| New Reply |
Wind turbine durability |
Share Thread | Thread Tools |
| Mar19-12, 10:05 PM | #1 |
|
|
Wind turbine durability
It is a puzzle to see so many of the wind turbines that are idle.
Even in active wind farms, such as at Altamount Pass, it is usual to see at least 20% of the turbines idle. Older installations are usually idle as well. Why is this? Hydraulic turbines routinely run flawlessly for decades with very little downtime. Is it not surprising that wind turbines appear incapable of matching this? It does seem a huge economic burden to idle these units. These are expensive structures, stuffed with precision mechanisms. |
| Mar20-12, 06:53 PM | #2 |
|
1. Wind power sells for a premium. If the utility can make it cheaper with coal than the windfarm sells it to them, that's what they will do. Unless gov't is forcing them to buy it. 2. A single steam plant might have the electrical output of 500 to 1000 windmills. So you just can't afford the same level of staffing for a windmill. A one megawatt windmill makes electricity enough to sell for perhaps fifty or a hundred dollars an hour. It can't suppport the interest payments on loans to build it AND a big maintenance staff. If one is offline it's not a lot of revenue lost. Probably they wait until there's enough "Fix Me's" to justify calling out the service crew. |
| Jul19-12, 12:00 PM | #3 |
|
|
|
| Jul19-12, 08:09 PM | #4 |
|
|
Wind turbine durabilityYet that phenomenon, lots of idle turbines, is apparent wherever wind farms are found. I've seen it in several places in Europe as well. Can anyone from industry help explain what is going on? |
| Jul20-12, 07:45 AM | #5 |
Recognitions:
|
Companies don't build wind farms to make electricity. They build them to make money.
If you get a huge governmemt subsidy for building a new wind farm, and peanuts from the electricty it generates, it's not your problem that the system is "stupid". You just build it and take the money. |
| Jul20-12, 08:57 AM | #6 |
|
It's largely foreign banks financing US windfarms and transmission lines, as well as lots of other infrastructure. It draws foreign money into US which i guess makes government happy. Put on your accountant's hat - when the balance sheet no longer justifies running the darn thing because there's no production tax writeoff, you abandon it. This page says the tax credit generally goes ten years http://dsireusa.org/incentives/incen...ive_Code=US13F An older Nuke plant that's no longer paying interest on the loan to build it can make electricity for about what the windpower production tax credit amounts to. A utility that's run by accountants might do better buying an old Nuke than a windfarm. That's why gov't is mandating certain % electric generation be renewables, it creates a market for them. You need to read C Northcote Parkinson's 'Law of Delay' to become properly cynical about the oxymoron '(insert corporate or government) wisdom'. |
| Jul20-12, 09:03 AM | #7 |
|
Please dont take me for anti- green.
What we as good citizens should do is reduce our use where we can. A flat plate solar water heater will work in most of the US and heating water is a big chunk of your electric bill. Somebody neeeds to make a solar airconditioner for the sunbelt, perhaps a sealed ammonia or steam system that runs in batch mode sized for the 12 hours of sunlight. |
| Jul20-12, 12:26 PM | #8 |
|
|
|
| Jul20-12, 12:42 PM | #9 |
|
|
|
| Jul20-12, 12:51 PM | #10 |
|
|
Another relevant point: the US spills (ie throws away) 1-3% of its total wind generation because the operators occasionally find themselves in a situation where they have surplus power, but the load point and predictability are such that they can not gamble on idling a fossil plant to use the wind generation and then have the wind die. I have no idea if this explains the observation of many idle wind turbines reported above. It would not surprise me to find that, when operators are forced to idle turbines during a surplus, they concentrate the shut downs in areas of high maintenance cost, i.e. the oldest turbines.
Wind Curtailments. The above suggesting that some wind farms are built knowing that on day one of operation there is insufficient transmission to deliver peak output of the wind farm should it occur. |
| Jul20-12, 01:40 PM | #11 |
|
The way i got into it was this a friend is developing a windfarm and has courted several investors. When i tracked them they were all backed by European banks, largely Spanish , some Italian one French. Tracking the other investments on the bank's sites i found they are building toll roads, transmission lines, dams here... One almost has to go company by company. You'll notice GE is the only US manufacturer of wind turbines. Look at Vestas, Nordex, Alstrom, Siemens, and see who's financing the farms using their turbines. http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/...le-for-america http://www.sustainablebusinessoregon...t_by_2013.html this is all i could get, it's behind a subscribe-wall.. http://www.terra-genpower.com/News/A...ale-of-th.aspx Terragen i'm not sure, but they seem entwined with these guys: http://global-infra.com/ , click on their investments.. http://www.terra-genpower.com/Home.aspx i think we've achieved globalization. I'm glad i'm a theta. old jim |
| Jul20-12, 04:54 PM | #12 |
Recognitions:
|
But back to the OP's question, another issue is distributing the power form the wind farm to the consumers. That had led to silly situations in Scotlamd for eaxmple, which has good sites for onshore wind farms but low local demands for power. That has led to wind farms being built (and subsidised) that can not be run at full power because the distribution network doesn't have enough capcaity to handle the power being generated, and the distribution companes (which are separate from the generation companies, and don't have the same access to "green energy" subsidies) can't afford to fix the problem using their own finances. |
| Jul20-12, 05:06 PM | #13 |
|
|
|
| New Reply |
| Thread Tools | |
Similar Threads for: Wind turbine durability
|
||||
| Thread | Forum | Replies | ||
| Does the wind speed up after a wind turbine blade? | General Engineering | 18 | ||
| Determine the Electric Power Produced by a Wind Turbine Over a Range of Wind Speeds | Advanced Physics Homework | 5 | ||
| Wind turbine | General Engineering | 4 | ||
| Alternator for Low Wind Speed Wind Turbine. | Engineering Systems & Design | 51 | ||