mathwonk's latest activity
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Grade Inflation at Harvard.To illustrate what a la-la land the current grading practice at Harvard inhabits, the Harvard college student handbook already defines...
-
MGrade inflation is a problem everywhere : https://www.gradeinflation.com/ Personally, I think it's detrimental for students sense of...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Grade Inflation at Harvard.That article was interesting. Some statements should be taken with salt however, e.g. the suggestion that grade inflation is related to...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Grade Inflation at Harvard.I think this is a difficult problem. As a student at Harvard in the early 1960’s, when maybe 15% of grades were A’s, I got a lot of...
-
Mmathwonk reacted to martinbn's post in the thread Graduate Trivial fiber bundle vs product space with
Like.
I am starting to think that the question of the thread is not about fibler bundles, but whether isomorphic objects are to be considered... -
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Graduate Trivial fiber bundle vs product space.It seems indeed this is the usual meaning of trivial, i.e. equivalent to a product, but without a choice of trivialization. I was...
-
Mmathwonk reacted to lavinia's post in the thread Graduate Trivial fiber bundle vs product space with
Like.
What I am used to and maybe this is wrong, a trivial bundle is one for which there exists a global trivialization. But there is no need... -
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Graduate Trivial fiber bundle vs product space.well yes. I had assumed you meant this to be an F-bundle over A, in which case those two projections give, in my opinion, one...
-
Mmathwonk reacted to cianfa72's post in the thread Graduate Trivial fiber bundle vs product space with
Like.
Yes however, even if diffeomorphic to a product, there is no canonical/natural diffeomorphism. That's the difference with a product that... -
Mmathwonk reacted to lavinia's post in the thread Graduate Trivial fiber bundle vs product space with
Like.
A choice of a product decomposition of a topological space that is homeomorphic to a Cartesian product AxF naturally supplies a... -
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Graduate Trivial fiber bundle vs product space.I essentially agree with you @cianfa72. i.e. technically a trivial bundle is a trivializable bundle plus a trivialization. the...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Undergrad The vector to which a dual vector corresponds.yes thank you. I probably should have said k = real numbers in my discussion above.
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Undergrad The vector to which a dual vector corresponds.Given any (finite dimensional) vector space V, it has a dual space V* consisting of linear functions f:V-->k, where k is the field of...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Finding the Centre of Mass of a Hemisphere.Yes. If the question referred to the center of mass of a hemispherical shell, (embedded in 3 -space), then since as I believe...
-
Mmathwonk replied to the thread Finding the Centre of Mass of a Hemisphere.I hope from the comments here it is ok to post a solution. this can be done by noting that, (just as one gets a solid 3 ball by...