Unusual Questions: Do You Get Those 'What If' Questions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Danger
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread explores a variety of unusual "what if" questions and curiosities, ranging from personal musings about hermaphrodites to societal observations about everyday products like ketchup and toilet paper. The discussion includes both humorous and serious inquiries, touching on conceptual and practical aspects of these questions.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants ponder whether a hermaphrodite can impregnate themselves, with differing views on the feasibility of natural versus artificial methods.
  • There is a recurring humorous inquiry about the placement of butter in refrigerators, highlighting personal experiences and frustrations.
  • Questions are raised about the presence of safety seals on plastic versus glass ketchup bottles, with some suggesting that the design of the bottles influences the need for such seals.
  • Participants discuss the changing dimensions of toilet paper sheets and the implications of packaging and marketing strategies in consumer products.
  • Some express curiosity about the lack of instructions for displaying toilet paper, suggesting that many people may not know the "correct" way to use it.
  • There are observations about the marketing tactics used in the pulp and paper industry, including the manipulation of sheet counts and product dimensions to influence consumer perception.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

The discussion contains multiple competing views and humorous anecdotes, with no clear consensus on the various questions raised. Participants share differing opinions and experiences without resolving the inquiries.

Contextual Notes

Participants express uncertainty about the knowledge and awareness of product features among consumers, as well as the implications of product design on usability and safety.

Who May Find This Useful

This thread may interest individuals curious about societal norms, consumer product design, and the humorous side of everyday questions and dilemmas.

Danger
Gold Member
Messages
9,805
Reaction score
251
Since a few somewhat strange things cross my mind occassionaly (are you surprised?), I figured to see if I'm alone in that. So, do any of you get that 'what if?' question that isn't easily answered?
To start off, what prompted this thread was a sudden curiosity (under circumstances that I don't care to divulge) as to whether a hermaphrodite leaves the seat up or down. :confused:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Down. Don't ask me how I know that.

Q2: Why is there a safety seal on plastic Catsup bottles, but not on glass Catsup bottles?
 
berkeman said:
Down. Don't ask me how I know that.

:rolleyes:
 
berkeman said:
Down. Don't ask me how I know that.

Q2: Why is there a safety seal on plastic Catsup bottles, but not on glass Catsup bottles?
Interesting question, since anybody with access to a syringe could adulterate the catsup in a plastic bottle but not a glass bottle. At least not without popping the tell-tale in the metal lid.
 
turbo-1 said:
Interesting question, since anybody with access to a syringe could adulterate the catsup in a plastic bottle but not a glass bottle. At least not without popping the tell-tale in the metal lid.

Oh, that's why. Plastic bottles aren't vacuum sealed, so have no tell-tale dimple in the lid. Thanks! Learn something new here on the PF every dang day.
 
turbo-1 said:
At least not without popping the tell-tale in the metal lid.

That might be the rationale behind not needing a seal on them, but how many people actually know about that or even pay attention to the condition of the lid? I didn't know about it until now, but I don't buy ketchup and I don't even know if they use that kind of lids up here.
Jeez, but I miss the good old days when you could just unscrew the cap and throw in some potassium cyanide.
 
I've always wondered if a hermaphrodite can impregnate his/herself.
 
I'm sure all the married men will agree with me that the quintessential unanswerable question is "Where is the butter?" My wife has put five or six loaded butter dishes on each shelf of our fridge in an effort to help me figure this one out. It didn't work. There's a place on the inside of the door for butter. It should be there.
 
lisab said:
I've always wondered if a hermaphrodite can impregnate his/herself.

Artificially, but not naturally.
 
  • #10
jimmysnyder said:
I'm sure all the married men will agree with me that the quintessential unanswerable question is "Where is the butter?" My wife has put five or six loaded butter dishes on each shelf of our fridge in an effort to help me figure this one out. It didn't work. There's a place on the inside of the door for butter. It should be there.
And for the unmarried/divorced men "What was that?" :biggrin:

My question is why did they not define a "sheet" when they started unit pricing paper products.
And why haven't they fixed this?
I figure a sheet of TP will be down to the size of a postage stamp in 10 years.
Already it's down to 3.7 x 4 or so from the original 4.5 x 4.5.
 
  • #11
NoTime said:
Already it's down to 3.7 x 4 or so from the original 4.5 x 4.5.

And you can't help noticing that the core gets bigger every year, resulting in fewer wraps to get the same overall diameter.
 
  • #12
Danger said:
And you can't help noticing that the core gets bigger every year, resulting in fewer wraps to get the same overall diameter.
Not only that, they advertise "even softer" when all they have done is to increase the angle on the creping blade to loft the sheet. This increases the bulk of the sheet so that you get fewer sheets/roll. The manufacturers can make more rolls of toilet tissue and more boxes of facial tissues using the same amount of raw materials. A prime example of this is Charmin - you have to buy a whole 4-pack of 250-sheet rolls to get as many sheets as you get in one traditional Scott tissue roll. I used to run a paper machine for Scott's S.D Warren division and later served as a technical/service consultant to other mills, often with tissue machines. There are a lot of tricks in the pulp and paper industry - especially in the consumer products divisions.
 
  • #13
And why don't they have instructions on the back of the TP that show how it is supposed to be displayed?
 
  • #14
chemisttree said:
And why don't they have instructions on the back of the TP that show how it is supposed to be displayed?

And why don't they have instructions on use? From an earlier thread in GD, it's obvious a lot of people don't know how to fold toilet paper and generally use way too much.

As far as the condition of the lid on a glass bottle or jar, how could people not know? A vacuum sealed bottle gives such a satisfying 'pop' feel when you open them.
 
  • #15
chemisttree said:
And why don't they have instructions on the back of the TP that show how it is supposed to be displayed?

I suspect that no matter how well matted and framed, you have a good chance of getting your house declared a hazardous waste site. :eek: :biggrin:
 
  • #16
chemisttree said:
And why don't they have instructions on the back of the TP that show how it is supposed to be displayed?

NoTime said:
I suspect that no matter how well matted and framed, you have a good chance of getting your house declared a hazardous waste site. :eek: :biggrin:

I disagree. http://www.annetaintor.com/air-fresheners.html - available in "Local Tavern Scent".

The "Lemon Gelatin" air freshener isn't bad either - at least it has attitude.
 
  • #17
NoTime said:
I suspect that no matter how well matted and framed, you have a good chance of getting your house declared a hazardous waste site. :eek: :biggrin:

:smile: :smile: :smile:

BobG said:
From an earlier thread in GD, it's obvious a lot of people don't know how to fold toilet paper and generally use way too much.

As mentioned in that thread, I neither fold nor scrunch. A roll lasts me at least 2 weeks, whereas W burns through at least 3 rolls per week. Luckily, we have our own separate bathrooms, but she still occassionally snipes a roll from me.
 
Last edited:
  • #18
turbo-1 said:
Not only that, they advertise "even softer" when all they have done is to increase the angle on the creping blade to loft the sheet. This increases the bulk of the sheet so that you get fewer sheets/roll. The manufacturers can make more rolls of toilet tissue and more boxes of facial tissues using the same amount of raw materials. A prime example of this is Charmin - you have to buy a whole 4-pack of 250-sheet rolls to get as many sheets as you get in one traditional Scott tissue roll. I used to run a paper machine for Scott's S.D Warren division and later served as a technical/service consultant to other mills, often with tissue machines. There are a lot of tricks in the pulp and paper industry - especially in the consumer products divisions.

I usually compare the number of sheets when figuring out which one is the best price (yes, I do seem to spend a long time in the toilet paper aisle when shopping, because I'm trying to do all the math). The best one I noticed was just yesterday. I looked at several packages of 2-ply, and they'd say something like 314 2-ply sheets (I'm sure they pick those numbers just to slow down my math), and then I got to one that was still 2-ply, and on the package said 250 single-ply sheets. :smile: Okay, so each roll really only has 125 sheets on it...yep, that's why it was about half the price of the others. But, yeah, they sure had fluffed it up nicely to make those rolls look about the same size as the other brands.

The other one that was interesting was packets of salad dressing mix. Same brand, same size packets, but one was sold in a package of two with a free cruet, and the other was sold in a box of 4 packets. On the grocery store shelf, the two packet was listed as price per unit (a unit being a packet) and the four packet one listed as price per ounce! As each packet was less than an ounce, if you only glanced quickly at the unit price, you'd think the 2 packet one was the better price (it was if you needed a cruet, but not if you just needed the mix). Fortunately, I'm a lot faster at dividing $3 by 4 than I am at dividing $7.59 by 314, so didn't have to spend nearly as much time staring at salad dressing packets as I did the toilet paper to decide whether to buy one box of 4 or two boxes of 2.

Not unusual questions, but just things I notice. Of course, now I'm wondering where I'm supposed to be putting the butter other than in the little shelf with the door on it that's for the butter?
 
  • #19
The butter thing sort of weirds me out. We use margarine in a tub, which is pretty hard to miss.
 
  • #20
Moonbear, you should just bring your calculator with you when shopping. Also, make sure and check that each roll of toilet paper has the same size sheets, perhaps price per unit area would be better than price per sheet?
 
  • #21
NeoDevin said:
Moonbear, you should just bring your calculator with you when shopping. Also, make sure and check that each roll of toilet paper has the same size sheets, perhaps price per unit area would be better than price per sheet?

The catch is that I have to finish all my calculations before I need to pee so I will have bought the toilet paper and gotten it home in time to use it. :biggrin: But, dangit, different sized sheets too. Buying toilet paper shouldn't require a degree in topography. *clandestinely slips calculator into purse* :rolleyes:
 
  • #22
NeoDevin said:
Moonbear, you should just bring your calculator with you when shopping. Also, make sure and check that each roll of toilet paper has the same size sheets, perhaps price per unit area would be better than price per sheet?
Lol. I've thought of that, but some of those sheets are so thin you can read thru them.
 
  • #23
NoTime said:
Lol. I've thought of that, but some of those sheets are so thin you can read thru them.

Dangit! Now I have to calculate price per unit volume or dry weight or some such and remember to either subtract out the air spaces or the cardboard core? This is just getting more and more difficult. Maybe I should just buy Depends instead.
 
  • #24
Danger said:
The butter thing sort of weirds me out. We use margarine in a tub, which is pretty hard to miss.
Didn't they find out that margarine was bad for your health?
In any event it tastes awful, at least to me.
 
  • #25
NoTime said:
Didn't they find out that margarine was bad for your health?
In any event it tastes awful, at least to me.

Oh come on what isn't bad for your health according to some medical study done by someone somewhere?
 
  • #26
Moonbear said:
Dangit! Now I have to calculate price per unit volume or dry weight or some such and remember to either subtract out the air spaces or the cardboard core? This is just getting more and more difficult. Maybe I should just buy Depends instead.
Depends, you could bring a scale and weigh it. :biggrin:
 
  • #27
Nabeshin said:
Oh come on what isn't bad for your health according to some medical study done by someone somewhere?
True. That's why I go by taste. If it's giong to kill me anyway, I might as well enjoy it.
 
  • #28
NoTime said:
If it's giong to kill me anyway, I might as well enjoy it.

Too right. Hence my propensity for gnawing my food off of the critter without regard to cooking. :biggrin:
 
  • #29
Here is an old one: Why are manhole covers round?
 
  • #30
Ivan Seeking said:
Here is an old one: Why are manhole covers round?

So they can't fall into the manhole. Any other shape could be turned so that it could.P.S. There is another that couldn't fall into the hole, an equilateral triangle, but a circle is still more efficiently shaped hole.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
3K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
2K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
3K
  • · Replies 23 ·
Replies
23
Views
4K
  • · Replies 64 ·
3
Replies
64
Views
8K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K