Register to reply

Did hitler personally kill anyone?

by Smurf
Tags: hitler, kill, personally
Share this thread:
Smurf
#1
Nov26-05, 03:25 PM
P: 2,891
As far as I'm aware the thing Hitler personally and directly killed was his dogs whom he poisoned. Everyone else was killed by his Waffen SS or soldiers. Does anyone know any time he actually directly murdered anyone?
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
Animals first flex their muscles
What can 14th century Venice teach us about Ebola and other emerging threats?
Fact or fiction: Which do moviegoers prefer?
russ_watters
#2
Nov26-05, 03:51 PM
Mentor
P: 22,294
I'm not sure, but I tend to doubt that he did. Guys like him don't need to do the messy work for themselves.
selfAdjoint
#3
Nov26-05, 04:45 PM
Emeritus
PF Gold
P: 8,147
Does anyone know if he killed anybody as a soldier in WWI?

Pengwuino
#4
Nov26-05, 06:30 PM
PF Gold
Pengwuino's Avatar
P: 7,120
Did hitler personally kill anyone?

Well, a quick look in wiki says he was a messenger so he probably didn't kill anyone in WW1
Smurf
#5
Nov26-05, 08:19 PM
P: 2,891
but he did get a few medals in WW1 and he was wounded 3 times, so he did see action.
Pengwuino
#6
Nov26-05, 08:33 PM
PF Gold
Pengwuino's Avatar
P: 7,120
Quote Quote by Smurf
but he did get a few medals in WW1 and he was wounded 3 times, so he did see action.
Says he took some rather dangerous missions...
Smurf
#7
Nov26-05, 10:04 PM
P: 2,891
did he kill anyone on those missions?
chound
#8
Nov27-05, 08:34 AM
P: 239
Is there any good character about Hitler.
I'm really impressed by his ability to inspire so many people to kill Jews.
His mustach(wot's the correct spelling) and haircut is really cool!!!!!
selfAdjoint
#9
Nov27-05, 11:49 AM
Emeritus
PF Gold
P: 8,147
Quote Quote by chound
Is there any good character about Hitler.
I'm really impressed by his ability to inspire so many people to kill Jews.
His mustach(wot's the correct spelling) and haircut is really cool!!!!!
I just can't understand this attitude, that you can abstract "cool" elements for current use from the image of one of the most horrible persons in history. Similarly you see images of Che and Mao used for purely decorative purposes. What message does this send to future generations?
Pengwuino
#10
Nov27-05, 04:23 PM
PF Gold
Pengwuino's Avatar
P: 7,120
Quote Quote by selfAdjoint
I just can't understand this attitude, that you can abstract "cool" elements for current use from the image of one of the most horrible persons in history. Similarly you see images of Che and Mao used for purely decorative purposes. What message does this send to future generations?
Might as well throw in the swastika for that matter. Maybe .1% of the kids who wear things like that even know of its pre-Nazi meaning... which leaves the rest of these idiots walking around with a symbol of one of the worst displays of genocide in modern times. I also have a problem with its use for political protests. I've heard quite a few WW2 over the years say its use in the US for political protests are disrespectful to outright disgusting. They say nothing in the United State's recent history, no act of congress, ideological group, politician, etc etc could even come close to what the Nazi's did. I am still rather amazed such a movement and its actions could have ever existed in such recent times but I'm even more .. well disgusted at how kids these days seem so far removed from what actually happened that they'll use such symbols for whatever purpose without a second though.
zoobyshoe
#11
Dec1-05, 03:00 AM
zoobyshoe's Avatar
P: 5,630
Quote Quote by Smurf
did he kill anyone on those missions?
There's no record or report of him ever having killed anyone with his own two hands.

I'm curious as to why you ask, though. Given the 50,000,000 people who died in WWII, what particular difference would it make if he'd personally killed any of them?
scott1
#12
Dec5-05, 10:42 PM
P: 459
Quote Quote by selfAdjoint
Does anyone know if he killed anybody as a soldier in WWI?
WWI.In his autobiography he said that he was in combat but he just made that up he was just a courier during WWI.
zoobyshoe
#13
Dec6-05, 12:40 AM
zoobyshoe's Avatar
P: 5,630
Quote Quote by scott1
WWI.In his autobiography he said that he was in combat but he just made that up he was just a courier during WWI.
His position as courier involved getting messages around during firefights and shelling. He "saw" plenty of combat, was wasn't participating in it himself.
Bystander
#14
Dec6-05, 01:49 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 1,384
"Courier" carries a connotation of something along the lines of "the singing telegram" in Clue; he was a "runner" at the "small unit" level, keeping OPs, LPs, Co. HQ, bunkers, and the like in communication with one another. Bottom line? He worked in "trench knife" country, and survived the war. Did he have to fight his way out of ambushes, trench raids, or any of the other "no man's land" and near "no man's land" festivities of the time? Unknown. He did pick up an Iron Cross, and that ain't too shabby for the enlisted ranks in that army in that war; suggests he may have had to do a little more than deliver Xmas cards.

"Murder?" Depending upon sources, there are questions surrounding Rohm's death and the death of one of his early girlfriends.
zoobyshoe
#15
Dec6-05, 02:11 AM
zoobyshoe's Avatar
P: 5,630
You're saying someone thinks he executed Rohm himself?
Bystander
#16
Dec6-05, 10:51 AM
Sci Advisor
HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 1,384
That's an inference drawn from accounts of the event --- and you just had to ask me whose inference (not percolating to the conscious level at the moment) --- based upon a lot of second-hand and circumstantial "testimony:" Hitler supposedly was carrying a drawn pistol when storming Rohm's residence; his orderly borrowed cleaning equipment following the event; and an unscheduled change of clothing. Strikes me the source is on the "suspicious" shelf alongside The Mind of Adolf Hitler, the OSS commissioned psychological profile.
NewScientist
#17
Dec6-05, 11:50 AM
P: 246
To my knowledge he never killed anybod and looking at him from a psychoanalytical historical point of view, and reading the studies I have, i believe it is outside of his character.

Rohm and Hitler were close - rohm had been with him since the beginning and was killed solely as a method of pacifing the army and conservatives. Rohm was killed by the SS and Army on the Knight of the Long Knives.

Oh actually hitler killed his family
zoobyshoe
#18
Dec6-05, 02:31 PM
zoobyshoe's Avatar
P: 5,630
Quote Quote by Bystander
That's an inference drawn from accounts of the event --- and you just had to ask me whose inference (not percolating to the conscious level at the moment) --- based upon a lot of second-hand and circumstantial "testimony:" Hitler supposedly was carrying a drawn pistol when storming Rohm's residence; his orderly borrowed cleaning equipment following the event; and an unscheduled change of clothing. Strikes me the source is on the "suspicious" shelf alongside The Mind of Adolf Hitler, the OSS commissioned psychological profile.
Under the circumstances I suppose there is some remote possibility he shot Rohm himself, althought it's out of character for him. But there was at least one other time he almost shot someone when he happened to have a pistol and was in a frenzy: himself. It was the wife of Ernst Hanfstaengle who physically stopped him. She had been trained in Judo.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Would you shoot Hitler? General Discussion 79
Do you personally think school is something you need? General Discussion 12
Have you been PERSONALLY wronged by the US? Current Events 57