choosing the outcome, somehow maintaining the Born rule as a rule of the Game, in order to hide themselves.
Perhaps they are magical leprechauns. :smile:

A similar thing is often said about Bell's Theorem - that there are pre-existing conditions that make Bell's Theorem appear to be violated - when it really isn't. The same, of course, could be said about ANY physical evidence we obtain. I.e. that it is somehow tainted and not representative of what really occurs.
 
  • #10
18
0
This I'd guess is a simple question for this forum. I'm just a middle age dude who never went to school and have taken an interest in physics, just trying learn how it works.

The question is, suppose you have an electron with a spin in a superposition of both up spin and down spin. It is my understanding that you are 'not allowed' to choose which spin the electron ends up with. You can only have the electron interact with something at which time 'it' chooses which spin it gets somehow. Why can't we choose?

Maybe just direct me to some material on the subject.

Thanks
There you go . http://www.ams.org/notices/200902/r...AQFjAB&usg=AFQjCNE7L-k87yWE32ru0rDjkLOdg12LRQ

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_will_theorem
 

Related Threads on Why cant we choose?

Replies
2
Views
942
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
0
Views
236
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
68
Replies
18
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
31
Views
6K
Top