image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > Mathematics > General Math


Reply

image Unsolved Problem Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Jun29-09, 09:08 PM                  #1
Dragonfall
 
Dragonfall's Avatar

Dragonfall is Offline:
Posts: 878
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Unsolved Problem

Can somebody give me a little-known unsolved problem that can be stated without differential equations?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun30-09, 12:26 AM                  #2
Civilized

Civilized is Offline:
Posts: 164
Re: Unsolved Problem

There are a variety of unsolved problems in graph theory which may be susceptible to elementary methods. A quick google search turned up this page:

http://math.fau.edu/locke/Unsolved.htm
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun30-09, 02:53 AM                  #3
AUMathTutor

AUMathTutor is Offline:
Posts: 490
Re: Unsolved Problem

Does P = NP.

How many angels can dance on the head of a pin.

How much wood would a woodchuck chuck if a woodchuck could chuck wood.

How many grammatically correct English sentences are there containing at most n commas.

Etc.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun30-09, 02:59 AM                  #4
Civilized

Civilized is Offline:
Posts: 164
Re: Unsolved Problem

AUMathTutor, most of those unsolved problems are well-known (the OP asked for ones which are little known), and furthermore I believe that the last three are ill-posed (since english has no formal grammar and angels and woodchucks are afaik undefined).
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun30-09, 06:45 AM                  #5
HallsofIvy

PF Mentor

HallsofIvy is Offline:
Posts: 24,778
Re: Unsolved Problem

Woodchucks will be surprized to learn that!
(You may know them better as groundhogs.)
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun30-09, 10:09 AM                  #6
CRGreathouse

CRGreathouse is Offline:
Posts: 2,939
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Helper
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Re: Unsolved Problem

Halls, do you have an axiomatization of woodchucks handy?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun30-09, 10:15 AM                  #7
AUMathTutor

AUMathTutor is Offline:
Posts: 490
Re: Unsolved Problem

Actually, the P=NP problem is quite poorly known, if you look at how many people in the world have ever heard of it and divide by the number of people in the world.

Far more poorly known if you look at how many people understand what the question is actually asking.

Perhaps "well known" is a poorly-defined term.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun30-09, 10:16 AM                  #8
AUMathTutor

AUMathTutor is Offline:
Posts: 490
Re: Unsolved Problem

And I think the English sentence one is actually not so ill-posed. You might have to make certain stipulations, but you do that all the time in any mathematical problem.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun30-09, 03:20 PM                  #9
molinaro

molinaro is Offline:
Posts: 17
Re: Unsolved Problem

Originally Posted by AUMathTutor View Post
How much wood would a woodchuck chuck if a woodchuck could chuck wood.
I first heard the answer to that question over 30 years ago:

A woodchuck would chuck as much wood as a woodchuck could chuck if a woodchuck could chuck wood.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun30-09, 05:24 PM                  #10
Aten

Aten is Offline:
Posts: 4
Re: Unsolved Problem

Well...

- Does an odd perfect number(s) exist?
- Prove the abc conjecture.
- Explain the role of modulus in Parrondo paradox.
- What is the probability that an infinitely small object would become finitely big?(well "big bang" theory :)...no comment..
- Prove the Riemann hypothesis.

I can give you many more - but those are OK for now :). The problem about the probability is more than obvious(0 probability for such thing to happen regardless of the fairytales about "singularity"!...) - it's interesting how it objects the big bang funny hypothesis of singularity. I believe in the bang - just don't believe in the idiotic religious assumptions about creation. Religion and dogmatic science(why not every science???:) should be forbidden by law...including present day big bang assumptions.

Anyway... :)

The problems above can be formulated without a single differential equation and believe it or not - many people haven't heard of the Riemann hypothesis - including many math teachers in economically developed countries.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun30-09, 05:57 PM                  #11
Petek

Petek is Offline:
Posts: 67
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Re: Unsolved Problem

See here for a list of unsolved math problems, some of which can be described as little-known.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jun30-09, 06:16 PM                  #12
gel
 
gel's Avatar

gel is Offline:
Posts: 509
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Re: Unsolved Problem

The Gaussian correlation conjecture.

If X is a joint-normal random variable in Rn, A,B are convex and symmetric (so A=-A, B=-B) sets in Rn, then

LaTeX Code: <BR>P(X\\in A\\cap B) \\ge P(X\\in A)P(X\\in B).<BR>
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul1-09, 01:53 AM       Last edited by Dragonfall; Jul1-09 at 02:00 AM..            #13
Dragonfall
 
Dragonfall's Avatar

Dragonfall is Offline:
Posts: 878
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Re: Unsolved Problem

P vs NP and Riemann are both well known to anyone with a bit of math experience. I'm asking for something more esoteric. No god damn angels.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul1-09, 01:58 AM                  #14
Dragonfall
 
Dragonfall's Avatar

Dragonfall is Offline:
Posts: 878
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Re: Unsolved Problem

Originally Posted by Civilized View Post
There are a variety of unsolved problems in graph theory which may be susceptible to elementary methods. A quick google search turned up this page:

http://math.fau.edu/locke/Unsolved.htm
Thanks for an actual reply. No angels dancing on pins here.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul1-09, 02:15 AM                  #15
CRGreathouse

CRGreathouse is Offline:
Posts: 2,939
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Helper
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Re: Unsolved Problem

Guy's Unsolved Problems in Number Theory has more if you're interested. I think he has at least one analog for (an)other field(s).
  Reply With Quote
Old Jul1-09, 04:50 PM                  #16
Dragonfall
 
Dragonfall's Avatar

Dragonfall is Offline:
Posts: 878
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
Re: Unsolved Problem

Yes! I had forgotten about that book. Thanks.
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Unsolved Problem
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
unsolved kmikias General Math 1 Aug29-08 05:31 PM
Unsolved Question 1 hcchong Introductory Physics 1 Sep24-06 04:47 AM
Unsolved problem of the week Jeff Ford General Math 0 Feb24-06 12:45 PM
A messy unsolved problem pervect Special & General Relativity 23 Feb20-06 03:21 PM
Unsolved Equation kazimo Brain Teasers 7 Nov8-04 09:46 PM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image