PAllen's latest activity
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Graduate Hau, Harris, Tsakmakidis for 2026 Nobel in Physics?.Unfortunately, while I have been hoping for Hau for many years (I met her once at a talk), I have developed the opinion that the Nobel...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Is AI Overhyped?.One thing that, to me shows a missing element of actual understanding, is the completely unique mistakes the top bots still make (as of...
-
P“They don’t miss. Gravity alone turns this into a collision, and the product is a black hole. First, the scale: a 145 g baseball at γ =...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Is AI Overhyped?.Here is another one for comparison between free Claude.ai and the paid version. The free version analyzes the following incorrectly...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Is AI Overhyped?.On the other hand, here is a financial example free Claude gets wrong, and the prompt needed to correct it: “I want to use an SBLOC to...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Is AI Overhyped?.Note, 3 test problems I gave Claude 6 months ago that it got wrong, it now gets right. These had to do with local, smooth, isometric...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Is AI Overhyped?.Here is one. Note, I get varying answers at different times, but all neglect to correctly describe the extreme anisotropy of what...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Is AI Overhyped?.How different are the paid versions from the free versions? I have used the free versions of chat gpt, claude, and gemini. All leave me...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Absolute versus relative grading for STEM: fairness and student motivation.I agree there is something to this point of view.
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Absolute versus relative grading for STEM: fairness and student motivation.I am a strong believer in absolute grading. In effect, there is a contract between teacher and student: this is the material to be...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Basic skills that kids are lacking.Recursion: see recursion
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Simplified Special Relativity: Looking to get roasted on this.I ask again what has been asked before. I don’t believe it is a violation of PF to state: here is a set of formal assumptions I tried to...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Is Water's Volume Expansion Upon Freezing an Intrinsic Property?.My understanding is that it would take a much stronger shell than that to keep the water liquid; so it would beak or stretch.
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Is Water's Volume Expansion Upon Freezing an Intrinsic Property?.I freeze glass jars with water filled to 2/3 all the time, with no breakage. They are covered, but not securely airtight. So, after...
-
PPAllen replied to the thread Undergrad Cosmological Redshift and Expansion.Frequently Doppler is used to define mutual rest, by absence of shift. Of course this is just one definition, but it is ONE. It...