
#1
Jul107, 07:17 AM

P: 339

well i saw a proof and therea re hundreds of them where conservation of angular momentum is used to solve the problems.let me state an example and then my question.
a ball with some initial velocity is put on a rough plane find the speed of the c.m when it stops pure rolling.well of course on solution is via the torque equation.but other solution is by conserving the angular momentum about the point of contact since there no net torque acts about that point. my question is this point itself is moving how can we conserve momentum about two diff. points(since the point initially with which the floor was in contact with is in general not same as the point it contacts after the ball starts pure rolling) 



#2
Jul107, 11:07 AM

P: 33

I don't think I understand your question: the speed of the center of mass when the ball stops pure rolling is 0.




#3
Jul207, 04:04 AM

P: 339

well what i meant was consider this ismple problem u hav aball rolling with speed [tex]v_{0}[/tex] initially and u put it ona rough surface and conserve momentuma about the point of contact(???) say that no torque acts about thsi point.thenn finally when it starts pure rolling we put
[tex]mv_{0}r=I\frac{v}{r}+mvr[/tex] but my question is the point about which we are conserving omentum is itself moving and finally when the sphere starts pure rolling then the point may not be the same as the one with which it was put in contact withthe ground hope i was clear 



#4
Jul207, 07:28 AM

HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 1,198

conservation of angular momentum 



#5
Jul207, 09:02 AM

P: 339

yes that' true i can always conserve angular momentum about the point of contact but this point is itself alwys changing.here the point about which i conserve is itself changing with time so how do i conserve angular momentum about two apparently different points




#6
Jul407, 12:56 PM

P: 1,583





#7
Jul507, 02:48 PM

P: 2

@pardesi
Hey buddy, you are not conserving angular momentum about the moving point, you are conserving angular momentum about any stationary point on the ground, which is in line with the frictional force (even the initial point will do), so that the net torque of friction about the stationary point is zero. You cannot conserve angular momentum about a moving point. 



#8
Jul507, 03:20 PM

HW Helper
P: 6,924

Assuming no losses, then angular moementum isn't conserved, but total energy is. So the initial condition could be 0 angular rotation, and some velocity as the ball starts off initially sliding on the surface. The initial total engery is all linear kinetic energy. The final state will be the sum of kinetic energy due to rotation and linear movement, and the rate of rotation will be proportional to the linear movement.




#10
Jul607, 07:19 AM

P: 339





#11
Jul607, 10:31 AM

HW Helper
PF Gold
P: 1,198





#12
Jul607, 12:29 PM

P: 339

yes i think this is settled now but not so convincingly as i had thought seems too conditional thanks everyone




#13
Jul707, 02:13 AM

HW Helper
P: 6,924

http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=159337 My previous most mentioned "assume no losses", but this could only happen in a case where no sliding occurred. The friction surface would have to immediate grip the sphere, and flex horizontally with a spring like reaction applied to the bottom surface of the sphere to convert the linear energy into a combination of linear and angular energy with no losses. 



#14
Jul707, 07:45 AM

Mentor
P: 40,872

As jee.anupam explained, angular momentum is conserved about any point along the line of action of the friction force. That fact, plus the noslipping condition ([itex]v = \omega r[/itex]), allows you to compute the speed at which rolling without slipping takes place.
(Of course, angular momentum about the cm of the ball is not conserved, otherwise the ball will never start spinning.) You can also solve this using Newton's 2nd law, which takes longer but is instructive. Energy is not conserved: Until rolling without slipping is attained, the ball scrapes along the floor, dissipating mechanical energy. Assuming energy conservation gives you the wrong answer. 



#15
Jul707, 12:58 PM

P: 2





#16
Jul707, 03:02 PM

HW Helper
P: 6,924

http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=159337 



#17
Jul707, 03:15 PM

Mentor
P: 40,872





#18
Jul707, 07:01 PM

HW Helper
P: 6,924

The idealized case would be one where the friction surface flexes elastically and without any slippage. A close approximation of this would be a marble sliding at a reasonably slow speed from a very slick surface onto a surface composed of table tennis rubber which is very sticky and can flex significantly along the surface with a very high energy retention factor (it would spring back, temporarily increasing angular velocity, but then settle), assume this is done in a vacuum chamber so that aerodynamic drag isn't a factor. Another idealized case would be a rolling gear sliding onto a geared plane. The result would be similar as obove, spring like flexing of the surfaces (gears), and no sliding. The more generalized case as I pointed out would be a very high coefficient of friction combined with a horizontally flexible surface. In real life, dynamic friction varies with speed (coefficient of friction is reduced as speed differences in the surfaces increase). I'm not sure what affect this would have on the results. The transition from dynamic to static friction isn't instantaneous, but assuming the flex in the friction surface can be ignored, this shouldn't matter. A more resonable example of a lossless case involving linear and angular energy would be to have a sphere resting on a sticky plane and then accelerate the sticky plane horizontally with a constant rate of acceleration. As velocity of the plane increases, what is the ratio of the velocity of the sphere versus the velocity of the plane the sphere is rolling on? Highlight for answer: 5/9 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Law of the Conservation of Angular Momentum > Principle of Conservation of Momentum  General Engineering  0  
Conservation of Angular Momentum  Introductory Physics Homework  4  
angular momentum conservation help  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
conservation of angular momentum  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
conservation of angular momentum  Introductory Physics Homework  3 