Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

News William Blum

  1. Apr 15, 2004 #1
    Greetings gentle readers,

    Ever heard of William Blum? He's a writer who has taken upon himself the task of showing the USA public exactly what their government does in their name. In aid of this, he lives near the Library of Congress, so as to spend his days in there gathering evidence - declassified documents and such. Pretty much everything he writes is sourced directly from the LOC. Many of his essays are copied and carried at many websites. One such, outlining USA support of dictators, or activities in overthrowing governments and such, can be found at: http://www.thirdworldtraveler.com/Blum/US_Interventions_WBlumZ.html

    http://www.thirdworldtraveler.com/Blum/Anti_Empire_Report_Iraq.html [Broken]
    Last edited by a moderator: May 1, 2017
  2. jcsd
  3. Apr 15, 2004 #2
    I read one of his essays while researching COINTELPRO. If anyone is interested in COINTELPRO, this website is by far the best resources on the web and one of the best resources in general.
  4. Apr 15, 2004 #3
    Another interesting essay by a former CIA chap: http://www.heart7.net/ciawar.html
  5. Apr 15, 2004 #4
    That quote is misleading. The US has supported (i.e. helped to come to power) governments who have done horrible things to their own people. In many cases CIA intervention was not great - too often people give the CIA WAY too much credit. Let's not go from admiting the CIA has acted in unethical ways to giving the CIA full responsibility (again, in many cases, even much responsibility) for atrocities commited by others.
  6. Apr 15, 2004 #5
    I bought his book Killing Hope, and he's clearly well informed, and he's also clearly very anti-USA/pro communist and fills his books with alot of great information, and leaves out alot of other stuff. He makes it seem like everything the USA's done is pure evil, and that the (mostly) Communist/Socialist dictators they've toppled weren't bad people at all. He clearly implies, or perhaps even states, that Fidel Castro is feared by America because he's turned Cuba into a prime example of what a Communist nation can be.
  7. Apr 15, 2004 #6
    Then the book is full of bias BS. The Soviet Union had operations going in many of the same countries as the US. In the Cold War no one was the good guy, but the US was the better and denying that is ignorant.
  8. Apr 15, 2004 #7
    Actually, that's a common mistake among message board people. William Blum is not anti-USA. He's very patriotic. He is, however, against the abuses of power he sees in the USA government. I know it's difficult for many, but you really must try to separate "USA" and "government". They are not the same thing.
  9. Apr 15, 2004 #8
    On what do you base this "good guys/bad guys", and "USA is best" assertion?
  10. Apr 15, 2004 #9
    Further details of the incident can be seen on the documentary "The Panama Deception": https://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/...f=sr_1_2/103-1201841-9005452?v=glance&s=video
  11. Apr 15, 2004 #10
    If you notice I claim that the Cold War cannot be simplified into a fight of "good guys/bad guys" - there were moral wrongs commited by both sides. I do not claim that the US is the "best" - I only claim that the US was better than the Soviet Union. The atrocities of the Soviet Union make CIA covert operations seem like elementary school games. I have no problem with claiming that the US was on the right side of the Cold War. People like you should realize that saying the US was on the "right side" doesn't excuse many of the US government's actions in the Cold War - don't take me for an apologizer for wrongs commited by the US government.

    I don't think that Blum is anti-US, but I do feel he is often blinded by his mission to "reveal" the injustices commited by the US. Blum has the same problem as Chomsky - simplifying world events out of anger towards the betrayal of American principles by the American government. Often times Blum gives the CIA and FBI too much credit. This is due to his own bias and the bias of his sources. For instance, in COINTELPRO (a horrible FBI program with many injustices) agent memos, naturally, overstate the importance of the operations in outcomes (the same is true for the CIA). Blum and others, strangely, often take FBI and CIA memos at face value - which can't and shouldn't be done. Blum, Chomsky, and co. also tend to evalute actions performed the the US government without putting them in context. This type of historical analysis is too prevalent in left academia today.
    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 15, 2004
  12. Apr 15, 2004 #11
    Can you please explain this view?

    I actually agree, they are on a mission. However, Blum's personal agenda does not in any way change the facts he pulls out of the Library of Congress. This is why Blum in particular is useful. Everything he asserts can be checked by others.
  13. Apr 15, 2004 #12
    Blum does has his facts right but he does not critically evaluate his facts. See my statements about the bias of CIA/FBI memos. My point is that he often overstates the importance of CIA and FBI actions in the overall outcomes - he often presents events as outcomes of CIA and FBI operations (CIA and FBI memos often do this as well) which often isn't accurate.

    On the Soviet Union, come on. Lenin and Stalin's atrocities are well known. The occupation of Eastern block countries was incredibly brutal. I'll look for some links, but you can't honestly believe that the Soviet Union didn't committ more atrocites than the US. Also, Soviet atrocities were generally Soviet actions - not covert operations (support, disinformation, etc) like those of CIA (not that the US didn't directly and immorally kill thousands - Vietnam anyone?). I don't know what is so surprising about me being highly anti-Communist and leftist. There used to be a lot of us (before I was born mostly)...
  14. Apr 15, 2004 #13
    Well, this is where PR/spin comes into it. USA activities during the Cold War actively killed, or caused the deaths of, millions. But people generally don't think about them much. The difference is that for one, it was open policy; for the other, it was covered with pretty window dressing.
  15. Apr 15, 2004 #14
    If one includes Vietnam I agree (on the "millions" figure). US actions during the Cold War have been blatantly lied about and misrepresented for decades and this "spin" continues today. I do believe that people like Blum are doing a service by revealing them to greater audiences. But again, in many instances I have a problem with the word "cause." Just because the CIA helped people at one point who went on to commit atrocities doesn't mean the CIA caused the atrocities. Also, the CIA's help is often times over emphasized. The US government deserves much more flak than it is usually given, but some people give it too much.

    I only have one factual misgiving about your post. Much of the CIA and FBI operations that Blum and others mention were not "open policy" - they were secrets. If it wasn't for the Church Committee and the Freedom of Information Act we would have little or no knowledge of them.
  16. Apr 15, 2004 #15
    True, many things they continue to hide, or declassify without letting anyone know about it. It's the same here. Until maybe 3 years ago, most Australians hadn't heard about the DSD, ASIS, and other agencies.
  17. Apr 15, 2004 #16
    That is the scary thing. Currently in the US, we have a fraction of the documents on COINTELPRO and even then ex-COINTELPRO operatives have testified that the vast majority of the most horrendous actions of the FBI in COINTELPRO were never recorded at all (because they were so horrible). There is a lot of trust given to intelligence and law enforcement agencies in all countries. Sadly, this trust has often been abused.

    edit - Which is why things like the Patriot Act are so scary. We are told that as long as you "do nothing wrong" you have nothing to worry about. History has shown that this isn't true.
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook