MATLAB accumarray problem

atrus_ovis

accumarray documentation
Is anyone proficient in the use of accumarray?
I supply two vectors of same length, indices L,weights W, L positive integers as required.
I sort the indices to ascending.Then, the result of accumarray is not equal to unique(L).How could this be?
Code for illustration:

Code:

i = [46    47    47    46    48    49    48    48    48]';
w = 2*rand(size(i));
Y=[i';w'];
[x y] = sort(Y(1,:));
Y = Y(:,y);
Y,pause
uw = accumarray((Y(1,:))',Y(2,:)');

ui = unique(i);
numel(uw),numel(ui)

--- OUTPUT :

Y =

   46.0000   46.0000   47.0000   47.0000   48.0000   48.0000   48.0000   48.0000   49.0000
    1.5844    0.0714    1.9190    1.3115    1.6983    1.3575    1.5155    1.4863    1.8680


ans =

    49


ans =

     4

I get 49 weight vectors for the 9 indices, the unique of which are 4!

MATLABdude

It took me a few passes to read through the documentation and understand it, but I think the key is where it explains what the function actually does (and then apply that to the first example).

Quote by MATLAB accumarray documentation

The function processes the input as follows:

Find out how many unique indices there are in subs. Each unique index defines a bin in the output array. The maximum index value in subs determines the size of the output array.
Find out how many times each index is repeated.
This determines how many elements of vals are going to be accumulated at each bin in the output array.
Create an output array. The output array is of size max(subs) or of size sz.
Accumulate the entries in vals into bins using the values of the indices in subs and apply fun to the entries in each bin.
Fill the values in the output for positions not referred to by subs. Default fill value is zero; use fillval to set a different value.

In the case of the example, the output size is the maximum of the subs array--4. The subs array acts as an array of subscripts applied to the values contained in val. 101 is given a subscript of 1, 102 and 104 given subscripts of 2, 103 and 105 given subscripts of 4, and none given subscripts of 3. Bin labels, if you want to think of it in histogram terms.

When you apply accumarray to them, the first entry will be the sum of those elements with subscript 1, the second with subscript 2, and so on. Which is why the output array has a sum of zero for the third element (none of the elements of val were subscripted with three).

In your case:

uw has 49 elements because that's the largest of the values contained in i.
uw probably only has six non-zero elements--uw(46) through uw(49)
uw(1:45) are zero

I hope this helps in your understanding of what's going on in this portion of your work, because I don't have any experience with the larger problem that you're working on.

atrus_ovis

Yes i got it eventually.
In my example,to add you just use the weights
uw(ui)

Similar Threads for: MATLAB accumarray problem
Thread	Forum	Replies
MATLAB problem	Introductory Physics Homework	1
Matlab Problem	Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework	0
Matlab ODE problem	Math & Science Software	3
MATLab Problem	Math & Science Software	3
Another Matlab problem	Math & Science Software	4

atrus_ovis	Yes i got it eventually. In my example,to add you just use the weights uw(ui)