| Thread Closed |
The Mayan Underworld |
Share Thread | Thread Tools |
| Aug15-08, 08:20 PM | #1 |
|
|
The Mayan Underworld |
| Aug15-08, 11:52 PM | #2 |
|
|
Cool, shame there are not more pictures.
|
| Aug16-08, 01:39 PM | #3 |
|
|
What would be good to find out is if the underground find pre-dates the above ground structures or visa versa. That could prove to be a difficult undertaking. |
| Aug18-08, 11:11 AM | #4 |
|
|
The Mayan Underworld
I'm not sure if this is the same function as the type of underground "facilities" I've linked to here but "chultuns" have been found in the past and they are said to be underground storage units for the Mayans.
Here's a link to some photos of those types of underground utilities. http://archaeology.about.com/gi/dyna...2Fchultun.html There is, as they mention on this site, a dilemma in archaeology these days. Many sites are still being used today and so the historical and pre-historical value is diminished by present day activity and requirements. When I first got into archaeology the "aboriginals" or "first nations" or "natives" were simply called indians. This was a throw back from Columbus or another exploiter...er.. explorer... thinking they'd found the passage to India. By the time I was supervising excavations and surveys we were handing the responsibility of uncovering the histories and pre-histories of the first nations back to the first nations. Today there is a higher percentage of First Nation people running museums and even excavating. In the Haida Nation of Haida Guaii... or what we called the Queen Charolotte Islands, there are "watchmen" at every significant site where the Haida had very populous and vibrant villages.edit... if you want to tour these sites, and they are incredible even in the state they're in... you are always under the watchful eye of a Haida nation dude who lives on site in a portable that's been fashioned to look like a miniature longhouse. Where many do not want to continue talking with me is when I remind them that the Haida often conquered other nations, taking the women back to Haida Gauii and killing all of the men on the spot. When the first nations ask for reparation for the abuse in Residential Schools, churches, and white man's transgressions.... I think its good to air these things out.... but I also think the Salish, Stolo and other nations could use the same dialog with the Haida and perhaps they'd all learn some better negotiating skills and have a better alliance for future economic/community endeavors. |
| Aug24-08, 03:02 PM | #5 |
|
Admin
Blog Entries: 5
|
neat! I did the seattle underground tour... I bet this would be even better!
|
| Aug25-08, 11:52 AM | #6 |
|
|
I assume Haida means the people, and Gauii means Island (it sounds like Hawaii to me but I don't assume there could be any linguistic connection) I have seen the phrase Xhaaidlagha Gwaayaai ---- I assume that Gwaayaai is the same word as Gauii, perhaps with a different transcription or case inflection, and then Xhaaidlagha would be "the edge of the world"----an agglutinative word where one part, e.g. Xhaai, might mean world and the other part, e.g. lagha, might mean edge (or vice versa). So you are giving us a glimpse of Canadian----or British Columbia----negotiations and policy regarding pre-European people and archeology. These are extremely delicate and complex issues. In the USA many mistakes have been made in how to handle this business (not to speak of broad social issues, I only mean the archeology part) A friend of ours is an archeologist whose professional career has been largely involved in navigating the site preservation process entailed whenever they build a new freeway or shopping mall in Arizona or Nevada. For a while he was at digs in Scotland and other UK areas and I imagine they have their own bluepainted aboriginals to cope with but maybe it is not so complicated. We are all obsessed with our ancestral past whether we realize it or not. So that is all really fascinating about what you do in the Queen Charlottes. I wish you success and would very much like to hear more. |
| Aug25-08, 12:46 PM | #7 |
|
|
Here's a bit of (pre)-history surrounding the area... And here's the DNA evidence as Wikipedia has it: The language of the Haida is endangered and an "isolate" language but just looking at the people and hearing the language makes you think of the distant shores of Hawaii. Here's a link to Wikipedia's take on the language. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haida_language Greg Bernhardt, yeah the Seattle underground city is fascinating. Vancouver has a similar feature. I guess that's one reason why Vanc. and Seattle are sister cities... another is that we share the rain and volcanic ash + earth quakes! |
| Aug25-08, 01:24 PM | #8 |
|
|
How can trading be ruled out, i mean it only needs one small group to manufacture, they could trade, then others copy, i guess an essential and successful tool would be to them as electricity is to us.
Edit. In other words the people were all ready there and the tool spread to them. The Fluted Clovis point spearhead used to hunt mammoths appears all over North America. Clovis man has been found in the Peace River, British Columbia, Nova Scotia, Washington, and Mexico. This unprecedented form of stone point has the conservatives puzzled, as it requires a very rapid spreading to fit their hypothesis. Conservatives suggest the Clovis Point likely only dates to 11,500 B.C. Another problem with this technology is that few Clovis points are discovered in Alaska and no Clovis points in Siberia except those dated 6,300 B.C. at Uptar which suggests an American to Asia migration. All evidence supports a south to north migration of this technology. The Clovis technology may have migrated from America to Asia. Many conservative scientists resort to science fiction type theories to explain these and other anomalies. |
| Aug25-08, 01:32 PM | #9 |
|
|
I didn't realize there was any evidence of a Polynesia-British Columbia connection. That is some of the most interesting stuff I have heard on PF for many a moon. Quite remarkable!
I don't know much about linguistics. don't know when the Hawaiian Islands are supposed to have been settled. Dont know how fast languages change. Can't guess when the last contact would have been, if there ever was contact, between Hawaii and the BC islands. Or maybe some words passed along by way of Tlingit? It all seems very tenuous. The way I picture it either 1. it is purely accidental that Guaii sounds like Hawaii, and that the Haida are big people (I imagine them like Tongans, good football linesmen) 2. it isn't accidental and there was some recent contact that nobody knows about and the words are actually from the same root! which sounds almost crazy 3. there was some kinship but the common ancestor was over 10,000 years ago and maybe involved Tlingits and the Bering Trek, and in that case it is all so remote I would think that language would have changed beyond all recognition and the two words could not be traced to a common root. But there could still be some traces of linguistic and genetic similarity. It is confused and only faintly suggestive, but absolutely fascinating! |
| Aug25-08, 01:56 PM | #10 |
|
|
But, then the problems with this theory are: If you look at South America and North America you can see that there are many points of entry to the two, conjoined continents. This leads me to believe there were many cultures embarking upon exploring the vast areas of these lands. And you can see the various genetic and cultural diversities even as early as the periods we're talking about. One find in the Yukon Territories, the "Blue Fish Caves" shows human habitation at 26,000 years ago. There are always going to be anomalies like this that throw everyone's "theories" off. There is the Northwest Passage that travels down the Rockies from Manning Park in BC. You can get to Mexico along that route and many "Native" stories from the interior and the coast speak of the travels to Mexico and beyond. One nation... the "Laxgalts'ap" and others have a direct genetic link with the native tribes in Mexico. The Laxgalts'ap traded their Obsidian... which was of fine quality... with them and many others around America and Central America. You're right to say that trade was a great "ice breaker" for different regions and we have to be able to distinguish between the original cultures works and those that have been traded. For instance, how mummies in Egypt test positive for cocaine and nicotine? The obvious answer... trade... |
| Aug25-08, 01:59 PM | #11 |
|
|
The more I learn the less I know about it. I have to dig up some of the stories from the Similkameen peoples in the interior... they talk about meeting the people on the southern tip of South America... by a method of "walking fast". But, I neglect my work so... cheers for now! |
| Aug26-08, 12:33 PM | #12 |
|
|
Here's what I could find for pictures of the "Mayan Underworld".
http://imagesoftheworld.org/mexico/cenote-cancun-mx.jpg http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1421/...f260d0.jpg?v=0 http://news.nationalgeographic.com/n.../11898621.html http://www.reuters.com/news/pictures...cienceNews#a=2 Interesting video about the rituals and some shots of the underground temples http://www.atitlan.net/video/mayan-religion.htm What appears to be new footage of the entrance and innards of the caves with shots of cave wall carving... http://www.reuters.com/news/video?vi...el=scienceNews |
| Aug26-08, 03:09 PM | #13 |
|
|
Someone who I think is named George Stewart tells it. I wonder what his reputation is, among anthropologists. He is in North Carolina, does that mean Chapel Hill UNC? Or is he freelance? |
| Aug26-08, 04:23 PM | #14 |
|
|
Thank you Baywax.
|
| Aug26-08, 04:45 PM | #15 |
|
|
I'm so wrong about the name of the trail from Manning park, east of Hope, BC to Mexico.
Its called the Pacific Crest Trail... and here's one link of many to a description of it. You can see why it was a viable trade route for over 7000 years... if not 15,000.... with all the game a healthy trade/explorer could eat. I have very little doubt that the Maya sent out ambassadors along this route (pronounced "root" here!!) and shared understanding and gifts with the people of the Pacific Northwest. |
| Aug26-08, 08:08 PM | #16 |
|
Mentor
Blog Entries: 4
|
Baywax, I've been menaing to tell you those are great links.
I too loved the story of the two brothers. I'd never heard that tale. |
| Aug27-08, 12:11 AM | #17 |
|
|
I visited a remote cave dwelling in the Similkameen Nation, the interior of BC. I have photos of the pictographs and the thousands of summer's worth of soot on its ceiling. I'll get them up here as soon as I find and scan them... with commentary. The coolest thing about these ones is that its a mix of the northern interior and the southern interior people's stories on the walls. The people in Montana and south of there would come up to the Similkameen territory, across today's boarder, to fish and hunt for the summer. I attempted to live that life while I was there, but you have to be very well trained at flint-knapping, spear fishing (illegal) and basically wrestling bears, cougars and wolverines. PS. Thanks Evo and Wolram! |
| Thread Closed |
| Thread Tools | |
Similar Threads for: The Mayan Underworld
|
||||
| Thread | Forum | Replies | ||
| 2012 mayan calender end of world astro line up opens stargate | General Discussion | 61 | ||