Work in Physics: Does it Always Involve Movement?

In summary: Work has been done. Now imagine you and the object are in space. There's no force pushing on the object, so there's no displacement and no work is done.
  • #1
adjacent
Gold Member
1,552
63
Wikipedia defines work as:
In physics, a force is said to do work when it acts on a body so that there is a displacement of the point of application, however small, in the direction of the force. Thus a force does work when it results in movement.
What if in space,where there is no external force acting,Someone applies a force and the object will move on to a infinite displacement forever(Newton's first law).Is work done?

Another question is from that wikipedia:
For example, the centripetal force exerted inwards by a string on a ball in uniform circular motion sideways constrains the ball to circular motion restricting its movement away from the center of the circle. This force does zero work because it is perpendicular to the velocity of the ball.
Work done=Energy transferred . That means in circular motion no energy is transferred to the object ,not even kinetic.Then how can it move?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
hi adjacent! :smile:
adjacent said:
What if in space,where there is no external force acting,Someone applies a force and the object will move on to a infinite displacement forever(Newton's first law).Is work done?

work is done is getting the object moving

once it is moving, it carries on in a straight line at the same speed (Newton's first law of motion) without any more force

"its work is done!" :wink:
Work done=Energy transferred . That means in circular motion no energy is transferred to the object ,not even kinetic.Then how can it move?

work was done to get it moving

the string keeps it in a circle, but doesn't reduce its speed

no further work is neeeded
 
  • #3
tiny-tim said:
hi adjacent! :smile:


work is done is getting the object moving

once it is moving, it carries on in a straight line at the same speed (Newton's first law of motion) without any more force

"its work is done!" :wink:
How can I calculate the work done then?
W=FS
It moves to an infinite distance,Meaning work done is infinite?
 
  • #4
tiny-tim said:
hi adjacent! :smile:
...
work was done to get it moving

the string keeps it in a circle, but doesn't reduce its speed

no further work is neeeded
We need centripetal force all the time it is moving in a circle,meaning work is done always?
 
  • #5
adjacent said:
How can I calculate the work done then?
W=FS
It moves to an infinite distance,Meaning work done is infinite?

no, S is the displacement of the point of application of the force

the force is only applied at the start (to get it going)

after that, there is no force (so zero displacement)
adjacent said:
We need centripetal force all the time it is moving in a circle,meaning work is done always?

the displacement (of the point of application of the force) is tangential, the force is radial

so the displacement "in the direction of the force" (see wikipedia) is zero

the full formula is the dot product, W = F·S
 
  • #6
tiny-tim said:
no, S is the displacement of the point of application of the force

the force is only applied at the start (to get it going)

after that, there is no force (so zero displacement)
But displacement is defined as the distance traveled in a stated direction.No force is needed.
Or do you mean S is the displacement(in the direction of force) covered when the force is still there?

Again
tiny-tim said:
the displacement (of the point of application of the force) is tangential, the force is radial

so the displacement "in the direction of the force" (see wikipedia) is zero

the full formula is the dot product, W = F·S
We still apply a force and get tired why?If no work is done,then we would not get tired?
 
Last edited:
  • #7
adjacent said:
But displacement is defined as the distance traveled in a stated direction.No force is needed.
Or do you mean S is the displacement(in the direction of force) covered when the force is still there?

yes

the displacement is of the point of application of the force

when the force is no longer applied, it no longer has a point of application!
We still apply a force and get tired why?If no work is done,then we would not get tired?

stand between two doorposts, and push apart

the doorposts don't move, but parts of your body do move, and work is done

now relax your arms … if they were made of elastic, you would get all the energy back, and then do the same again without getting tired

but they're not made of elastic, so the energy is wasted, and if you do it again, you have do work all over again
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #8
adjacent said:
But displacement is defined as the distance traveled in a stated direction.No force is needed.
Or do you mean S is the displacement(in the direction of force) covered when the force is still there?
Think of it this way: work is only done when a force is applied. Imagine you and an object are the only two things in the whole universe. Start with the object at rest (relative to you) and push on it. You apply a force and the object accelerates from rest to some velocity in a certain distance while you push on it. Because you're applying a force and the object is moving, you're doing work. [itex]F[/itex] isn't 0 and [itex]s[/itex] isn't 0 in the [itex]W = F \cdot s[/itex] equation, so [itex]W[/itex] also isn't 0.

But once you let go of the object, it no longer accelerates. It travels at constant velocity and it does have a displacement, however you're no longer applying a force. Now [itex]W = 0 \cdot s = 0[/itex]. So you can see that no work is done even though the object moves. :smile:

That was an ideal situation where the only force was your pushing. So that you could see the concept clearly, I neglected an important fact: just by having mass you would be attracting the object gravitationally and the object would be attracting you. So even once you let go of the object and you're not pushing on it, there would still be a gravitational force pulling it back toward you. Does this force do work?
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #9
adjacent said:
We still apply a force and get tired why?If no work is done,then we would not get tired?
We are inefficient, 0% efficiency in some circumstances. You get tired, not because you are doing external work, but because you are wasting lots of energy generating heat by using your muscles inefficiently.
 

1. What is work in physics?

Work in physics is defined as the transfer of energy from one object to another, resulting in a change in the state of motion of the object. It is a measurable quantity that is calculated by multiplying the force applied to an object by the distance it moves in the direction of the force.

2. Does work in physics always involve movement?

No, work in physics does not always involve movement. Work can also be done on an object by exerting a force on it without causing it to move, such as pushing against a stationary wall. In this case, the object does not move, but work is still being done.

3. How is work different from force?

Force is a push or pull on an object, while work is the result of applying that force over a distance. In other words, force is the cause of work, while work is the effect of force.

4. Is work a scalar or vector quantity?

Work is a scalar quantity, meaning it has magnitude but no direction. This is because work is calculated by multiplying two scalar quantities, force and distance, and not by a vector quantity like displacement.

5. Can work be negative?

Yes, work can be negative. When a force is applied in the opposite direction of an object's motion, the work done on the object is negative. This means that energy is being taken away from the object instead of being transferred to it.

Similar threads

  • Mechanics
Replies
1
Views
904
Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
34
Views
3K
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
884
Replies
4
Views
906
Replies
5
Views
773
Replies
9
Views
641
  • Mechanics
Replies
30
Views
2K
Back
Top