Thread Closed

Shotgun wedding

 
Share Thread Thread Tools
May19-04, 05:13 PM   #1
 

Shotgun wedding


US raids Iraqi safe house
From correspondents in Washington
May 20, 2004

PENTAGON officials said they had no information about an air attack that was reported to have killed 40 people celebrating a marriage in a village near the Iraqi-Syrian border.

But US forces raided a suspected safe house for foreign fighters in the open desert near the border, seizing large quantities of currency, foreign passports and sophisticated communications devices, a defence official said.

The official, who asked not to be identified, said the raid occurred at about 3am local time (9am AEST) about 25 kilometres from the Syrian border. The nearest town was Husaybah, the official said.

"During the operation, the coalition forces came under hostile fire, and returned fire," he said.

"Coalition forces on the ground recovered a large amount of Iraqi and Syrian currency, foreign passports and sophisticated communications equipment," he said.

In Dubai, Al Arabiya television said witnesses said an air strike killed 40 Iraqis celebrating a marriage.

http://www.news.com.au/common/story_...5E1702,00.html
Every news agency seems to be carrying this story. Everyone except the USA says it happened. The USA says it never happened.

http://abclocal.go.com/kabc/news/051...q_wedding.html
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2004/...917681299.html
http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/s1111847.htm
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stori.../85873/1/.html
PhysOrg.com
PhysOrg
science news on PhysOrg.com

>> Ants and carnivorous plants conspire for mutualistic feeding
>> Forecast for Titan: Wild weather could be ahead
>> Researchers stitch defects into the world's thinnest semiconductor
May19-04, 05:38 PM   #2
 
Another story on it:
"US planes dropped more than 100 bombs on us," an unidentified man who said he was from the village said on al-Arabiya.

"They hit two homes where the wedding was being held and then they levelled the whole village. No bullets were fired by us, nothing was happening," he added.

The Dubai-based network also showed those who survived digging graves for the numerous men, women and children that died in the raid.

A local police official told AP news agency between 42 and 45 people had died as a result of the US attack.

The US has said it has no knowledge of the alleged attack but says US forces did conduct a raid on a house in the border area. In Baghdad, a US military spokesman said the allegation was being investigated.

In July 2002, an American air strike on an Afghan wedding party killed 48 civilians.

A report released by the US Central Command said the strike was justified because American planes had come under fire.

http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exer...0339A14320.htm
May19-04, 11:13 PM   #3
 
US denial over wedding deaths
By Scheherezade Faramarzi in Baghdad
May 20, 2004

US aircraft have fired on a house in the desert near the Syrian border killing more than 40 people who, according to Iraqi officials, were part of a wedding party.

The US military said the target was a suspected safehouse for foreign fighters from Syria, but Iraqis said a helicopter had attacked a wedding party.

Associated Press Television News footage showed a truck containing bloodied bodies, many wrapped in blankets, piled one on top of the other.

Several were children, one of whom was decapitated. The body of a girl who appeared to be less than five years of age lay in a white sheet, her legs riddled with wounds and her dress soaked in blood.

http://www.news.com.au/common/story_...E31317,00.html
So, there are pictures floating around the AP.
May20-04, 06:39 AM   #4
 

Shotgun wedding


Happened in Afghanistan as well, old habits are hard to break.
May20-04, 12:38 PM   #5
 
adam, this story, today, May 20th, is one of the big stories on fox news... Just a heads up...
May20-04, 12:46 PM   #6
 
I was expecting a story about a pregnant girl, the fellow who put her in such condition, and the girl's angry father. I think I heard about this story recently, but I don't consider the death of innocents any less significant due to what they were attending.
May20-04, 12:52 PM   #7
 
Quote by Simon666
Happened in Afghanistan as well, old habits are hard to break.
I wonder if these people in Iraq were shooting weapons in the air as well.
May20-04, 12:53 PM   #8
 
Quote by BoulderHead
I was expecting a story about a pregnant girl, the fellow who put her in such condition, and the girl's angry father. I think I heard about this story recently, but I don't consider the death of innocents any less significant due to what they were attending.
agreed, nor I do find them anymore significant than any soldier over there that is killed.
May20-04, 01:08 PM   #9
 
Quote by phatmonky
I wonder if these people in Iraq were shooting weapons in the air as well.
Does that matter?
May20-04, 01:35 PM   #10
 
Quote by Simon666
Does that matter?
Such information could lead to avoidance of such events in the future.
May20-04, 01:38 PM   #11
 
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor
From various news sites linked
"The US planes dropped more than 100 bombs on us," an unidentified man who said he was from the village said on Al Arabiya. "They hit two homes where the wedding was being held and then they levelled the whole village. No bullets were fired by us, nothing was happening," he added.

Iraqis interviewed on the videotape said revelers had fired volleys of gunfire into the air in a traditional wedding celebration before the attack took place. American troops have sometimes mistaken celebratory gunfire for hostile fire.

The area, a desolate region populated only by shepherds, is popular with smugglers, including weapons smugglers, and the U.S. military suspects militants use it as a route to slip in from Syria to fight the Americans. It is under constant surveillance by American forces.
Obviously, the Iraqis in the story can not be taken at their word, since they are contradicting each other. Nor should we accept the US version on faith. We should find out what happened.

It is entirely possible that a mission was run against a gun smuggling operation on the day of a wedding. Gun smugglers have families too. The site was kept under observation, any plans for a large event would draw suspicions. A large number of people converging on a smugglers residence might draw a reaction. As soldiers moved in on what they believe to be a well armed hostile enemy force, gunfire erupts. I'm not saying that is what happened, but it is very possible.

Njorl
May20-04, 01:45 PM   #12
 
Quote by phatmonky
Such information could lead to avoidance of such events in the future.
How come? It is tradition in the area and US helicopters fire from a distance away that they cannot be heard from, and the US army knows pretty well it is such a tradition. They could have avoided it if they wanted to instead of being trigger happy.
May20-04, 01:50 PM   #13
 
Quote by Simon666
How come? It is tradition in the area and US helicopters fire from a distance away that they cannot be heard from, and the US army knows pretty well it is such a tradition. They could have avoided it if they wanted to instead of being trigger happy.

Fire guns in the air in a war zone, even if it is tradition, is a highly dangerous (and one might argue stupid) thing to do.


they cannot be heard from? The guns they are firing in the air you mean???

Do you really believe that information to the helicopters only comes from the helicopter crew,thus they must hear shots themselves to be aware that someone is firing there?
May20-04, 02:22 PM   #14
 
Quote by phatmonky
Fire guns in the air in a war zone, even if it is tradition, is a highly dangerous (and one might argue stupid) thing to do. they cannot be heard from? The guns they are firing in the air you mean????
Sorry, I meant the US helicopters can't be heard from the distance they usually fire away from the target so you can't really say the villagers shouldn't be doing it. They were also on some remote place not far from the Syrian border, not a place like Baghdad, Fallujah, or some other hotbed. So the chance terrorists are holding a tupperware party there exchanging AK47s and RPGs is pretty small, they could have checked out before they decided to blow the place to smithereens.
May20-04, 03:29 PM   #15
 
Mentor
Quote by Adam
Every news agency seems to be carrying this story. Everyone except the USA says it happened. The USA says it never happened.
"Everyone," being foreign and domestic news sources as reported by Iraqis. "The US," being the US government, which says not much more than 'we're investigating.' The title of the third report does not correspond to the report: there is no "denial" in the report.
They were also on some remote place not far from the Syrian border, not a place like Baghdad, Fallujah, or some other hotbed. So the chance terrorists are holding a tupperware party there exchanging AK47s and RPGs is pretty small, they could have checked out before they decided to blow the place to smithereens.
The reason it was under investigation in the first place was because it is a place of known terrorist activity.

Anyone considering the possibility that it was both a terrorist safehouse and a wedding (besides Njorl)? Remember, terrorists hide by blending in amongst civilians. Heck, they had a good example in Saddam: he built major military facilities under hospitals and schools, hid tanks in residential neighborhoods and weapons in schools.

Quit it with the rhetoric and look for some real facts before making judgements, guys.
May20-04, 03:34 PM   #16
 
Quote by russ_watters
Anyone considering the possibility that it was both a terrorist safehouse and a wedding (besides Njorl)? Remember, terrorists hide by blending in amongst civilians. Heck, they had a good example in Saddam: he built major military facilities under hospitals and schools, hid tanks in residential neighborhoods and weapons in schools.
That happened occasionally, the US occasionally did the same as well, like in a school in Fallujah. When an angry crowd wanted their school back, the US fired in the crowd. I hope you didn't think until now they killed those contractors for no reason or "because they hate freedom" or something like that?
May20-04, 03:51 PM   #17
 
Quote by Simon666
So the chance terrorists are holding a tupperware party there exchanging AK47s and RPGs is pretty small,

WE'll have to wait for the full report, however this cracked me up
Thread Closed
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Shotgun wedding
Thread Forum Replies
What is the force of a shotgun blast? Introductory Physics Homework 14
Wedding anniversary General Discussion 16
Wedding gift General Discussion 10
Bombed Iraqi wedding video released Current Events 24