Register to reply

Why is Entropy a concave function of internal energy?

by Wentu
Tags: entropy, microstates, temperature
Share this thread:
Jan14-13, 07:20 AM
P: 12

I may well be all wrong about this but I am trying to understand from a microscopic point of view why Entropy is a concave function of internal energy. I found this in the following .pdf:

I started from this wikipedia article and i understand why, if the particles composing the system have a limited number of available energy levels, then S(E) first increases and then decreases.

But saying that S(E) is concave should mean:
- when the temperature is T1, if i give a dE to the system its entropy increases of dS1
- when the tempereture is T2>T1, if I give the same dE to the system, its Entropy increases only of dS2 < dS1

I cannot see this with single particles.
If I have N particles in their lowest energy state there is only one microstate: all the particles are still.
If I give to this system the tiniest possible amount of energy, it will be taken by just one of the particle, so the possible microstates are N.
If I add another dE, the possible microstates should be N + N(N-1) = N^2 ... that is or one particle gets both dE or two different particles get it. Every time I add a dE I should increase the power of N.
Now, if the entropy is somehow proportional to the logarithm of the number of microstates, I should get S proportional to K ln(N^E), that is, something that is proportianl to E... taht is, no concavity

I am sure I am getting all this wrong... could you please help me understand this?

Thank You

Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on
IHEP in China has ambitions for Higgs factory
The physics of lead guitar playing
The birth of topological spintronics
Jan14-13, 07:27 AM
Sci Advisor
P: 3,552
Quote Quote by Wentu View Post
If I add another dE, the possible microstates should be N + N(N-1) = N^2 .
Where do you get the first N on the left hand side from?
Jan14-13, 07:49 AM
P: 12
The first N is for a single particle having 2*dE energy and all other particles ground energy

Jan14-13, 08:08 AM
Sci Advisor
P: 3,552
Why is Entropy a concave function of internal energy?

Ah, ok. Shouldn't the second term should rather read N(N-1)/2?
Jan14-13, 08:14 AM
P: 12
You are right... I was considering distinguishble particles but this isn't enough, so yes, the term should be divided by 2. I wonder if this is enough to change the behaviour from linear to less-than-linear... I think the number of microstates still increases as a power with the increasing of E... but again, i could be all wrong


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Internal energy and thermodynamic entropy Classical Physics 7
Entropy and internal energy Introductory Physics Homework 6
Entropy, Adiabatic Conditions and Internal Energy Introductory Physics Homework 0
Internal energy vs. Enthalpy vs. Entropy Advanced Physics Homework 6