Register to reply 
Why do you get sideband frequencies for amplitude modulation (AM)? 
Share this thread: 
#1
May1512, 06:15 PM

P: 202

I thought that the frequency was constant for AM modulation, and just the amplitude was modulated. So why are there a range of frequency's (side bands around the baseband) when the signal is plotted on a frequency domain graph?



#2
May1512, 08:45 PM

P: 3

The AM carrier frequency is constant but the modulation signal can change.
If you look at the case of modulating the AM carrier frequency (a sine wave) with a pure sine wave, the resulting AM waveform is close to what you would get if you multiplied the two sine waves. AM mixing is like multiplication. In the realm of trigonometry, the product of two sine waves can be simplified to the sum of three pure sine waves: The carrier and two side bands. So if you multiply two sine waves (carrier and modulation), you get the same result as adding three sine waves (carrier and two side band sine waves). That result, the AM waveform, can be viewed in two different ways:through mixing (multiplication) or as a sum of three sine wave (which is the frequency domain way of looking at things). 


#3
May1512, 08:54 PM

P: 3




#4
May1612, 08:45 AM

P: 589

Why do you get sideband frequencies for amplitude modulation (AM)?
Craig,
As kevlat indicates, the sidebands fall out of the trig. However, you are right in that it seems counterintuitive at first. In order to get a sense of where the other frequencies come from consider that the amplitude modulation is in the form of periodic instantaneous shifts in amplitude. Say we have a 1MHz RF carrier 1Vpeak. It periodically shifts in amplitude to 100Vpeak, and the shift occurs at the crest of the sine wave. So we have a 1MHz sinusoidal signal that at some point reaches 1V and shifts instantaneously to 100V then continues on as a sinusoid. That vertical 1V to 100V step in voltage is where the non1MHz frequency components are introduced. We will create the same frequencies that you would get from a square wave with instantaneous edges. 


#5
May1612, 09:39 AM

P: 2,537

A good rule to remember is that you cannot do ANYTHING to a sine wave without creating new frequencies.



#6
May1612, 05:38 PM

P: 4,663

See
The product of a small amplitude modulation on a carrier can be represented by [itex] \left(1+A\cos\omega_1t \right)\cos\omega_2t [/itex]. This can be rewritten as [tex] \left(1+A\cos\omega_2t \right)\cos\omega_1t=\cos\omega_1t +A\cos\omega_2t\cos\omega_1t =\cos\omega_1t + \frac{A}{2} \cos\left(\omega_1\omega_2 \right)t+\frac{A}{2} \cos\left(\omega_1+\omega_2 \right)t [/tex] So the AM modulation produces sum and difference sidebands at any amplitude modulation frequency. 


#7
Jan1514, 08:45 AM

P: 1

Hi, I'm new to the forum and also to the topic and so pardon me for maybe not doing the proper protocol. I have a followup related question. Do the sidebands frequencies exist during transmission? I mean does the transmitter actually transmits three signals at a time, the lower, upper and the carrier?



#8
Jan1514, 09:38 AM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 12,262

The process of Modulation is Non Linear  it's a sort of Multiplication  and it produces those extra frequency components (if you choose to think of it in the frequency domain). In the time domain, it looks like a carrier with a varying amplitude (the 'envelope'). That's the 'scope picture, where the frequency domain is the Spectrum Analyser picture of the same signal. Mentally hopping between time and frequency domains can be very handy. 


#9
Jan1514, 12:53 PM

P: 1,084

This is my weird intuitive view, and can't stand up to any rigorous scrutiny. (be gentle, folks)
When you measure the spectrum of a modulated sinewave you are measuring the average energy over a period of time. That makes it look like there are three distinct frequencies with related phases. Well, there are 3 distinct frequencies by any measurement methods, but if you could track instantaneous frequency (a debatable concept) you would sort of see a continuum of frequencies. But the energy between sidebands sort of cancels out when you average over an interval. Think of a sinewave. If you lower the amplitude, there is a frequency/phase discontinuity that occurs. That is, there has to be a transition that isn't exactly a sinewave. That is, or results in, "spurious" energy at different frequencies. This get more complicated when you think of FM modulation, where a continuous sweeping frequency somehow unintuitively becomes bessel sidebands. Again, it is "sort of" an "artifact" of the measurement method caused by the fact that it is an average over an interval. Don't get me wrong. This average is very real and very useful. Instantaneous frequency is tricky because a single point can't have frequency without knowledge of past and future. But, in contrast, most people don't really think about the "averaging" occuring in a spectrum analysis filter (be it FFT, DFT, Fourier based or whatever). 


#10
Jan1514, 01:29 PM

PF Gold
P: 201



#11
Jan1514, 03:48 PM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 12,262




#12
Jan1514, 03:54 PM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 12,262

(I love the way that the "Bessel sidebands" just pop out of 'intuition'. They emerge from a pretty difficult bit of Fourier Transform and I don't think that's very intuitive at all) 


#13
Jan1614, 12:10 AM

P: 1,084

Well, your reading skills could use some honing. I absolutely did say unintuitive. And, what I am saying is actually not so far off as you seem to think. It is not a "soup of buzzwords" as you insultingly state (you do that sort of thing a lot, it seems). There is actually some real stuff there regarding instantaneous frequency that you obviously do not understand.
Think about narrowband FM and why it appears to have 2 sidebands, yet is made by a continuously sweeping VCO. 


#14
Jan1614, 04:40 AM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 12,262

My problem with your post is that it contains a lot of correct words and phrases 'but not in the right order'  to quote Eric Morcambe, in his sketch with Andre Previn. You could look at the 'Rules and Guidelines', to be found in the 'site info' at the top of this page. Greg Bernhardt makes it quite clear what the purpose of the site is and it is not to promote personal and nonstandard views. Your initial post starts with an excuse for 'weird and intuitive' views and that is just what they are. I merely confirmed that. Many of the ideas in your post are, at best confusing and certainly cannot be found in mainstream text books (in that order). Mr Fourier went to a lot of trouble to provide a way of relating time and frequency domains (defining them properly). You don't need to "think about" FM. You just write out the time domain formula and do the transform and you get the spectrum. We are lucky that Mr Bessel sorted out the integration for us. It may be difficult to accept that some things are not explicable by waving arms. I do understand that "instantaneous frequency" is, in fact, an oxymoron and the term, whilst in common enough use, needs a lot of qualification before it can be used in a valid way. 


#15
Jan1614, 10:29 AM

P: 1,084

Good response.
I'll look around and see if I can find somthing more rigourous that addresses this. I've seen stuff in the past, but it didn't pop out when I did my search. You are obviously quite happy not trying to understand how a sweeping frequency becomes 2 sidebands. It just is. 


#17
Jan1614, 02:50 PM

Sci Advisor
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 12,262

Anything you need to 'explain' all this to me is available in a dozen well know books on communications theory and signal analysis. Google tends to throw up a lot of less rigorous stuff  which is why PF can be a bit huffy about what's available on the Web. 


#18
Jan2314, 12:17 AM

P: 1

meBigGuy actually provided a very good visual of what is actually going on. I've always had trouble understanding why AM produced sidebands, and accepting the math just wasn't cutting it. I'm a visual person. This quote right here: As for the "soup of buzzwords" jab, I fail to see what you're talking about. Thanks meBigGuy, very simple and to the point. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Using ring modulator for generation of double sideband full carrier amplitude modulat  Electrical Engineering  0  
Amplitude modulation  General Physics  2  
Amplitude Modulation  General Physics  1  
Amplitude modulation  Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework  2  
Modulation in high frequencies and antennas  Electrical Engineering  5 