Recent content by jeffn1

  1. J

    Undergrad Particle vs Wave Interpretations of QM

    I can't help thinking, from a big picture conceptual perspective, that the shift from QFT clearly represents a paradigm shift. It shifts the perspective from the behavior of individualized particles to universal quantum fields, with particles constituting excitations of the underlying field. I...
  2. J

    Graduate Why is Bell’s theorem still considered controversial?

    The interesting thing is, when we measure it/detect locally, the entanglement ends immediately for both the local and nonlocal particle, seemingly "causing" an effect billions of miles away (even though the termination of the correlation cannot be confirmed until the non-local particle is...
  3. J

    Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics

    Doesn't the Schrodinger equation apply to the electron like other quantum particles? We can only detect a location when when it is measured (but with the familiar tradeoff of location/momentum). So, we currently have "probabilities" (that, as I understand it, correspond to the shapes of...
  4. J

    Undergrad Getting to the Heart of Entanglement and Locality in Plain English

    Forgive me if this is a dumb question, but in the case of a pair of entangled particles in a singlet state, if the spin of one entangled particle is measured (which causes them to disentangle, as I understand it), is the spin of the other particle always the opposite?
  5. J

    Undergrad Getting to the Heart of Entanglement and Locality in Plain English

    Yes, I meant entanglement ends. But, to my way of thinking, as a result of this the spins of the two formerly entangled particles are no longer correlated. I think I've resolved myself to accept nonlocality. QFT, based on (let's call them) infinite quantum fields is so well supported. I tend...
  6. J

    Undergrad Getting to the Heart of Entanglement and Locality in Plain English

    Yes, "cause" is an interesting concept; more slippery than one might initially think. In law there are two legal concepts "but for" causation and "proximate" causation. "But for" causation seems to be the relevant one for science. Proximate cause is used in tort law to say that something...
  7. J

    Undergrad Getting to the Heart of Entanglement and Locality in Plain English

    Ahh, that's a deeper question. I am not doing "actual physics", but I do want to understand science. Is it fair to say you are in the Niels Bohr school of thought? ;)
  8. J

    Undergrad Getting to the Heart of Entanglement and Locality in Plain English

    Thank you, Peter. Maybe the confusion stems from what we are defining as "the cause". I tend to think the detection/measurement/interaction of either particle causes both particles to dis-entangle. Is that helpful?
  9. J

    Undergrad Getting to the Heart of Entanglement and Locality in Plain English

    I think forget about the conveyor belt analogy (and thank you for thinking about it). I don't think it was very good because it is too removed and different from entangled particles. But, I suppose all I was trying to say was that, if the detection/measurement/merely stops any further...
  10. J

    Undergrad Getting to the Heart of Entanglement and Locality in Plain English

    Thank you! The conveyor belt analogy (I suspect others have created a better one) is that the pre-detection environment is "in flux". But, a detection performed at different points in time would result in different spins (so there is no predetermined hidden spin(s)). But, once the...
  11. J

    Undergrad Getting to the Heart of Entanglement and Locality in Plain English

    I didn't think Bell inequalities experiments ruled out nonlocal hidden variables. I thought Bohmian Mechanics is a nonlocal hidden variable interpretation.
  12. J

    Undergrad Getting to the Heart of Entanglement and Locality in Plain English

    I understand two particles can be entangled even though they are many millions of miles away. I understand a simple example of this is a "quantum singlet state": Singlet State: This is the precise quantum state where two entangled particles have a total spin of zero. Because the total spin...
  13. J

    High School Does entanglement synchronization change with distance in general relativity?

    If the act of measuring/detecting/collapsing either particle causes both particles to select opposing spins, I do not see why this should not be considered cause and effect. But I'll keep digging. :) FWIW, I think this is consistent with Art Hobson's view. I recall him stating that this occurs...