
#1
Jun812, 05:27 AM

P: 4

Consider gas here as idea gas.
The gas expands from state 1: P1, V1 and T1 to state 2: P2, V2, and T1 using two different paths: Path A: reversible expansion at constant T Path B: irreversible expansion by releasing the gas to a vacuum to achieve V2 at adiabatic condition. Thing I confuse: consider that enthalpy as a state function: H1 to H2 from state 1 to state 2. for reversible path A: dU = q + w. dU = 0. so q=w. The system needs some q from surrounding to perform w. and dH = q. H2 = H1 + dH = H1 + q. but for Path B: w=0, q=0, dU=0. dH=0. So, H2 = H1. Why? my question is enthalpy can't be same for path B, because enthalpy is a state function which is independent from its path. 



#2
Jun812, 07:16 AM

P: 5,462

How did you arrive at w = 0 for the second expansion?
Don't forget that full expansion into a vacuum implies that P2 = 0 & V2 = ∞ The work done is pv work which is the area in the pv indicator diagram shown. Between some point C at P3, V3 (say 1 atmosphere) and vacuum (unattainable) the work is shown by the hatched diagram. If you take it all the way to infinity as shown the work is the area under the whole graph. You need to integrate an equation of state for the gas to obtain this figure. 



#3
Jun812, 07:20 AM

P: 4

Thanks for your reply
the V2 in path B is assumed equal to V2 in path A. therefore, Path B and Path A could both reach a same state, P2, V2, and T1. the vacuum part is V2V1, it's like lift a barrier and let the gas go to extra V2V1 part and reach V2. I don't want V2 go infinite. 



#4
Jun812, 09:12 AM

P: 5,462

enthalpy as a state function
The point of state variables is that at any state there is one and only one value available to each state variable.
So to compare enthapies, start and end points have to be the same for both processes. You started well by noting this. At every point on each path there will be a well defined P and V. You didn't answer the question about why you think w = 0 for the adiabatic irreversible path. 



#5
Jun812, 09:47 AM

P: 4

Hi Studiot,
Thanks for the discussion. To answer your quesion: "why you think w = 0 for the adiabatic irreversible path" my path B is a free expansion path. a free expansion path does zero work. see Free_expansion in wikipedia. And actually, I only try to specify two variables P and V, where T is kept constant as T1. sorry for not clear. 



#6
Jun812, 10:12 AM

P: 5,462

Wiki also says




#7
Jun812, 10:21 AM

P: 4

apparently, the enthalpy change for a free expansion is zero. However, by taking another reversible Path A at constant T. the enthalpy change is not zero. The thing is the start state (P1, V1, T1), end state (P2, V2, T1) of Path A and B are exactly the same. I want to expect the same enthalpy change for path A and B. however, this is not the case. This confuses me a lot if we take enthalpy as a state function, who is independent of the paths. 



#8
Jun812, 11:46 AM

P: 5,462

OK what you are asking about is known as Joules experiment.
The second part of this might help your question (and save me a lot of writing). http://wikieducator.org/The1stLawofT...ynamicsLesson2 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Why is enthalpy a function of Temperature and Pressure?  Classical Physics  1  
Enthalpy and Heat State Functions  Classical Physics  1  
State Functions and Order of Diff and Enthalpy  Classical Physics  0  
enthalpy of reaction as function of the equilibrium constant kp  Classical Physics  0  
Do a state function be multuvalued function  Classical Physics  14 