Register to reply

Mechanical or Electrical Problem?

by Ryuk1990
Tags: electrical, mechanical
Share this thread:
Ryuk1990
#1
Feb11-13, 10:44 PM
P: 157
Last summer, I was taking apart a fan because it wasn't working. It turned as I expected that it was a burned out motor.

Now one of my co-workers was a little upset at me because I had called it an electrical problem or failure. He said a burned out motor is a mechanical failure.

Was he right?
Phys.Org News Partner Engineering news on Phys.org
Comfortable climate indoors with porous glass
Crash-testing rivets
Customized surface inspection
UniverseAlien
#2
Feb12-13, 06:24 AM
P: 3
I call it, mechanical problem, due to electrical failure.
berkeman
#3
Feb12-13, 12:00 PM
Mentor
berkeman's Avatar
P: 40,740
Quote Quote by Ryuk1990 View Post
Last summer, I was taking apart a fan because it wasn't working. It turned as I expected that it was a burned out motor.

Now one of my co-workers was a little upset at me because I had called it an electrical problem or failure. He said a burned out motor is a mechanical failure.

Was he right?
It could be either. If the fan stuck for some reason, that can cause the motor to burn out. So a mechanical failure like a stuck bearing can cause the electrical failure of the windings shorting out.

Or the windings can just short out on their own (as the motor gets old and the insulation on the windings gets less effective), so that's an electrical failure.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Mechanical vs Electrical (Help!) Career Guidance 5
Mechanical vs Electrical Academic Guidance 3
Electrical or Mechanical. Career Guidance 3
Electrical or Mechanical Engineer Academic Guidance 2
Mechanical or Electrical? Academic Guidance 8