Register to reply

Question about a magnet and normal force.

by port31
Tags: force, magnet, normal
Share this thread:
Nov10-12, 05:45 AM
P: 20
Lets assume that liquid superconductors exist. Now I place a magnet above a pool of the
liquid. Now will the surface of the liquid remain level or will it appear to have dent in it.
Im not sure I kind of back and forth in my head.
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on
Engineers develop new sensor to detect tiny individual nanoparticles
Tiny particles have big potential in debate over nuclear proliferation
Ray tracing and beyond
Nov10-12, 07:38 AM
Sci Advisor
P: 2,470
If there was a fluid that was superconducting and would remain superconducting throughout its volume despite deformations and flows, then yes, there would be a dent, because that would reduce energy in magnetic field, allowing gravitational potential energy to increase.

However, theories of superconductivity I am familiar with require a lattice. Therefore, a conventional superconductor will not be able to exist in a fluid state.

There are some hypothetical ways around that. Option one. We might be dealing with superfluid. An ionic superfluid would also be a superconductor. If like Helium such a superfluid would exist as combination of superfluid and normal phases, the magnetic field would only expel the superfluid phase. So fluid surface would remain level, but properties of the fluid near and away from magnet would be different. I am not aware of any material, even a hypothetical one, that would fit the bill. So this is pure conjecture.

Option two is supersolid. It's effectively a superfluid with a lattice. In principle, it could be a superconductor. The only material to have been theorized to be a supersolid superconductor is metallic hydrogen, and by that point we are in crazy territory. If such a phase of hydrogen exists, its interaction with magnetic field would be absolutely bizarre, and I wouldn't even try to make a prediction.
Nov10-12, 05:55 PM
P: 20
Its not clear to me why the gravitational potential energy would increase or why
it would reduce energy in the B field.
thanks for your post

Register to reply

Related Discussions
Can the force exerted by a perm magnet be equated to electro magnet watts? General Physics 3
A simple question about a magnet's force on a steel bar Classical Physics 0
Magnet pull force Question's General Physics 1
Question with Normal Force Introductory Physics Homework 4
Question with normal force Introductory Physics Homework 15