Ben vdP's latest activity
-
BBen vdP replied to the thread Undergrad Bell's theorem and measurements not done.Indeed, one other assumption that may have been made is that the dynamic behaviour and nature of interactions should be similar to those...
-
BBen vdP reacted to PeterDonis's post in the thread Undergrad Bell's theorem and measurements not done with
Like.
Yes, that was Bell's point when he formulated the theorem: reality violates the Bell inequalities, so at least one of the assumptions... -
BBen vdP replied to the thread Undergrad Bell's theorem and measurements not done.Indeed for large objects, but that is no longer the context. There has been another assumption made. The assumption that the...
-
BBen vdP reacted to Nugatory's post in the thread Undergrad Bell's theorem and measurements not done with
Informative.
It’s a proof by contradiction argument. The calculation is correct if the realism and locality assumptions hold; we do the experiment... -
BBen vdP replied to the thread Undergrad Bell's theorem and measurements not done.Ok, thanks for the reply. I may have unconsciously rejected the realism assumption since I find it highly questionable that you can...
-
BBen vdP replied to the thread Undergrad Bell's theorem and measurements not done.I might have lost some of the formatting when trying to copy and paste from the wiki page.
-
BBen vdP posted the thread Undergrad Bell's theorem and measurements not done in Quantum Interpretations and Foundations.I wanted to have a quick check on how Bell's theorem was formulated so consulted the wiki page...
-
BBen vdP replied to the thread A question about quantum entanglement.The most entangled might (in general) be the problem description. Maybe in first order: Step 1, suppose there is a process in which...
-
BBen vdP replied to the thread Graduate Quantum interpretations and indistinguishable elementary particles.The issue has become more clearer now and I think these posts misses the point. It is not about individual elementary particles at all...
-
BBen vdP replied to the thread Graduate Quantum interpretations and indistinguishable elementary particles.I can agree with that. p.s. Post 8 was not really relevant at all, but lets leave that
-
BBen vdP reacted to bhobba's post in the thread Graduate Quantum interpretations and indistinguishable elementary particles with
Like.
It's trivial in QFT. Ordinary QM is only an approximation to the relativistic limit of QFT. There are no antiparticles in ordinary... -
BBen vdP replied to the thread Graduate Quantum interpretations and indistinguishable elementary particles.It is not just a choice. By describing it as an individual physical system, it is being overlooked that every such physical system is...
-
BBen vdP replied to the thread Graduate Quantum interpretations and indistinguishable elementary particles.Because elementary particles are identical. The indistinguishability is a consequence of that. A photon may have a different energy...
-
BBen vdP replied to the thread Graduate Quantum interpretations and indistinguishable elementary particles.It is not about describing a single elementary particle, but about an individual physical system. Let me guess, you never had a real...
-
BBen vdP replied to the thread Graduate Quantum interpretations and indistinguishable elementary particles.No, there is no such requirement indeed. Thus you are trying to describe with a wave function a system and interpretate it as an...