Apples and oranges

Jimmy Snyder

There are three boxes. One contains apples only, one contains oranges only, and one contains apples and oranges. They are mislabeled. You designate one of the boxes. I will remove a single piece of fruit from it and hand it to you. From that information you will correctly label all three boxes.

Borek

Quote by Jimmy Snyder

They are mislabeled.

They are mislabeled, or they are labeled at random? What I mean is - if the box is labeled "apples" can I be sure it contains either oranges or mix, or can it contain apples as well?

Jimmy Snyder

Quote by Borek

They are mislabeled, or they are labeled at random? What I mean is - if the box is labeled "apples" can I be sure it contains either oranges or mix, or can it contain apples as well?

mislabeled

Borek

Spoiler

give me something from the box labeled apples and oranges, please

Jimmy Snyder

Wait, it's a prune. Let me get another one.

JaredJames

Smell?

If you've got an apple that smells of orange, or vice versa, that should tell you what is in the box with it.

(I have no idea what I'm talking about, only thing I could come up with).

I can see the logic you have to apply, just got to get my head around it.

JaredJames

A more serious attempt at the answer. It all comes down to the boxes being deliberately mislabelled and I've taken this to mean they cannot contain what is written.

Spoiler

I choose the Apples/Oranges box.

If you pull an apple, the oranges box must contain the apples/oranges and the apples box must contain the oranges.

If you pull an orange, the oranges box must conatin the apples and the apples box must contain the apples/oranges.

EDIT: corrected my mistake

Jimmy Snyder

It's a very simple problem. I had trouble with it because it took me a while to see the importance of the

Spoiler

mislabeling

Once that hurdle is passed the rest is easy. Borek focused attention on that detail.

JaredJames

So was my assumption regarding it correct?

Jimmy Snyder

Quote by jarednjames

So was my assumption regarding it correct?

Yes, by mislabeled, I meant that none of the boxes contain what the label says they do.

ashishsinghal

That is an easy one.

Spoiler

Take one out from both fruits container. If it is apple then the orange container will have both fruits and apple will have orange. Same method if it is orange

Similar Threads for: Apples and oranges
Thread	Forum	Replies
Apples and oranges	Linear & Abstract Algebra	9
Help- throwing apples	Introductory Physics Homework	6
Donuts oranges coconuts and an ever expanding superpositional slinky all tied togethe	Beyond the Standard Model	5

Jimmy Snyder Blog Entries: 1 Recognitions: Gold Member	Apples and oranges Tweet There are three boxes. One contains apples only, one contains oranges only, and one contains apples and oranges. They are mislabeled. You designate one of the boxes. I will remove a single piece of fruit from it and hand it to you. From that information you will correctly label all three boxes.

Borek Admin	Apples and oranges Spoiler give me something from the box labeled apples and oranges, please

JaredJames Blog Entries: 8 Recognitions: Gold Member	Smell? If you've got an apple that smells of orange, or vice versa, that should tell you what is in the box with it. (I have no idea what I'm talking about, only thing I could come up with). I can see the logic you have to apply, just got to get my head around it.

ashishsinghal	That is an easy one. Spoiler Take one out from both fruits container. If it is apple then the orange container will have both fruits and apple will have orange. Same method if it is orange