
#1
Nov2712, 09:33 AM

P: 3

Hi. I'm studying (introduction to) QFT, and I'm really lost. If possible, I'd like a pointer to a good textbook on the subject. I'll give an example of my confusion with a question:
I think I've understood phi(x) as a classical scalar field, what it is and how to use it in a lagngian for classical field theory.Before even getting into any of the ugly calculations and normalizations, I'm trying to understand the basic "rules and players". What are the different operators and functions, what do they depend on, what do their values means, how are they dynamical... I'm very mathematically minded, so I'm hoping to find a book in that style. As an example  I really like Sean Carroll's General Relativity textbook. 



#2
Nov2712, 09:48 AM

P: 640

Quantum Field Theory in a Nutshell, A. Zee, Princeton Univ Press, 2003 (although, I believe there is a newer edition).




#3
Nov2712, 09:53 AM

P: 3

I actually skimmed it already and I thought it didn't go into detail much of definitions and how to go from classical field to quantum field, but maybe I didn't give it enough of a chance, I'll try it now, look more carefully, since it's such a short book anyway. Thanks!




#4
Nov2712, 10:26 AM

Sci Advisor
P: 5,307

Looking for book on Introduction to QFT
From what I read in the forum I wouldn't propose Zee; what about Ryder?
And then there is Srednicki's free draft: http://web.physics.ucsb.edu/~mark/qft.html 



#5
Nov2712, 10:42 AM

P: 640

Check out this thread, too: http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=654697




#6
Nov2712, 11:59 AM

P: 123

If you are mathematically minded, grab hold of Hatfield "QFT of point particles and strings" (I feel like an echo chamber sometimes, always recommending this.) It nicely explains the basics in three different ways. Srednicki is also quite nice. Many people don't like it, but I would also recommend to have a look at Bob Klaubers qftfieldtheoryinfo site  he has an idiosyncratic take on many concepts (like vacuum fluctuations, where I am sure he is wrong...), but he explains the basics in a very didactic (and mathematical) way and he always states clearly when what he writes is not the standard interpretation.
Your confusion with the meaning of phi is possibly due to the fact that "What is phi in QFT" has two completely different answers: In path integral formulation, phi is a classical field that has a value at each spacetime point. The path integral accounts for the quantummechanical superposition of different possible field values. In canonical formulation, the phi's become operators because at least in principle, the classical phi(x) is an observable. The trouble (at least to my understanding for a long time) is that these operators of course have to act on quantum state vectors  usually the vacuum state; and almost nobody tells you what that is (Hatfield does in detail, Srednicki has an exercise on it, but without a solution that may not help you much and be frustrating). I wrote a bit on that in this thread: http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=654697 



#7
Nov2712, 07:36 PM

P: 123

I strongly recomment you to study Weinberg's book "The Quantum Theory of Fields, vol 1  Foundations" . It requires some knowledge of group theory to get start and a good understanding of general QM formalism. You will see that quantum fields are a direct consequence of the CORRECT merging of QM and SR. In my opinion, the second quantization approach (wich involves fields turning to operators this is not the case of this book) is just a makeshift (like Dirac sea) in order to solve the paradoxes that appear when someone does relativistic wavemeachanics. Try Weinberg's method (if it is not too hard for you) and your confusion will probably disappear.




#8
Nov2812, 12:47 AM

P: 123

Shows how tastes differ  I hate the Weinbergbook because to me it seems never to get to the actual physical interpretation of the equations.
Probably the best idea is to read the first two chapters or so of several QFTbooks and see which ones you like best. 



#9
Nov2812, 03:21 AM

Sci Advisor
P: 869

Weinberg is nice if you already know the subject and want to deepen your understanding. For an introduction I think it's absolutely not the right book to start with. The same goes for Zee's book: that has some really nice things in it, but for an introduction it's not good, mainly because of the lack of rigour and computations. If you know the subject already a bit it's a very nice book to read, because it gives clarifications and insights which are not (or hard) to be found elsewhere.
I would recommend Ryder or Srednicki. I also found Peskin&Schroeder nice (that's the book I really used as my first introduction), they stress the second quantization and only at half the book introduce path integrals. It has a lot of computational details in it, but also give nice conceptual explanations. 



#10
Nov2812, 03:45 AM

P: 318

Glad to see I am not alone, I started the thread suggested above and am still very very confused.
I too, have no idea what the "rules and players" are. It would be very helpful if someone gave us a direct list of posulates like the case in Shankar's principle of quantum mechanics. For example do the X and P operators for particle states still apply? How do I solve the basic problem of physcs, If I leave some multiparticle in A state, what happens to it some time T after in my frame?? 



#11
Nov2812, 06:57 AM

P: 3

Thanks for the replies everyone!
HomogenousCow, I'm also glad to see I'm not the only one with these questions, your confusion seems very similar to mine. Interesting timing we had... I've been recommended a few things by a few people, so here's my summary, in order of recommendation: Lectures Notes: 0) http://isites.harvard.edu/fs/docs/ic...Relativity.pdf (background) 1) http://arxiv.org/pdf/1110.5013v4  Lecture notes by Sidney Coleman, recognized by some as the best available 2) http://isites.harvard.edu/icb/icb.do...icb.page507113 3) http://www.physics.utoronto.ca/~luke...cturenotes.pdf Books: 1. Srednicki (free pdf, can email for solutions) 2. Zee (nutshell) 3. Peskin & Schroeder 4. Weinberg  The Quantum Theory Of Fields Vol 1 Foundations A more mathematical book  Brian F. Hatfield  Quantum Field Theory Of Point Particles And Strings Somewhat nonstandard book  Robert D. Klauber  http://www.quantumfieldtheory.info/ Another book  Lewis H. Ryder  Quantum Field Theory Postulates for relativistic QFT are in section 3.5 of http://uqu.edu.sa/files2/tiny_mce/pl...2179/non11.pdf So right now, my plan is to read (0) and (1), with filling in holes from 1. I haven't started yet, I'll report back how it goes... 



#12
Nov2812, 08:00 AM

P: 318

I'm looking for a book like shankars treatment of QM, starting from he vey bare bone structure to advanced stuff




#13
Nov2812, 10:55 AM

P: 123

"For example do the X and P operators for particle states still apply?"
Not really. Since you want to be relativistic, you have to treat t and x on the same footing. In QM, t is a "label", x is an operator. In QFT, you would either have to make the time an operator (difficult), or consider t and x as a label of a field. Then you have two possibilities: Either you use the path integral and treat the field as a classical field, or you promote the field to an operator acting on states. @ods You mght also try Michael stones "The physics of quantum fields", that's also wellwritten. 



#14
Nov2812, 12:03 PM

P: 270





#15
Jun1813, 04:17 AM

P: 16

Srednicki's book is very frustrating for a beginner who is studying it without any teachers help. Peskin or Ryder is good for starting QFT. Srednicki uses [tex]\phi^3[/tex] theory and there are no additional resources available on the net compatible with this book. You may find some class notes/slides which are not very helpful.



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Introduction to Proof Book  Science & Math Textbook Listings  0  
I need a new introduction to physics book..  Science & Math Textbook Listings  1  
Suggest a book for introduction to DFT  Science & Math Textbook Listings  0  
Book for introduction in aerodynamics  Mechanical Engineering  6  
Best Introduction to Calculus Book  Calculus  39 