1. Limited time only! Sign up for a free 30min personal tutor trial with Chegg Tutors
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Work of a Carnot machine

  1. May 28, 2005 #1
    integration of

    Dear people of this section.

    Suppose you have two indepenfent functions x and y and we need to find the integral of the following expression y dx ,and y does not depends upon x, but y varies between 4 and 8 in the interval of integration. ¿ Do you think that the value of the integration is (( 4+8)/2 ) x ?
  2. jcsd
  3. May 28, 2005 #2
    [tex]\int y dx= yx + h(y)[/tex]

    does that make sense? as far as y varying from 4 to 8... umm... i guess you would just plug those at the end...
  4. May 28, 2005 #3
    we need to find the integral of the following expression y dx ,and y does not depends upon x

    This statement shows that the integral will evaluate to [itex] yx + C [/tex]

    y varies between 4 and 8 in the interval of integration
    If y varies as plotted against x, then y does depend on x. If it varies when plotted against a different variable, then this information has no meaning for the given problem.
  5. May 28, 2005 #4


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    In other words, you just use the fundamental theorem of calculus like you always would:

    \int_a^b f_x(x, y) \, dx = f(b, y) - f(a, y)
  6. May 29, 2005 #5
    In order to be clear my qustion to you, I am going to explain better the origin of this thread. I am interested to find the work of a carnot machine that operates between a hot reservoir at 800k (constant temperature) an a series of cold reservoirs whose temperature varies from 400 t0 800K. From thermodynamics the work, W, will be

    W = Integral (1-Tb/Ta) dQ
    where Tb is the variable temperature of the cold reservoir, Ta is the constant temperature of the hot reservoir and Q is the heat input. Solving we get

    W= Integral dQ - integral (Tb/Ta)dQ = Q- (1/Ta)integral Tb dQ

    Since Tb and Q are independent, we obtain

    W= Q-Tb Q

    To get a number a need to introduce a value for Q and Tb. ¿ What value do I choose for Tb if it varies between 400 and 800?. Q is equal to 2000 calories. Because of this I said, well, Tb is the arithmetic mean of 400 and 800 K, or Tb= (400 + 800)/2. ? Is this reasonable, honest?
  7. May 29, 2005 #6


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    Ack, I just noticed the section. This isn't even a number theory question to begin with! (Should be calculus & analysis, if you wanted to put it in the math forum)

    However, your problem appears to be your modelling of the scenario. Q and Tb cannot be functionally independent, since both depend on time. (Unless one of them is a constant) I'm going to punt this over to the physics section -- should be someone over there who knows exactly what you should be doing.
  8. May 31, 2005 #7
    Dear Hurkyl, since I don´t have any answer, yet. Let me to present a different solution to the original question of the thread. In other words, let us find the integral of YdX using the basic definition of integration. As you suggest Y and X are not functionally independent, but we don´t know how they depend. We know that X varies between a and b. Then , we can define an infinite set of equals intervals delta X = (b-a)/n, where n is the number of intervals. n tends to infinite. then,

    integral Y d X = Summatory (Y1 delta X+ Y2 deltaX + Y3 delta X+ ....Yn delta X)

    Y1, Y2, Y3,.............Yn, are the Y values in each interval delta X.

    Since each delta X = (b-a)/n, we get

    Integral Y dX = (b-a) Summmatory ( Y1+ Y2+ Y3+......Yn) /n
    where n tends to infinite

    But Summatory (Y1+ Y2+Y3+ .......+ Yn) / n is the arithmetic mean or the average of an infinite set of values , as I will prove now.
    By the mean value theorem

    Summatory ( Y1+Y2+Y3+......+Yn) = 1/ ( Yb -Ya) Integral YdY = (Yb +Ya) / 2

    where Ya and Yb are the initial and final values of Y.

    Integral YdX= (b-a)(Ya+Yb)/2
    This final result coincides with the empirical value I initially suggested.

    Now, since I am not an expert mathematician, I have doubts about the validity of this demonstration, and I appreciate very much your comments and suggestions. If this is correct I think I can apply it to the Carnot machine.
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook