PAllen's latest activity
-
PPAllen reacted to julian's post in the thread AI Did Claude discover a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis? with
Like.
I went to Terence Tao's blog and asked the following question about Alpöge and Claude's proposed proof: I received the following... -
PPAllen replied to the thread AI Did Claude discover a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis?.It seems to say the lean code starts only from 3 foundational axioms. Doesnt this imply that perhaps 10 million or more of the 17...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread AI Did Claude discover a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis?.There is a thread of mathematicians working through the lean...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread AI Did Claude discover a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis?.I went to a talk about AI a number of years ago, where the speaker was showing trend lines and making the case that there was no sign of...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread AI Did Claude discover a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis?.Actually, he is. It is in footnote 2 of his post. But in this footnote, he gives an example of how textualizing the lean formalization...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread AI Did Claude discover a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis?.As described in the OP link, this reads more like a collaboration than a pure AI proof. There appeared to be a lot of guidance and...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics.Instantaneous interaction and apparent communication are interpretation dependent. The only observable is a correlation that can be...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?.it was certainly suspected from SR because light has momentum in SR, and if absorbed contributes to rest mass. So this non inclusion...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?.Just as an aside - one of the ways to address binding energy directly in GR is to assume, for a large local system, e.g, a galaxy, you...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?.Yes, to some extent it gets around my criticism - the trace of T is obviously a Lorentz scalar, and it avoids instant changes at a...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?.But total mass/energy is a source in a relativistic gravity theory, and that is definitely NOT a Lorentz scalar. For example, a system...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?.The Newtonian potential depends position, and this is mathematically incompatible with special relativity because any local change has...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?.You seem to have completely missed my point. You were complaining “where is the potential in GR”. I explain there can’t possibly be...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Is GR superior to Newtonian gravity?.The Newtonian scalar potential is associated with action at a distance and absence of gravitational radiation. Thus the potential is...
-
PPAllen reacted to Dale's post in the thread High School Einstein equations don't work at large scale? with
Like.
This source does not meet the PF standards. So we can certainly discuss your questions, but we will not be relying on or discussing the...