image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > Physics > General Physics


Reply

image How does salt melt ice? Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Jan19-05, 04:55 AM                  #1
Mk

Mk is Offline:
Posts: 2,025
How does salt melt ice?

Of course I mean my table salt, specificly, but how does salt melt ice?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan19-05, 05:01 AM                  #2
cepheid
 
cepheid's Avatar

cepheid is Offline:
Posts: 2,254
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Helper
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Unfortunately, I do not know what physical or chemical process occurs. All I know is that salt lowers the melting point of water so that it is able to melt at lower temperatures. I've seen many icy sidewalks to which salt had been recently applied. The ice looks as though it is "dissolving" ...becoming more of a "slush". This is presumably because it is melting partially.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan19-05, 05:35 AM                  #3
gschjetne

gschjetne is Offline:
Posts: 98
From what I know about inter-molecular forces My best guess is that the sodium and chloride ions "gets in the middle" of the strong hydrogen bonds. You might think of it like the small beads in some rotating device (have no idea what it's called) designed to reduce friction.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan19-05, 05:44 AM                  #4
Mk

Mk is Offline:
Posts: 2,025
But what does reducing friction have to do with my question? The sodium and chloride bond with the hydrogen? Could you be more specific please.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan19-05, 06:06 AM                  #5
futb0l

futb0l is
Posts: n/a
http://antoine.frostburg.edu/chem/se...elts-ice.shtml
Take a look at this.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan19-05, 06:53 AM                  #6
Mk

Mk is Offline:
Posts: 2,025
And why does when you put a cup of ice with salt, frost forms on the outside of the cup from condensated water? And a cup without salt doesn't?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan19-05, 08:04 AM                  #7
poolwin2001

poolwin2001 is Offline:
Posts: 173
It is a colligative property-lowering of melting point.
it is proportional to no:moles of salt per 1000g of ice.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan19-05, 08:10 AM                  #8
spacetime

spacetime is Offline:
Posts: 119
Decrease of free energy of salt due to decrease in temperature is less than the corresponding decrease for water.

So, when salt is mixed in water, the free energy of the system decreases less with decrease in temperature than it would have decreased if water were present alone. As a result, the free energy for the corresponding solid state (to be formed if the mixture freezes) becomes lower than the free energy of pure water only at a relatively lower temperature. That is why the melting (or freezing) point decreases.



spacetime
www.geocities.com/physics_all/
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan19-05, 02:43 PM                  #9
Gonzolo

Gonzolo is
Posts: n/a
Adding to the discussion that salt also causes osmosis. Whether melting ice or causing osmosis, salt "pulls water molecules towards itself".
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan19-05, 05:00 PM                  #10
russ_watters

PF Mentor

russ_watters is Offline:
Posts: 15,188
Originally Posted by Mk
And why does when you put a cup of ice with salt, frost forms on the outside of the cup from condensated water? And a cup without salt doesn't?
Since salt lowers the freezing/melting point of water, the outside of the cup is below freezing - thus, frost.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan20-05, 06:23 AM                  #11
suman.patil

suman.patil is Offline:
Posts: 1
its actually an exothermic process
when we put salt the bonds break and also results in liberation of heat
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan20-05, 04:56 PM                  #12
Schneibster

Schneibster is Offline:
Posts: 80
First, the melting point of saltwater is much lower than fresh water. This is because the van der Waals forces between water molecules that hold the water in its solid state are weakened by the presence of the sodium+ and chloride ions that salt dissolves into in water. As a result, salt added to ice melts the ice.

Second, there is latent heat involved in the transition from the solid to the liquid state; thus, when salt is added to ice, as the ice melts, it not only loses heat to provide the latent heat of liquifaction, but it also absorbs heat from its surroundings. Thus, not only is the saltwater cooler than the ice was, even though it is now a liquid because it is still above the liquifaction temperature of salt water, it has also cooled the air around it and any solid material it might be in contact with.

So if you want to draw heat out of your ice cream, add rock salt to the ice in the outside container, and it will melt the ice and draw out the the heat!
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan20-05, 05:07 PM                  #13
jjjsarnis

jjjsarnis is Offline:
Posts: 15
does anyone know at what temperature salt stops working and the area would remain icy?
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan20-05, 06:14 PM       Last edited by Schneibster; Jan20-05 at 06:17 PM..            #14
Schneibster

Schneibster is Offline:
Posts: 80
Depends on the concentration of salt. I couldn't find a table that will give the answer to your question; this seems to go over how to approximate it. You should be able to derive the freezing point for salt water by concentration of salt from this.
  Reply With Quote
Old Jan20-05, 08:09 PM                  #15
Bystander

Bystander is Offline:
Posts: 1,305
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Helper
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Freezing point depression for water is 1.86 K/m, or thereabouts; NaCl is a dissociating solute, 2m ions/m; solubility of NaCl decreases as T decreases, something like 5.4 m at 25 C, decreasing to 4.5, if memory serves at the eutectic point (the lower limit jjjsarnis is asking for), 4.5 might be at 0 C; 4.5 X 1.86 x 2 gives us -16 or 17 C. This ain't what's observed since ion association and other non-ideal behavior in concentrations exceeding 0 m reduce the 1.86 K/m freezing point depression constant which is defined only in the limit of zero concentration.
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: How does salt melt ice?
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
How to melt ice? HK911 General Physics 41 Apr10-08 05:24 PM
Why do wires melt? i.am.lost Introductory Physics 4 Feb27-08 09:23 AM
What happens when semiconductor melt? opuktun Introductory Physics 0 Feb11-08 06:00 PM
What happens when semiconductor melt? opuktun Advanced Physics 0 Feb11-08 10:19 AM
Can wood melt if.... SleSSi Atomic, Solid State, Comp. Physics 8 May17-05 04:09 PM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image