image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > Physics > General Physics


Reply

image Newton's Cradle office desk toy Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Nov23-09, 02:56 PM                  #1
techmologist

techmologist is Offline:
Posts: 63
Newton's Cradle office desk toy

How does this work? I know energy is roughly conserved. But why, for instance, doesn't the one metal ball bounce back off the others when it hits, and all the other balls move slightly in the other direction? Is it because the balls are separated by a thin gap?

  Reply With Quote
Old Nov23-09, 05:48 PM                  #2
A.T.

A.T. is Offline:
Posts: 1,034
Re: Newton's Cradle office desk toy

Originally Posted by techmologist View Post
I know energy is roughly conserved.
Not only energy but also momentum. Taken together it follows: If a moving mass elastically hits an identical resting mass, it transfers all momentum to it.
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov23-09, 06:09 PM                  #3
TurtleMeister

TurtleMeister is Offline:
Posts: 368
Re: Newton's Cradle office desk toy

You may find this Wikipedia page helpful in understanding elastic collisions.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elastic_collision
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov23-09, 08:09 PM                  #4
techmologist

techmologist is Offline:
Posts: 63
Re: Newton's Cradle office desk toy

A.T. and TurtleMeister:

Thank you. Sorry I forgot to mention in the OP that I know about elastic collisions. I understand that, at least during the collision, momentum is conserved along with energy. But then the strings pull the balls into a circular path.

In the picture there are five balls. If you pull one back and let it smash into the other four, it transfers all its momentum and energy, and the ball on the other end pops off with that same momentum. But this would not happen if we replaced the four identical balls with one ball which has four times the mass. The first ball would bounce back off the heavy ball without transferring all its energy.

I'm wondering if there are small gaps between the five balls or if they are touching when they hang at rest. If there are gaps, that would at least explain what happens when you pull back one ball. It slams into the second ball (the first one at rest), transferring all its momentum and energy, which in turn slams into the third ball, etc. But what about when you pull back two balls and release them? Would you expect two balls to transfer all their energy and momentum to the first ball at rest. That would seem to violate conservation of momentum and energy. But I think that in reality the two balls do transfer all their momentum and energy to the remaining three balls (whether or not it is transferred to each one successively, I don't know) . And somehow two balls pop off the other end with the same momentum the incoming two had.

I know this satisfies the conditions of conservation of momentum and energy, but it doesn't seem like the only possible result that could satisfy those conditions. So how is the momentum and energy communicated from one end to the other?
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov23-09, 11:31 PM                  #5
Jeff Reid

Jeff Reid is Offline:
Posts: 2,905
Re: Newton's Cradle office desk toy

Originally Posted by techmologist View Post
I'm wondering if there are small gaps between the five balls or if they are touching when they hang at rest.
Not sure if the gaps are needed. Video of a large scale model, here you can see that the ball does bounce back a bit, and that it's not perfect, with gaps bewteen some balls and not the others.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mFNe_pFZrsA&fmt=18
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 02:44 AM       Last edited by TurtleMeister; Nov24-09 at 02:59 AM..            #6
TurtleMeister

TurtleMeister is Offline:
Posts: 368
Re: Newton's Cradle office desk toy

Originally Posted by techmologist
In the picture there are five balls. If you pull one back and let it smash into the other four, it transfers all its momentum and energy, and the ball on the other end pops off with that same momentum. But this would not happen if we replaced the four identical balls with one ball which has four times the mass. The first ball would bounce back off the heavy ball without transferring all its energy.
Originally Posted by techmologist
I'm wondering if there are small gaps between the five balls or if they are touching when they hang at rest.
It makes no difference whether the balls are touching or not. As long as each ball is able to freely rebound off the other balls, the action will be observed.
Originally Posted by techmologist
I know this satisfies the conditions of conservation of momentum and energy, but it doesn't seem like the only possible result that could satisfy those conditions. So how is the momentum and energy communicated from one end to the other?
Here's another link that addresses that question.

http://www.lhup.edu/~dsimanek/scenario/cradle.htm
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 04:34 AM                  #7
A.T.

A.T. is Offline:
Posts: 1,034
Re: Newton's Cradle office desk toy

Originally Posted by techmologist View Post
But what about when you pull back two balls and release them? ...(whether or not it is transferred to each one successively, I don't know).
You can see it as happening successively. The inner of the two pulled balls, kicks off the most outer ball on the other side. Then the outer pulled ball impacts and kicks of the second ball on the other side.
  Reply With Quote
Old Nov24-09, 06:49 PM                  #8
techmologist

techmologist is Offline:
Posts: 63
Re: Newton's Cradle office desk toy

Originally Posted by TurtleMeister View Post
It makes no difference whether the balls are touching or not. As long as each ball is able to freely rebound off the other balls, the action will be observed.


Here's another link that addresses that question.

http://www.lhup.edu/~dsimanek/scenario/cradle.htm
That is a fantastic link. It is as if the author read my mind and knew what questions I had. The rest of that website looks interesting, too. Thanks!


Originally Posted by Jeff Reid
Not sure if the gaps are needed. Video of a large scale model, here you can see that the ball does bounce back a bit, and that it's not perfect, with gaps bewteen some balls and not the others.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mFNe_pFZrsA&fmt=18
That is a very cool demonstration with the "duck pin" bowling balls. thank you.
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Newton's Cradle office desk toy
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Newton's Cradle HoloBarre General Physics 1 Jul30-09 01:15 PM
Newton's Cradle faunmia Introductory Physics 2 Mar18-08 03:06 PM
newton's cradle adamg Classical Physics 2 Jan28-05 06:36 PM
Newton's cradle 7bear General Physics 4 Oct2-04 11:06 PM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image