image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > Mathematics > Calculus & Analysis


Reply

image Why the sequence is not convergent? Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Jun20-09, 09:36 PM                  #1
symbol0

symbol0 is Offline:
Posts: 53
Why the sequence is not convergent?

In a book I am reading, they mention the following as an example of a Cauchy sequence which is not convergent:
Consider the set of all bounded continuous real functions defined on the closed unit interval, and let the metric of the set be
d(f,g)=LaTeX Code: \\int_0^1 \\! |f(x)-g(x)| \\, dx .
Let LaTeX Code: (f_n) be a sequence in this space defined as:
LaTeX Code: f_n(x)=1 if LaTeX Code: 0 \\leq x \\leq 1/2
LaTeX Code: f_n(x)=(-2)^n(x-1/2)+1 if LaTeX Code: 1/2 \\leq x \\leq 1/2+(1/2)^n
LaTeX Code: f_n(x)=0 if LaTeX Code: 1/2+(1/2)^n\\leq x \\leq 1

I can see that this is a Cauchy sequence, but I can't see how this sequence does not converge. I would say that it converges to:
LaTeX Code: f_n(x)=1 if LaTeX Code: 0 \\leq x \\leq 1/2
LaTeX Code: f_n(x)=0 if LaTeX Code: 1/2 < x \\leq 1

I would appreciate if anybody can help me to see why this sequence does not converge.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun20-09, 10:08 PM                  #2
Hurkyl

PF Mentor
 
Hurkyl's Avatar

Hurkyl is Offline:
Posts: 13,011
Re: Why the sequence is not convergent?

Originally Posted by symbol0 View Post
I can see that this is a Cauchy sequence, but I can't see how this sequence does not converge. I would say that it converges to:
LaTeX Code: f_n(x)=1 if LaTeX Code: 0 \\leq x \\leq 1/2
LaTeX Code: f_n(x)=0 if LaTeX Code: 1/2 < x \\leq 1
I'm going to assume you meant to say something like the following.
I would say that it converges to the function f defined by
LaTeX Code: f(x)=1 if LaTeX Code: 0 \\leq x \\leq 1/2
LaTeX Code: f(x)=0 if LaTeX Code: 1/2 < x \\leq 1 [/quote]
I would appreciate if anybody can help me to see why this sequence does not converge.
A good way to see these things is to try and prove that it does, and see where things fail. You need to:
(1) Show that f is well-defined
(2) Show that LaTeX Code: \\lim_{n \\rightarrow +\\infty} d(f_n, f) = 0
Try it out, and let us know how it goes!
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun21-09, 07:30 PM                  #3
symbol0

symbol0 is Offline:
Posts: 53
Re: Why the sequence is not convergent?

Thanks for the reply Hurkyl,
First of all , I think this sequence is not really in the mentioned space because when n is even, the functions are not continuous.
But even if we take only the functions with odd n, I think the sequence converges to the function I wrote, but this function is not continuous, so it is not in the space.
Thus the sequence does not converge in the space.

Am I right?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun21-09, 10:25 PM                  #4
Hurkyl

PF Mentor
 
Hurkyl's Avatar

Hurkyl is Offline:
Posts: 13,011
Re: Why the sequence is not convergent?

Originally Posted by symbol0 View Post
I think the sequence converges to the function I wrote, but this function is not continuous, so it is not in the space.
That last part is the key thing here -- f is not in the space.

In fact, technically speaking, d was only defined for pairs of elements in the space, so it would be wrong to say that the sequence converges to f! You only get that convergence when looking at the larger space
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun22-09, 11:08 AM                  #5
symbol0

symbol0 is Offline:
Posts: 53
Re: Why the sequence is not convergent?

Thanks Hurkyl
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Why the sequence is not convergent?
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Proving a Sequence is Convergent bobcat817 Calculus & Beyond 1 Oct2-08 05:33 PM
uniformly convergent sequence alligatorman Calculus & Analysis 1 Apr21-08 04:59 PM
Convergent sequence of functions? pivoxa15 Calculus & Beyond 19 Apr17-07 03:45 AM
bounded sequence as convergent electronic engineer General Math 7 Jan17-06 11:56 AM
convergent sequence? soulflyfgm Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics 1 Nov20-05 05:53 AM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image