Physics Forums

Physics Forums (
-   Classical Physics (
-   -   Walter Lewin's riddle (

Nikitin Feb16-13 07:07 AM

Walter Lewin's riddle

At 37:00 he charges a conductor with a dielectric inside, removes the conductor plates and discharges them, and in the end puts them back into position.

Then something "remarkable" happens - when he connects the conductor plates with each-other, a spark is produced. Why did this happen?


Is this because the dielectric is still polarized when he puts back the plates, and thus the plates themselves become charged (by induction) in turn? If not, what is the answer to this riddle?

jfgobin Feb16-13 07:54 AM

Re: Walter Lewin's riddle
You're on the right track. If you want to put some math on it, consider the simpler case of a plane capacitor, with a dielectric and two gaps. Calculate the field both in the gaps and in the dielectric needed to have a potential difference around 20kV between the two plates, and compare to the breakdown field for air (around 3MV/m)

DrZoidberg Feb16-13 08:02 PM

Re: Walter Lewin's riddle
Walter Lewin explains how this works here

atyy Feb16-13 08:38 PM

Re: Walter Lewin's riddle
How did he discover this?

vanhees71 Feb17-13 03:58 AM

Re: Walter Lewin's riddle
This is marvelous! I could listen to this guy the whole day :-)).

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:49 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
© 2014 Physics Forums