Women: how have guys you've liked approached you

  • Thread starter wasteofo2
  • Start date
464
1
Women: good ways you've been approached

Lots of guys don't have the confidence to talk to girls, thinking they will be labelled ''creepy'' for just starting a random conversation with a girl they find attractive.

So ladies, from your experience, what kinds of approaches work to start a good conversation that can lead to attraction, and what kinds of approaches are creepy?

For my part, usually I will talk to girls with situational things, and simply roll into a natural conversation. Otherwise, a simple, low-key compliment (about her jacket, her style, her walk, something specific) is usually a pretty good way to start off in my experience; it shows you're obviously interested in her without degrading anyone ala ''hey sexy, where you goin' baby?''
 
Last edited:
115
2
I was working in the library, he came over and said he's going to the cafe, did I want anything? I said no thanks, he went and came back with a brownie for me anyway :) I was very happy. we ended up going out for 2 years :)
 

Evo

Mentor
22,867
2,343
Re: Women: good ways you've been approached

Lots of guys don't have the confidence to talk to girls, thinking they will be labelled ''creepy'' for just starting a random conversation with a girl they find attractive.

So ladies, from your experience, what kinds of approaches work to start a good conversation that can lead to attraction, and what kinds of approaches are creepy?

For my part, usually I will talk to girls with situational things, and simply roll into a natural conversation. Otherwise, a simple, low-key compliment (about her jacket, her style, her walk, something specific) is usually a pretty good way to start off in my experience; it shows you're obviously interested in her without degrading anyone ala ''hey sexy, where you goin' baby?''
I mostly met men at dance clubs when I reached my 30's. A guy asks you to dance, you talk while dancing, then you both decide if the other is worth spending more time on. So simple, no stress.
 

BobG

Science Advisor
Homework Helper
110
80
Apparently, helping her steal a bicycle is a good way to start up a conversation.
 
88
1
Apparently, helping her steal a bicycle is a good way to start up a conversation.
You make me wonder what an armed robbery would have landed you. :devil:
 
319
1
Re: Women: good ways you've been approached

For my part, usually I will talk to girls with situational things, and simply roll into a natural conversation.
Precisely that. Make a simple, casual, situational comment. Plus-points if the comment makes me laugh.

Just being respectful and treating me as if you're interested in me as a human being is a sure-fire way to not be creepy.
 

FrancisZ

Re: Women: good ways you've been approached

Lots of guys don't have the confidence to talk to girls, thinking they will be labelled ''creepy'' for just starting a random conversation with a girl they find attractive.
Exactly why I don't. So I've often chosen to wait a very long time to even instigate anything; and even then, I prefer to write.

Recently, however, even the writing has failed me utterly. Whereas I had always thought it showed careful introspection and the dedication taken to construct such thing; it totally blew up in my face.

Moral of the story (from a male perspective anyway): there's no simple solution to the age old problem of "approaching women." Some people just don't like you any way you present yourself. :frown:
 

Pengwuino

Gold Member
4,854
14
Simple solution: Just approach them.

If a girl considers a guy creepy just because you approached them to talk to, why would you care about what such a girl thinks of you?

A) She'll be a normal human being and not think you're a creep just for talking to her
or
B) She's socially awkward and will be freaked out that you tried to talk to her and in that case, who cares? I haven't heard of many relationships that start with "my husband walked up to me and at first i thought he was a creep".
 
88
1
Re: Women: good ways you've been approached

Exactly why I don't.
Is somebody think you are a creep just because you walk to them ,talk , and invite to a coffee, sit at your table and whatever else, it's not you who is the creep , it is them.


So I've often chosen to wait a very long time to even instigate anything; and even then, I prefer to write.
Don't waste time thinking and rethinking simple actions.

Recently, however, even the writing has failed me utterly. Whereas I had always thought it showed careful introspection and the dedication taken to construct such thing; it totally blew up in my face.
You don't need introspection and dedication to talk to anyone. You just doit. And tbh, if I would ever receive a letter from a girl trying to construct anything, I would get the impression she is socially awkward. Just talk to me, ok ?

Moral of the story (from a male perspective anyway): there's no simple solution to the age old problem of "approaching women."
Approaching women is not a problem. It doesn't require any special solution. And I would carefully add, don't generalize, it's not a general male perspective you illustrate. The vast majority of men don't find it such an issue.

Some people just don't like you any way you present yourself. :frown:
And the same ppl will like somebody else in just about any way they presented themselves. It's OK. We are not suposed to like anyone. Not you, not me, nor others.
 
464
1
Re: Women: good ways you've been approached

Exactly why I don't. So I've often chosen to wait a very long time to even instigate anything; and even then, I prefer to write.

Recently, however, even the writing has failed me utterly. Whereas I had always thought it showed careful introspection and the dedication taken to construct such thing; it totally blew up in my face.

Moral of the story (from a male perspective anyway): there's no simple solution to the age old problem of "approaching women." Some people just don't like you any way you present yourself. :frown:
Francis,

The very thing that's creepy IS waiting a long time. If you stare at someone for an hour before talking to them, that's creepy. If you write someone a letter who doesn't even know you that's creepy.

Why should you put that much time, effort, or thought into a complete stranger? You don't know if she's worth a minute of your time.

That's why you should just go up to her without giving her too much imaginary value in your head.
 

Pyrrhus

Homework Helper
2,160
1
This thread needs to be sticky now. Basically most of you guys say and I (and others) continue to repeat time and time again. You JUST GO FOR IT, who cares if she rejects you? just go for another girl. Stop thinking she's that special, you don't even know her yet!.
 
84
0
I have now come to a painful realisation about myself: forever alone...
 

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,258
1,864
I have now come to a painful realisation about myself: forever alone...
You seem to be waiting for someone else to make the first move. You will not make the first move. Are you not worth it?
 
84
0
Are you not worth it?
That`s a very hard thing to answer indeed... and my answer is: I just don`t know. What do you mean by that?

edit: actually yes, I guess I`m just not worth it to whomever I would like to be of some "worth" ....
 
Last edited:

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,258
1,864
That`s a very hard thing to answer indeed... and my answer is: I just don`t know. What do you mean by that?
Okay, so I now understand that girls were expecting ME to make the first step... hmm, I see now why I failed... and why I am DOOMED.
You recognize the problem that, for a two way relationship to start, one person has to take a chance. Yet you have no intention of being the one.

I'm going to guess that you won't take a risk on anyone because rejection is too likely in your mind. Only if they step forward and demonstrate that they might like you on spec, will you pursue a relationship.

So, my question is: why do you feel that you're not a "catch"?
 
84
0
You recognize the problem that, for a two way relationship to start, one person has to take a chance. Yet you have no intention of being the one.

I'm going to guess that you won't take a risk on anyone because rejection is too likely in your mind. Only if they step forward and demonstrate that they might like you on spec, will you pursue a relationship.

So, my question is: why do you feel that you're not a "catch"?
This part of PF is definitely outside my comfort zone (why did I post here anyway)... but we don`t know each other so what the heck.

It`s not looks, it`s apparently my personality...

I`ve found that the more people know me (like the "real" me) the more they think I am weird, and they don`t always hold that word in the "compliments" area (neither do I tbh). A few have been vocal about it (I`ve even been called a freak once) but it`s just something you start to notice in their looks, gestures, etc.
The only way I can actually socialize is if I play an "act", otherwise people will tend to keep a certain distance from me. I don`t really know if it`s actually me who`s misreading everything but ever since I was a kid it was so much easier socialize if I was pretending to be someone else then if I was just "being myself" (in which case I would end up the acting the outcast whether I wanted it or not...); I`ve survived middle school and some of highschool playing the class jester and similar "roles" for example.
Whenever someone catches me off-guard without my mask on, they will tend to throw me in the buddy friend who`s a little...different zone, the guy who`s a little more interesting... that is when they`re not running away from me like I`m the plague.

I`m now more and more inclined to simply not socialize (lately I find it troublesome to even attend lectures and seminaries even if there`s hardly any direct socializing involved in this case) and there have been times when I haven`t left my dorm for more than a week.

But whatever, being alone isn`t that bad. I`m growing used to it.
 
Last edited:

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,258
1,864
I`ve found that the more people know me (like the "real" me) the more they think I am weird, and they don`t always hold that word in the "compliments" area (neither do I tbh).
Can you give a specific example of your weirdness?

But whatever, being alone isn`t that bad. I`m growing used to it.
This is a downward spiral. You are losing interest in socializing because you have little skill at it. You have little skill at it because you are not doing it enough.

You don't want to be a social outcast or you wouldn't be here ruing it. That means you are in a spiral that is taking you in a direction you would rather not go, but currently are unwilling or unable to change.

For your long term health, you might consider changing that pattern. Growth is always good; atrophy is never healthy.
 
88
1
I`m now more and more inclined to simply not socialize (lately I find it troublesome to even attend lectures and seminaries even if there`s hardly any direct socializing involved in this case) and there have been times when I haven`t left my dorm for more than a week.
Please consider getting professional help. I sincerely hope you will overcome those tendencies.
 

mephisto51

If you want to learn how to actually socialize with girls, get lots of friends that are girls and hang out with them. (Who knows girls better than girls?) Now with this, it's best if you try to socialize with some of your friend's friends that are girls. (Especially if you feel like approaching one is creepy) Your friends should be able to somehow get all of you to hangout in someway. Only very few of my friends are male. Once when you start communicating with those, from friend to friend, you will be able to ask questions from them and get a response. Sometimes it's general enough for figuring out a solutions and techniques that is right for you when approaching girls.
In fact, I've talked to so many girls just by being friends with them that it's no issue to walk up to them and start a conversation. You'll start to come out of your shell and feel relaxed around girls. That gives you the oppertunity to feel perfectly secure as to trying to make her laugh. You may come to the conclusion right now that it may be different due to the girl you're trying to talk to? You're right but why would you change who you are/how you talk to get to know them?
 

Related Threads for: Women: how have guys you've liked approached you

Replies
72
Views
9K
Replies
50
Views
18K
  • Posted
2
Replies
32
Views
14K
  • Posted
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Posted
2 3
Replies
63
Views
6K
Replies
62
Views
9K
  • Posted
Replies
3
Views
1K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Hot Threads

Top