
#1
Nov3011, 02:52 PM

P: 23

Suppose we have a spring placed vertically on a table. We put a body with mass "m" on it. The spring compresses by "x".
Then sum of forces is zero, therefore: kx=mg, so k=mg/x But if we look on it as the energy problem, then: we hold the body on the string, then we release it, so loss of gravitational potential energy is "mgx" and gain of spring energy is 0.5*k*x^2. From that: k=2mg/x, which contradicts previous equation. Where I did a mistake? 



#2
Nov3011, 03:07 PM

Mentor
P: 40,875





#3
Nov3011, 03:09 PM

P: 1,506

This is a well known question dealing with springs !!!!
When you lower a weight onto a spring the force exerted on the spring increases from 0 up to the maximum (the weight of the object). Therefore the work done compressing the spring = AVERAGE force x distance = 0.5F x distance. During the placing of a weight on a spring your hand is part of the process and ensures that the force on the spring increases from 0 to the maximum. On the other hand (sorry !!!!!) if you release (drop) the weight then the force on the spring is constant (mg) for the compression and the extra (0.5mgh) energy appears as KE... the mass on the spring will bounce up and down Doc Al has said the same !!!! 



#4
Dec111, 04:46 AM

P: 23

Mass on a spring
Thanks for both explanations :)




#5
Mar412, 11:01 AM

P: 9

I'd also like to thank Doc Al and technician for the answers. I missed this thread last month when I asked nearly the same question:
http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=576713 Incidentally, I received a notashelpful answer from the askthephysicist.com site when I inquired there: I understand that when the mass is placed on the spring, displacement x = mg/k. When the mass is dropped on the spring, (nonequilibrium) displacement x = 2mg/k. Per my question in the other thread, if we instead fired the mass horizontally at a wallmounted spring… we can no longer talk of g, so have to look at the projectile's KE in terms of its mass and velocity. Doing so, we get: x = √(m/k) * v (momentarily, anyway, before the spring completely pushes the mass away again) Is that correct? The confirmation would be greatly appreciated. (The difference between x proportionate to m/k when the mass is placed or dropped onto the spring, vs proportionate to √(m/k) when it's fired at the sidemounted spring, is what had me confused… but I believe I now see the misunderstanding that led to my confusion.) 



#6
Mar412, 11:09 AM

Mentor
P: 40,875





#7
Mar812, 08:39 AM

P: 9

Of course, an answer here just leads to more questions there… but that's for other threads down the road. Thanks again!



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Three spring two mass system, compression of the middle spring  Introductory Physics Homework  3  
Spring Constant given mass, and equivalent mass in free fall from fixed height.  Introductory Physics Homework  3  
spring mass spring mass spring  2 balls oscillations  General Math  1  
Finding a spring constant of a spring holding a mass  Advanced Physics Homework  1  
what happens in acompletely reversing massspring system? (spring turns inside out)  Introductory Physics Homework  2 