Need Help Understanding 3 Problems?

  • Thread starter mohabitar
  • Start date
In summary: Work done by string is: not really sure about this one :(In summary, the free fall case has less work done than the incline and string cases because the weight of the object is the only force acting on it. The incline case has less work done because there is no friction and the weight is weaker than the free fall case. The string case has the same amount of work done as the free fall case because the tension force acts perpendicular to the motion and does no work.
  • #1
mohabitar
140
0
I have these 3 problems, and it doesn't tell me whether my answer is right or wrong right away. I choose the answer I thought was appropriate, and explained why. Can anyone take a look at the explanations and see if they're true? I'm sure some may be flawed.

1.
qUx46.png

2.
vXTay.png

3.
Df0dO.png
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
That's a lot of questions in a single post! You should post each one separately with your relevant equations and attempt at a solution. For the first one, what are the forces acting on the mass in each case that do Work? Then use the definition of Work to get your answer. The one you checked is wrong.
 
  • #3
Sorry I didnt want to spam the forum with 3 different posts all relatively the same.

So for the free fall case, forces acting on mass that do work are:
-its weight, mg

Incline:
Since there is no friction, only force that act on its movement are mg. But I'm not really sure here: the normal force acts on it as well but 'canceled out' by the w=mg, since both of those added should equal zero, no?
So the mg in this case is weaker than the free fall, since its not full gravity.

Last case:
Forces acting on the ball are mg as well as Tension.

These kind of questions usually have the answer of 'same', which it probably is in this case, but it's not my first logical guess.

I still don't see how my answer is wrong. Isnt the force of gravity strongest in the free fall? For incline, it would be only sin/cos of gravity, so only a portion, right?
 
  • #4
mohabitar said:
Sorry I didnt want to spam the forum with 3 different posts all relatively the same.
I understand, but when you pose several questions at once, helpers and you can get bogged down just responding back and forth to one of them, and before you know it, the post either gets several pages long, or, more likely, your other questions get lost in the abyss (black hole:wink:).
So for the free fall case, forces acting on mass that do work are:
-its weight, mg
correct; how much worK?
Incline:
Since there is no friction, only force that act on its movement are mg. But I'm not really sure here: the normal force acts on it as well but 'canceled out' by the w=mg, since both of those added should equal zero, no?
No. The normal force acts perpendicular to the incline, so it doesn't cancel out the weight. But the normal force does no work...W =Fdcostheta, but theta is 90 degrees for the angle between the force and displacement, so the work done by the normal force is 0. What's the work done by gravity?
So the mg in this case is weaker than the free fall, since its not full gravity.
mg is always full gravity. The component of the gravity force doen the plane is less than mg, but the distance traveled is longer. Again, what's the work done by gravity?
Last case:
Forces acting on the ball are mg as well as Tension.
again the tension always acts perpendicular to the motion, so it does no work.
These kind of questions usually have the answer of 'same', which it probably is in this case, but it's not my first logical guess.

I still don't see how my answer is wrong. Isnt the force of gravity strongest in the free fall? For incline, it would be only sin/cos of gravity, so only a portion, right?
See above response
 
  • #5
For question 2, there is no displacement relative to the truck,but plenty relative to the ground..and also a friction force acting that keeps the block accelerating at the same rate of the truck.
 
  • #6
When you say what's the work done by gravity, are you asking for a value? Well work is force x displacement (integral, kind of) so work done by gravity for the free fall is 9.8*m*h -is that what you're asking for?

Work done by incline is: m*h*9.8cosx
Work done by string is: not really sure about this one :(
 
  • #7
For question 2, there is no displacement relative to the truck,but plenty relative to the ground..and also a friction force acting that keeps the block accelerating at the same rate of the truck.

Ahh ok..so the block IS accelerating, even though its not really moving itself?
 
  • #8
And regarding the third question, 'total' work and 'net' work are the same term. Since the net force is 0, the net work is___??___?
 
  • #9
mohabitar said:
When you say what's the work done by gravity, are you asking for a value? Well work is force x displacement (integral, kind of) so work done by gravity for the free fall is 9.8*m*h -is that what you're asking for?
yes, correct, now compare that to the net work done in the other 2 cases
Work done by incline is: m*h*9.8cosx
The work done by the normal force is 0. The work done by gravity is mgsintheta times the length (h/sin theta) of the incline. Or, the work done by gravity (or any conservative force) is always just the negative of the change in potential energy
Work done by string is: not really sure about this one :(
Use same reasoning as above.
 
  • #10
mohabitar said:
Ahh ok..so the block IS accelerating, even though its not really moving itself?
It is moving, with respect to the ground. It is accelerating with respect to the ground, so its speed is changing. If an object is accelerating, there must be a net force acting on it. Is work being done? (this is question 2).
 
Last edited:

1. What is the best approach to understanding and solving complex problems?

The best approach to understanding and solving complex problems is to break them down into smaller, more manageable parts. This can be done through the use of diagrams, charts, or even creating a step-by-step plan. It is also important to approach the problem with an open mind and be willing to consider multiple solutions.

2. How can I improve my critical thinking skills when facing a challenging problem?

One way to improve critical thinking skills when facing a challenging problem is to ask questions and gather information from multiple sources. It is also important to challenge assumptions and think outside the box. Additionally, taking breaks and approaching the problem from different angles can also help improve critical thinking skills.

3. Are there any specific strategies for understanding and solving math and science problems?

Yes, there are several strategies that can help with understanding and solving math and science problems. These include identifying key concepts, using visual aids, practicing problems, and seeking help from a teacher or tutor if needed. It is also important to understand the reasoning behind each step in the problem-solving process.

4. What are some common roadblocks that can hinder problem-solving?

Some common roadblocks that can hinder problem-solving include lack of information or understanding, fear of failure, and being too focused on finding a single "correct" answer. Overthinking and not being able to think outside the box can also prevent successful problem-solving.

5. How can I stay motivated and focused when facing difficult problems?

One way to stay motivated and focused when facing difficult problems is to remind yourself of the end goal and the importance of finding a solution. Breaking the problem down into smaller, achievable tasks can also help maintain motivation. It can also be helpful to take breaks and come back to the problem with a fresh perspective.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
16
Views
460
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
24
Views
890
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
470
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
2
Replies
38
Views
1K
Replies
29
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
968
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
14
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
1K
Back
Top