image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > Mathematics > Calculus & Analysis


Reply

image vector calculus in higher dimensions Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Jun7-09, 12:29 PM       Last edited by lolgarithms; Jun7-09 at 01:15 PM..            #1
lolgarithms

lolgarithms is Offline:
Posts: 118
vector calculus in higher dimensions

in 2d, "curl"(grad(f)) = 0 "curl" is the operation that green's tehorem talks about.

In 3D, curl(grad(f)) = 0 and div(curl(F)) = 0.

We may consider vector calculus in 4 spatial dimensions, for vector fields F:R^4 -> R^4. what is "curl" like in 4D, since curl is actually only difined in 3D. I think there would be no curl in 4D because there's no cross product in 4D. instead there would be 2 operators related by Stokes's theorem for general manifolds.
my conjecture is that in 4 dimensions, some other operator D2 exists such that div(D2(F)) = 0. Also there exists another operator D1 such that D2(D1(f)) = 0 and D1(gradient(f))=0. Div would still be from an operator from a vector field to a scalar field.
the divergence theorem would be relating 4-volumes to 3-volumes(boundary of 4-volume)

Do they exist? what is the nature of such an operator (in cartesian) and how can i visualize it?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun7-09, 01:04 PM                  #2
dx
 
dx's Avatar

dx is Offline:
Posts: 1,491
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Homework Helper Homework Helper
Re: vector calculus in higher dimensions

The generalization of vector calculus to general higher dimensional manifolds is the calculus of differential forms. Curl, div, grad all become special cases of a single operator called the 'exterior derivative' d.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun7-09, 01:15 PM                  #3
lolgarithms

lolgarithms is Offline:
Posts: 118
Re: vector calculus in higher dimensions

yes, all differential operators are special cases of exterior derivative, but in 4 or higher dimensions would they still take the general sequence of gradient:{f: R^4 -> R} -> {f:R^4 -> R^4}, ... then some other differentail operators ..., then divergence: {f:R^4 -> R^4} -> {f:R^4 -> R} ? or would some of the operators split in a different way? (an analogy for lower dimensions is how div and curl are actually the same in 2D, but they become different operators in 3D.)
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun7-09, 01:25 PM       Last edited by dx; Jun7-09 at 01:31 PM..            #4
dx
 
dx's Avatar

dx is Offline:
Posts: 1,491
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Homework Helper Homework Helper
Re: vector calculus in higher dimensions

Originally Posted by lolgarithms View Post
yes, all differential operators are special cases of exterior derivative, but in 4 or higher dimensions would they still take the general sequence of gradient:{f: R^4 -> R} -> {f:R^4 -> R^4}, ... then some other differentail operators ..., then divergence: {f:R^4 -> R^4} -> {f:R^4 -> R} ? or would some of the operators split in a different way?
d acting on a function (which gives a 1-form) is the analog of gradient, d acting on a 1-form (which gives a 2-form) is the analog of curl and d acting on a 2-form (which gives a 3-form) is the analog of divergence.

In general, d takes a p-form to a (p+1)-form.

Originally Posted by lolgarithms View Post
(an analogy for lower dimensions is how div and curl are actually the same in 2D, but they become different operators in 3D.)
div and curl are not the same in 2D.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun7-09, 01:35 PM       Last edited by lolgarithms; Jun7-09 at 02:07 PM..            #5
lolgarithms

lolgarithms is Offline:
Posts: 118
Re: vector calculus in higher dimensions

oh, i meant that both div and curl can be described by green's theorem in 2D:
div:
LaTeX Code: \\int_C -M  \\,dx + L\\, dy = \\iint_{D} \\left(\\frac{\\partial L}{\\partial x} + \\frac{\\partial M}{\\partial y}\\right)\\, dA = \\iint_D\\left(\\nabla\\cdot\\mathbf{F}\\right)dA

curl:
LaTeX Code: \\int_{C} L\\, dx + M\\, dy = \\iint_{D} \\left(\\frac{\\partial M}{\\partial x} - \\frac{\\partial L}{\\partial y}\\right)\\, dA = \\iint_D |\\nabla\\times\\mathbf{F}| dA
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun7-09, 01:46 PM       Last edited by dx; Jun7-09 at 01:57 PM..            #6
dx
 
dx's Avatar

dx is Offline:
Posts: 1,491
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Homework Helper Homework Helper
Re: vector calculus in higher dimensions

Green's theorem involves the curl. I'm not sure what you mean by "both div and curl can be described by green's theorem". All the integral theorems of vector calculus are special cases of the general stokes theorem

LaTeX Code:  \\int_{\\Omega} d\\omega = \\oint_{\\partial \\Omega} \\omega
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun7-09, 02:17 PM       Last edited by lolgarithms; Jun7-09 at 04:17 PM..            #7
lolgarithms

lolgarithms is Offline:
Posts: 118
Re: vector calculus in higher dimensions

im being a little sloppy here... you rotate L and M (L,M) -> (-M,L) so that the tangent vectors become normal to the boundary, so that (L dx+ M dy) -> (-M dx + L dy). plug -M into L, and plug L into M, in to the green's tehorem, and you will get the theorem for 2D divergence.
we got wrapped up in (metaphorical) tangents, now could you answer my question


a little clarification on opening post:
in 1D there is only one integral theorem, the fundamental theorem of calculus. (special case of line integral theorem)
in 2D there are the line integral theorem and Green's theorem
in 3D there are the line integral theorem and the kelvin-stokes (curl) theorem and gauss's divergence theorem
in 4D: line integral theorem (true for all dimensions) and ????

do not tell me that they are special cases of stokes's theorem. i already know that, thank you very much. i want the specific formulas for the 4D integral theorems and the 4 dimensional vector calculus operations corresponding to them.
template:
"fundamental theorem of calculus(derivative): LaTeX Code: \\int _a ^b fsingle-quote(x) dx = f(b)-f(a)
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun16-09, 11:20 AM                  #8
lolgarithms

lolgarithms is Offline:
Posts: 118
Re: vector calculus in higher dimensions

in 4D: line integral theorem (true for all dimensions) and ????

do not tell me that they are special cases of stokes's theorem. i already know that, thank you very much. i want the specific formulas for the 4D integral theorems and the 4 dimensional vector calculus operations corresponding to them.

do I really have to repeat myself to be heard??

I should have titled this "vector calculus in 4D"
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply

Tags
4 dimensions, vector calculus
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: vector calculus in higher dimensions
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Is it possible that there are organisms in higher dimensions? Ukitake Jyuushirou Beyond the Standard Model 15 Aug26-08 02:14 AM
Conceptualizing higher dimensions... jasc15 Special & General Relativity 3 May20-06 09:30 AM
higher dimensions nightcleaner Beyond the Standard Model 5 Feb3-05 12:15 PM
higher dimensions wolram Special & General Relativity 5 Aug2-04 02:12 PM
Higher Dimensions TechPerson1024 General Physics 0 Jul18-04 03:49 AM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image