Calculating Free Electron Density in a Metal Wire

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating the density of free electrons in a metal wire and the power consumption of a light bulb when connected to a lower voltage outlet. The original poster presents calculations related to both scenarios but expresses uncertainty about the correctness of their results.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the relationship between current, drift velocity, and electron density, questioning the omission of the electron charge in calculations. There are attempts to clarify the definitions of "n" and "ne" and their respective units. Additionally, discussions arise regarding the impact of voltage on power consumption for the light bulb.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with each other's calculations and reasoning. Some offer guidance on how to approach the problems, while others express confusion about specific steps and terminology. There is a recognition of the need to verify calculations and assumptions, particularly regarding the definitions of variables and units.

Contextual Notes

There are constraints related to the homework rules, including the requirement for answers in specific units. Participants also note the importance of significant figures in their calculations.

NINHARDCOREFAN
Messages
118
Reaction score
0
A length of metal wire has a radius of 0:002 m and a resistance of 0.1. When the potential difference across the wire is 14 V, the electron drift speed is found to be 0:000229 m/s. Based on these data, calculate the density of free electron in the wire. Answer in units of m^-3.

r=.002m R=.1 Vd=.000229

V/R=i
14/.1=140

Vd= drift velocity.

i/(Vd*A)=ne
140/(.000229*pi*.002squared)=4.86499826e10
j=neVd
11140846.02 (I tried plugging in this answer, it's wrong)
11140846.02/1e-3 = 1114084602e10 (I did this because it says answer is
supposed to be in 1e-3)

The answer is wrong I don't know why.

A 72:5 W, 191.2 V light bulb is plugged into a 61:6 V outlet. If energy costs 4.7 cents/kWh, how much does it cost per month (30 days) to leave the light bulb turned on? Answer in units of
cents.

light bulb = 72.5W, 191.2V
outlet = 61.6V
Energy = 4.7 cents/kWh
Days = 30

P/V = i
72.5/191.2 = .3791841
i*V=P
.3791841*61.6 = 23.35574059W
23.35574059/1000 = .02335574059kW
Pt = P*t
.02335574059*30*24 = 16.81757322
Cost = P*cents
16.81757322* 4.7 = 79.04259414 cents
This is also wrong, I don't know why.

Any help is appreciated.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Originally posted by NINHARDCOREFAN
...
i/(Vd*A)=ne
140/(.000229*pi*.002squared)=4.86499826e10
j=neVd
11140846.02 (I tried plugging in this answer, it's wrong)
11140846.02/1e-3 = 1114084602e10 (I did this because it says answer is
supposed to be in 1e-3)

The answer is wrong I don't know why.
What happened to "e", the electron charge? Seems like you left it out. (Also, don't carry so many significant digits; three is plenty.)
P/V = i
72.5/191.2 = .3791841
i*V=P
.3791841*61.6 = 23.35574059W
23.35574059/1000 = .02335574059kW
Pt = P*t
.02335574059*30*24 = 16.81757322
Cost = P*cents
16.81757322* 4.7 = 79.04259414 cents
This is also wrong, I don't know why.
You forgot that the bulb is plugged into a lower voltage than it is rated for, so it will consume less power. The bulb's wattage depends on the voltage. First find the resistance of the light bulb (assume it is constant). Then find the power consumption at the new voltage.
 
What happened to "e", the electron charge? Seems like you left it out. (Also, don't carry so many significant digits; three is plenty.)

The e wouldn't have mattered by the end because I am taking the value "ne" together

You forgot that the bulb is plugged into a lower voltage than it is rated for, so it will consume less power. The bulb's wattage depends on the voltage. First find the resistance of the light bulb (assume it is constant). Then find the power consumption at the new voltage.
I don't understand what you're telling me to do here.
 
Originally posted by NINHARDCOREFAN
The e wouldn't have mattered by the end because I am taking the value "ne" together
I thought the question asked for electron density, which is "n", not "ne". "ne" would have units of C/m3, not 1/m3.
I don't understand what you're telling me to do here.
Treat the light bulb as a resistor. Find its resistance, based on the rated numbers (watts at a given voltage). Now find out how much power is used when that bulb (a resistor) is given a different (lower) voltage.
 
I thought the question asked for electron density, which is "n", not "ne". "ne" would have units of C/m3, not 1/m3.

How sure are you that this is right? Because there is one try left for me to get this right. If you think this is right, can you please double check my work at tell me if it's right.

r=.002m R=.1 Vd=.000229 e=1.6e-19

V/R=i
14/.1=140

Vd= drift velocity.

i/(Vd*A)=ne
140/(.000229*pi*.002squared)=4.86499826e10

ans/e= n
4.86499826e10/1.6e-19 = 3.0406e29
n/1e-3 = 3.0406e32
 
Originally posted by NINHARDCOREFAN
How sure are you that this is right? Because there is one try left for me to get this right. If you think this is right, can you please double check my work at tell me if it's right.
Of course I think it's right. But it's your homework. Sounds like you've been doing more "plugging and praying" than understanding. :smile:
ans/e= n
4.86499826e10/1.6e-19 = 3.0406e29
n/1e-3 = 3.0406e32

I have no idea what you mean by "n/1e-3", but the answer seems correct; the units are 1/M3 (which means the number of electrons per cubic meter... that's the definition of "n").
 
the question said the answer should be in 1e-3. So I divided the answer by 1e-3
 
****, the answer was 3.0406e29. Anyway, thanks for the help
 
Last edited:
Originally posted by NINHARDCOREFAN
the question said the answer should be in 1e-3. So I divided the answer by 1e-3
The question asked for units of m^-3, which are the proper units for "n", not "1e-3". (At least that's what you said: "Answer in units of m^-3.")

Perhaps I should have been clearer. I meant that the answer you gave for "n" was correct. (I have no idea why you divided by 1e-3, which is why I questioned it.) Oh, well... sorry.
 
  • #10
Whoa! I just realized that the question says that the answer is supposed to be in 1e-3 but the correct answer was in 1e3, maybe I can ask my prof. to give me credit for the answer!
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
9K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
22K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
5K
Replies
1
Views
6K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K