Register to reply

When light moves what moves

by bobsmith76
Tags: light, moves
Share this thread:
Apr6-12, 04:51 AM
P: 339
Here's a question from my textbook. Since there are no calculations I put this in this forum rather than the hmwk forum.

When light (or other electromagnetic radiation) travels across a given region, what is it that oscillates? What is it that is transported?

Here is the answer provided:

Energy moves. No matter moves. You could say that electric and magnetic fields move, but it is nicer to say that the fields stay at that point and oscillate. The fields vary in time, like sports fans in the grandstand when the crowd does the wave. The fields constitute the medium for the wave, and energy moves.

I thought it was the photon that moves. Maybe I'm thinking of the photon as a particle when it's not really a particle but only has particle like properties.
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on
Engineers develop new sensor to detect tiny individual nanoparticles
Tiny particles have big potential in debate over nuclear proliferation
Ray tracing and beyond
Apr6-12, 10:08 AM
P: 643
Okay. This involves a little quantum physics. I might not be qualified to answer this question, as I only have a basic understanding of it, but here goes.

The photon isn't "really" a particle or a wave. Or it's both. In some experiments, it shows particle-like properties, and in others, it appears to show wave-like ones. (In fact, from observations, in some experiments it acts exactly like a particle and in others, exactly like a wave.) I'd imagine that in this experiment, it would exhibit wave-like properties as opposed to particle-like ones.

This sound confusing? Welcome to Quantum Mechanics.
Apr6-12, 10:14 AM
DaveC426913's Avatar
P: 15,319
Quote Quote by bobsmith76 View Post
I thought it was the photon that moves. Maybe I'm thinking of the photon as a particle when it's not really a particle but only has particle like properties.
It's a particle, it's just a massless particle.

Whovian's answer is a good description.

Thing to remember is that all words (such as "particle") are approximations and analogies. No amount of words can properly describe anything subatomic. What describes them is the formulae. Words are simply metaphors to help us visualize things. "The photon is like a particle". Like any analogy, it can be carried too far.

Apr6-12, 10:23 AM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 39,568
When light moves what moves

From the "electromagnetic wave" point of view (as opposed to the "photon" point of view) the wave is changes (increases and decreases) in the strength of the electric and magnetic fields (or the "electromagnetic" field), not actual motion of anything.
Apr6-12, 10:26 AM
P: 5,632
All the above sounds good.....
electromagnetic waves carry energy in a 'nothing'....there is no background material, no mass,no atoms, no particles, required, just space and time; with sound waves in contrast, energy is also transferred but requires a medium, like air or water or metal...some mass, some particles, to carry the energy.

When light travels in a medium, like glass, things get more complicated.....that's another discussion.

Also, it should be noted that while not requiring a material medium, light CAN cause a medium to gain energy....the photoelectric effect is such a situation in which incident light can set orbital electrons into different energy levels.....

Register to reply

Related Discussions
If an object moves towards you at light speed, what would you see? Special & General Relativity 7
Star moves faster than light Special & General Relativity 18
Light moves at C from all frames of references? Special & General Relativity 9
How do we know Gravity Moves the Speed of Light? Special & General Relativity 11
How light moves General Physics 7