New Reply

In the classical view of the electron, would the electron "fall" into the nucleus?

 
Share Thread
Mar7-12, 05:00 PM   #1
 

In the classical view of the electron, would the electron "fall" into the nucleus?


I'm not asking why the electron doesn't fall into the nucleus. I know this is explained by quantum mechanics.

But in class the other day, my professor said that treating the electron as a classical particle would lead to it crashing into the nucleus. This didn't really make sense to me. An electron experiences a coulombic force from the nucleus, much like a planet experiences a gravitational force from a star. With a classical view of the electron, wouldn't the electrons just adopt an elliptical orbit like a planet on a much smaller scale, or is there some other distinction between a planet and an electron where the electron would act differently and "fall" into the nucleus?

I know the classical view is wrong, I just didn't know if this reasoning really applied.
PhysOrg.com physics news on PhysOrg.com

>> Is there an invisible tug-of-war behind bad hearts and power outages?
>> Penetrating the quantum nature of magnetism
>> Rethinking the universe: Groundbreaking theory proposed in 1997 suggests a 'multiverse'
Mar7-12, 05:50 PM   #2
 
Mentor
A classical electron would radiate and lose energy.
Mar7-12, 05:52 PM   #3
 
Quote by Vanadium 50 View Post
A classical electron would radiate and lose energy.
Gotcha, thanks.
New Reply

Similar discussions for: In the classical view of the electron, would the electron "fall" into the nucleus?
Thread Forum Replies
Spin and orbit velocity of electron slows down approaching "c"? General Physics 23
Explanation why dosen't the electron fall into the nucleus? Quantum Physics 74
why doesn't the electron fall into the nucleus!? Quantum Physics 104
why according to classical, electron circuling around the nucleus will emit EM wave? General Physics 4
Do protons also exist as "proton waves" similar to the "electron waves"? High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics 8