Why I am sinner ?

  • Thread starter Saint
  • Start date
402
0


In my life, I did wrong, as well as good.
So far, I am not as bad as a criminal who breaks the law, commit killing, robbing and other felony.

But the bible condemns that I am Sinner, and the good that i did seems have no value to neutralise my wrong, even for a few percent!

Is that Just/Fair ?

 

Zero

Originally posted by Saint


In my life, I did wrong, as well as good.
So far, I am not as bad as a criminal who breaks the law, commit killing, robbing and other felony.

But the bible condemns that I am Sinner, and the good that i did seems have no value to neutralise my wrong, even for a few percent!

Is that Just/Fair ?

It is the trick to brainwashing you, to start out by making you feel worthless. That makes it easier to force you to accept anything you are told.
 

FZ+

1,550
2
Depends on your interpretation of the Bible.

My Reverse Pascal's Wager: Seriously, just live life as you feel it should be lived, without regrrets. If God is good, then He will forgive you. If God isn't, then you are screwed anyway.
 
462
0
Originally posted by Saint
Is that Just/Fair ?

For most people, no, but we're making an exception in your case. :smile:
 

Hurkyl

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,845
17
It certainly is fair.

Note to Zero: your atheistic bigotry consistently blinds you to the possibility that any religous idea can have merit in the secular world. For example, note that in our justice system you can't, pardon the expression, get away with murder just because you did a few good deeds.


In our mortal justice system, you do bad and you get punished. God, however, delays the punishment, giving you a chance to correct your behavior and seek forgiveness for your mistakes. You need to strive to be an all around good person, not to do enough good things to neutralize your bad.
 

FZ+

1,550
2
I think the problem isn't that but rather there is eternal punishment for a system of laws that you may not even know, and the rather dare I say it, materialist idea of two wrongs make a right inherent in the idea of punishment. Why should moral action be motivated by fear?
 

Zero

The whole thing is nonsense...a supposedly perfect creator created a seriously flawed creation, and then blames the creation. Like I said, it is a scam, perpetuated by people racked with self-loathing, and promoted by those who want to keep the sheep in line.
 

Phobos

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
1,927
6
Originally posted by Hurkyl
It certainly is fair.
I fail to see how eternal damnation* is fair for any sin or combination of sins. The punishment is out of proportion to the crime.

* I suppose we would need to define this though since it means different things to different religions.
 

Hurkyl

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,845
17
I was referring specifically to the topic of whether or not it was fair that one's good actions don't "neutralize" one's bad actions. Other topics are, well, other topics. :smile:



But since the thread has already been hijacked...

Why should moral action be motivated by fear?
Why do you think it (always) is? Some people act morally because it's the "right" thing to do, and in a perfect world so would all people.

Anyways, even if you don't believe religion, such a concept certainly has societal value because it discourages illegal behaviour that would otherwise go unnoticed by the justice system.


I fail to see how eternal damnation* is fair for any sin or combination of sins. The punishment is out of proportion to the crime.
Is it? The crime isn't merely the sins committed, but one's unwillingness to act rightously. Forgivness for your sins is easy to get, at least in Christianity.
 

Zero

Good deeds don't matter...sucking up to the Man is what counts. All you have to do is give up your dignity and humanity, and you are just fine!!
 

Hurkyl

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,845
17
All this talk about dignity coming from someone using a bloody face for an avatar...

Anyways, do you enjoy beating strawmen?
 

Zero

Originally posted by Hurkyl
All this talk about dignity coming from someone using a bloody face for an avatar...

Anyways, do you enjoy beating strawmen?
No, I enjoy beating people...with sticks....



What does that have to do with anything? Can I help it if I find all the Christian 'sinner' and 'forgiveness' thing to be similar to Wayne and Garth bowing and whining 'We're not worthy! We're not worthy!'?
 

Hurkyl

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,845
17
As I said, you're beating strawmen.
 
402
0
I admit that i am sinner. Ok, i can agree that the sin i committed deserves punishment, but is that justful to be Eternal Torment?
How about the good I did, where is the rewards? Why not Eternal Reward too?
 

Zero

Originally posted by Hurkyl
As I said, you're beating strawmen.
Then show me the argument I should be hitting, if you would be so kind.
 

FZ+

1,550
2
Why do you think it (always) is? Some people act morally because it's the "right" thing to do, and in a perfect world so would all people.
I am commenting that the existence of a heaven/hell, and a retributive style of justice (ie. eye for an eye) is somewhat incongruous with the more modern new-testament image as God being (a) fair, (b) fundamentally good, (c) desiring of free will.
 

Hurkyl

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,845
17
Then show me the argument I should be hitting, if you would be so kind.
Something relating to the poster's topic would be nice, discussing the idea that good acts should "neutralize" bad acts. Even if you can't bring yourself to speak within a religous context, it's still an interesting question for secular morality / justice, and responding along those lines would certainly be better than slander. When is slander ever an appropriate response anyways?
 
Last edited:

Hurkyl

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,845
17
I admit that i am sinner. Ok, i can agree that the sin i committed deserves punishment, but is that justful to be Eternal Torment?
How about the good I did, where is the rewards? Why not Eternal Reward too?
If you're sorry you sinned and ask God for forgiveness, you do get Eternal Reward.
 

Zero

Originally posted by Hurkyl
Something relating to the poster's topic would be nice, discussing the idea that good acts should "neutralize" bad acts. Even if you can't bring yourself to speak within a religous context, it's still an interesting question for secular morality / justice, and responding along those lines would certainly be better than slander. When is slander ever an appropriate response anyways?
You should point out the slander as well...unless I am slandering a mythological figure, in which case I invite it to appear in court to sue me...

The Christian viewpoint starts with the premise that people are loathsome and worthless. You start out negative, and nothing you do can change it. Plus, also according to Christianity, you are culpable for the actions of your parents. Such a standpoint is ethically reprehensible, and cannot be defended by any stretch of theology or logic that I have come across.

But, of course, you can get out of it by grovelling to the very creator who created you to be worthless and loathsome to begin with. Kissing butt isn't a great basis for ethical judgment either.
 

Hurkyl

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
14,845
17
Yay, again with the off topic strawman beating.
 

Zero

Originally posted by Hurkyl
Yay, again with the off topic strawman beating.
LOL, is it really? You could try facing what I say, instead of posting 'strawman' and leaving it at that. Where is my strawman, and what would be the correct 'man' to attack?
 
73
0
Originally posted by Saint


In my life, I did wrong, as well as good.
So far, I am not as bad as a criminal who breaks the law, commit killing, robbing and other felony.

But the bible condemns that I am Sinner, and the good that i did seems have no value to neutralise my wrong, even for a few percent!

Is that Just/Fair ?

The Bible message is that God does indeed look at the good you do and take it into consideration: "For God is not unjust to forget your work" - Hebrews 6:10
 

Zero

Re: Re: Why I am sinner ?

Originally posted by Laser Eyes
The Bible message is that God does indeed look at the good you do and take it into consideration: "For God is not unjust to forget your work" - Hebrews 6:10
Good answer!! Not alot of Christians think that means anything, but good answer!
 
402
0
Re: Re: Re: Why I am sinner ?

Originally posted by Zero
Good answer!! Not alot of Christians think that means anything, but good answer!
Zero, you misunderstood!
That bible verse only refers to the good done by christians for the sake of Christ, excluding whatever compatible good done by unbelievers.
 
73
0
Zero, you misunderstood!
That bible verse only refers to the good done by christians for the sake of Christ, excluding whatever compatible good done by unbelievers.
It is not really limited to work done by Christians excluding good things done by unbelievers. Here is the verse in full:

"For God is not unjust to forget your work and labor of love which you have shown toward his name, in that you have ministered to the saints, and do minister." - Hebrews 6:10

You have to remember that the Bible often speaks in illustrations and general principles that you have to take and apply to other situations. The point is that God sees all things that happen on earth and he remembers them. He sees the bad things that we do and the good things that we do, not just Christians but all people. There are many sciptures which indicate this. If you don't think the verse above shows that God takes the good things people do into account try these:

"The eyes of the Lord are in every place, keeping watch on the evil and the good." - Proverbs 15:3

"For God will bring every work into judgment, including every secret thing, whether good or evil." - Ecclesiastes 12:14

"And there is no creature hidden from his sight, but all things are naked and open to the eyes of him to whom we must give account." - Hebrews 4:13
 

Related Threads for: Why I am sinner ?

Replies
1
Views
359
  • Posted
2 3 4
Replies
78
Views
28K
Replies
1
Views
370
Replies
2
Views
635
  • Posted
2
Replies
48
Views
6K
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • Posted
2
Replies
30
Views
3K
  • Posted
Replies
20
Views
2K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Hot Threads

Top