How Difficult is it to get PhD in physics


by adam_96
Tags: difficult, physics
adam_96
adam_96 is offline
#1
Jan15-13, 03:37 PM
P: 3
I'm 16 and have applied to sixth form to do all 3 sciences and maths.
How difficult is it to get a PhD in physics and then become a particle physacist?
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Cougars' diverse diet helped them survive the Pleistocene mass extinction
Cyber risks can cause disruption on scale of 2008 crisis, study says
Mantis shrimp stronger than airplanes
ModusPwnd
ModusPwnd is offline
#2
Jan15-13, 03:44 PM
P: 855
Very difficult. Nearly all who try fail, or at least change their mind. Check out the "So you want to be a physicist" thread for some insight into the process.

https://docs.google.com/document/pub...3R7_OEHM&pli=1
adam_96
adam_96 is offline
#3
Jan15-13, 04:05 PM
P: 3
Quite helpful thanks

TMFKAN64
TMFKAN64 is offline
#4
Jan16-13, 01:46 AM
P: 1,079

How Difficult is it to get PhD in physics


Let's be clear on the hard part... "and then become a particle physicist".

Not to belittle the accomplishment of getting a Ph.D., but if you are very determined and have some talent for math and a keen interest in physics, you can probably get a Ph.D. in physics. The hard part is to find a job in the field after you graduate.
Locrian
Locrian is offline
#5
Jan16-13, 08:29 AM
P: 1,696
It should be pretty difficult, but I saw more than a few people do mediocre work, hang around for 7 years, and get scooted out the door with a PhD. I'm not the only one to mention the seven year boot on this forum.
adam_96
adam_96 is offline
#6
Jan20-13, 03:30 PM
P: 3
Currently I'm doing GCSE's and have an interview for sixth form (where I will do physics, chemistry, biology and maths) so what do I have to do to get a career as a researcher. I would like to work for CERN as a theoretical physacist, I have looked at job vacancies to see what I would need, a phd and 5-10 years as a researcher with published papers that have made an actual contribution to the scientific community. So what do I have to do from now to end up as a researcher and then go on to CERN?
Shisnu
Shisnu is offline
#7
Jan21-13, 04:59 AM
P: 16
I would have possibly suggested taking Further Maths instead of Biology, but this isn't really a big deal as long as the course you go onto at university (I assume you're planning on going to uni?) has a strong basis in advanced maths.

However, my advice would probably be not to worry too much about your career at this stage and rather to focus on what you enjoy doing. After all, you are just starting out on the road of higher education and what you enjoy now may not be what you enjoy doing later.

I would highly recommend to look at getting a summer internship at CERN or somewhere similar so you can experience first hand what they do.

If you have an interest for Maths, Chemistry, Physics and Biology, there'll be a whole multitude of things you could end up doing that you would love, a particle physicist is but one choice.
Cbray
Cbray is offline
#8
Jan26-13, 07:43 AM
P: 135
"get a PhD in physics and then become a particle physacist?" - You make it sound so easy.
Vampyr
Vampyr is offline
#9
Feb8-13, 03:48 PM
P: 28
Quote Quote by Locrian View Post
It should be pretty difficult, but I saw more than a few people do mediocre work, hang around for 7 years, and get scooted out the door with a PhD. I'm not the only one to mention the seven year boot on this forum.
In the UK it's a 4 year boot so even easier
ModusPwnd
ModusPwnd is offline
#10
Feb8-13, 04:02 PM
P: 855
At my grad school the average PhD time was 7.6 years... There was more than one past their 10th year.
G01
G01 is offline
#11
Feb9-13, 08:55 AM
HW Helper
G01's Avatar
P: 2,688
Quote Quote by ModusPwnd View Post
Very difficult. Nearly all who try fail
A PhD is hard but c'mon. This is a bit melodramatic!

The average time to PhD at my physics department is 5.7 years for post bachelor's candidates.
ModusPwnd
ModusPwnd is offline
#12
Feb9-13, 12:04 PM
P: 855
Quote Quote by G01 View Post
A PhD is hard but c'mon. This is a bit melodramatic!
I dont think so. Of an incoming class of physics freshman who want to get PhDs I would say less than 10% do. How many of of the incoming class who want to do particle physics get a career in it? Probably 5% or less. There is massive attrition at each and every step of the process.
Mépris
Mépris is offline
#13
Feb9-13, 12:42 PM
P: 826
^
I reckon G01 thought that the "nearly all who try fail" comment was directed at people who have already entered grad programs? Well, that's what I thought anyway!

---

OP, if you have a broad interest in the sciences (and it seems so; why else would you not take further maths and additional further maths instead of chem and bio?), you shouldn't restrain yourself to one subject now, let alone, one specific sub-field of that subject! Your interests can change.

You may find that you really dig systems biology or climate science, and then do grad work there instead! Or that you just don't like uni-level physics, and go find a job instead. Or maybe you end up really liking philosophy of science.

Right now, assuming you want to stay in the UK, the best thing to do is get the best grades you can. As far as I'm aware, that's all that's required to get into a "top uni" in the UK. Excluding Oxbridge, of course, where one would have interviews.
G01
G01 is offline
#14
Feb9-13, 12:49 PM
HW Helper
G01's Avatar
P: 2,688
Quote Quote by Mépris View Post
^
I reckon G01 thought that the "nearly all who try fail" comment was directed at people who have already entered grad programs? Well, that's what I thought anyway!
That is what I thought. I would agree that most Physics B.S. holders do not go on to grad school. That is not the same thing as most people who try to get a Physics PhD fail, however.

Alot of people decide they do not want to go to grad school. It is a bit unfair to consider someone who decides not to do grad school as 'failing.'
ModusPwnd
ModusPwnd is offline
#15
Feb10-13, 10:18 AM
P: 855
Quote Quote by Mépris View Post
^
I reckon G01 thought that the "nearly all who try fail" comment was directed at people who have already entered grad programs? Well, that's what I thought anyway!
The OP is 16. He/She is not even in undergrad yet.




Quote Quote by G01 View Post
I would agree that most Physics B.S. holders do not go on to grad school. That is not the same thing as most people who try to get a Physics PhD fail, however.

Alot of people decide they do not want to go to grad school. It is a bit unfair to consider someone who decides not to do grad school as 'failing.'
Maybe you should re-read my original quote.

In either case, nearly all physics undergrads start with an intent to do a PhD. Most of them dont get one. Whether they want to view it as though they changed their mind rather than failed, it doesnt really matter. Even if you are going to look at students already in PhD programs my statement is still true, most who want to get a career in particle physics will not do so.
wolfmax
wolfmax is offline
#16
Feb11-13, 05:13 AM
P: 16
I don't think most undergrads start a physics degree with the intent to do a PhD. At least that's not my experience. But this may be due to the ability to be more laissez faire in the UK system.

To the op. Your A levels sound fine. If you could slot in further maths AS it will give you an edge in red brick unis. Study an intergrated masters get a 2:1 and you should be able to get on a PhD program. Easy as that
Lavabug
Lavabug is offline
#17
Feb11-13, 05:46 AM
P: 849
Quote Quote by wolfmax View Post
I don't think most undergrads start a physics degree with the intent to do a PhD.
Almost all the physics undergrads I know started their degree because they wanted to do science as a job, which unwitting to them or not, requires a phd at the professional level. Only a few because they weren't sure what they wanted to do. Out of my entering class of about 40 only 3-5 of us have the intention of going onto postgraduate studies, most realized they didn't like the subject as much halfway into the degree.

I think the real question is whether you'll change your mind later down the line, which is a very real possibility, rather than how difficult it is to get into grad school and pass your dissertation.
wolfmax
wolfmax is offline
#18
Feb11-13, 10:00 AM
P: 16
We have obviously had different experiences. In my year I would say 25% want to do a PhD, 25% just did physics as route into finance and 50% don't know what they want to do. This may change now with the trebling of tuition fees, so new students want a set career plan before starting uni.
Quote Quote by Lavabug View Post
I think the real question is whether you'll change your mind later down the line, which is a very real possibility, rather than how difficult it is to get into grad school and pass your dissertation.
I definitely agree with this. Don't worry about how hard/easy something is to do, you'll probably change plans anyway. I couldn't see myself doing a PhD, now i'm applying. If you like physics study it and see where it takes you.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Why is intro physics difficult for me? Academic Guidance 18
Difficult Calculus/ Physics Calculus 0
How difficult: First year calculus-based physics without Grade 12 physics? Academic Guidance 13
difficult physics problems. need help! Introductory Physics Homework 1
Why is Physics GRE more difficult than that of Mathematics!? General Physics 8