PDA

View Full Version : Maths puzzle


jcsd
May30-04, 02:23 PM
I've nicked this puzzle (and slightly modified it) from another forum:

If the sum of a set of numbers is 100, what is their highest possible product if:

a) they are non-negative reals

b) they are non-negative integers

AKG
May30-04, 02:25 PM
I've nicked this puzzle (and slightly modified it) from another forum:Would it be from this thread (http://forums.philosophyforums.com/showthread.php?t=8778)?

jcsd
May30-04, 02:29 PM
No, it's not from that forum. The original puzzle only had part b) in it, part a) is my own addition, but I see that someone's already posted a very simlair puzzle.

mathman
May30-04, 07:22 PM
Since the maximum is always achieved when the numbers are all equal, the problem reduces to finding the maximum of x100/x, and then calculating the products for the integers bracketing 100/x. The answer is x=e. I'll let you work out the final answer.

jcsd
May31-04, 06:28 AM
I've solved it already, it was meant to be a quiz.

The answer to part a) as the fact that the maximum value of x^1/x is e^1/e, is quite well known, though it's helpful for part b) it's not necessrily needed to be known.

uart
May31-04, 10:00 AM
Yes but e^(100/e) is not a valid solution in this case as the numbers must add to 100, and no integer multiple if e is equal to 100. Note that the number of numbers is an integer regardless of whether or not the actual numbers themselves are constrained to be integers.

Anyway I think the solution to "part a" is (100/37)^37 and the solution to "part b" is 4 * 3^32, though I haven't totally confirmed these values.

jcsd
May31-04, 10:27 AM
Of course yes.

well your defintely right on part b), and you certainly look right for part a)



the question I really wnated to ask for part a) I suppose was then which value of xy = 100 gives the highest vlaue for x^y.