
#1
Feb813, 06:16 PM

P: 6

How exactly does radius affect centripetal acceleration? In one formula we have (a=v^2/r) which implies inversely proportional, while in the other we have (a=(w^2)*r) which implies directly proportional. I understand that increasing r increases velocity (v=w*r) which means the right answer is increasing r increases acceleration, however how do we justify that increasing r would decrease a in the formula (a=v^2/r)?
Also how can I intuitively makes sense of this? Does increasing r not mean that the same velocity has more time to change (as Khan Academy states at 3:294:32) > http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UmiotSKSRvw This MIT lecture at 5:406:21, states that the acceleration would decrease as radius decreases. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Otmg0...88ECB2FF119649 So which is it ? They seem to be saying opposite things. Am I misunderstanding something? p.s. this site is amazing that people contribute their time and knowledge for free to help someone else they will never meet in their life. Truly thank you from one sentient being to another. 



#2
Feb813, 06:27 PM

HW Helper
P: 3,337

well, it depends if you want to hold omega fixed, or velocity fixed. The idea is that the centripetal acceleration must be a specific value, so that a perfect circle is made. So to keep to that requirement, if you have a larger radius, you must have a smaller omega. And equivalently, you must have a larger velocity.




#3
Feb1113, 05:25 AM

P: 34

For a given angular rotational frequency, the centripetal acceleration acting on the point is proportional to r, as your second equation says. The reason your first equation seems to disagree is it because it contains v, the velocity of the specific point you are looking at. But the velocity of that point also depends on its distance from r, from the equation v = wr. So when you make r bigger, you are also making v bigger. Substitute v=wr into your first equation and you will see that both are saying the same thing. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Do uniform circular motion and nonuniform circular motion have same formula for a?  Classical Physics  2  
Vertical circular motion in uniform circular motion  Introductory Physics Homework  3  
Uniform circular motion  plane in a circular arc  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
Radius of the path of an accelerating object in uniform Circular motion  Introductory Physics Homework  4  
Uniform Circular Motion, Rotational Motion, Torque, and Inertia  General Physics  1 