View Single Post
Studiot
Studiot is offline
#39
Apr5-11, 06:21 PM
P: 5,462
The problem is when you say
I didn't say that. I understood circuit analysis long ago.

I reproduced (and said so) the Original Post (OP).

I didn't originally offer advice to FF because I knew (sadly ) she would be offered a hotchpotch of conflicting advice - which she was.

I think FF posted the message that is being taught to students (wrongly IHMO) around the world, because it is confusing.

I agree that it is confusing.

Charge, current or current density are the fundamental quantities in electricity, not potential. It should be possible to set this out without recourse to potential, which you had to do to 'explain' the contradiction.

Indeed there is another thread currently raging where your method would fail. Is it therefore fair on students to introduce it?